#protection
1 messages · Page 2060 of 1
guys curious about your thoughts on this. when I first started playing prot I felt quite a bit weaker than my brew monk, but now that both are @ 340 ish ilvl with good itemization I feel so much stronger on warrior. I almost get the impression that warriors scale better than other tanks with good traits/gear, at least when compared to my monk. I feel like survivability per ilvl didnt increase as much on monk nearly as much as it did with warrior. shield block feels amazing suddenly. also the damage is incredible for a tank with tclap spam so I like that. curious about others thoughts on scaling
by stronger on warrior I dont mean necessarily compared to brew, I mean compared to being 310/320 ilvl, relative to the monk when he gained similar ilvls
Well I think monk is special in that way, I never played it so it's just my general thought, since stagger will always be the same. You don't suddenly feel that you midigate much more
also magic damage is rough at times still, but I put a point in bloodsport and it seems to be helping with IP absorbs on magic
But I do think prot will make a "comeback" as In people will start to notice how strong we actually are
I could be wrong though
I feel very strong with being able to have plenty of rage for IP, I just wish it wasnt on the GCD.
and IP itself feels strong mitigation wise
Same
right nome, stagger is great but scales less by its nature, whereas at my current ilvl shield block makes me feel almost immune to damage at times
Warriors/Paladins take a lot less damage compared to a monk but are much more susceptible to dying in a short burst from a single mistake.
What is "better" depends on the type of content you are doing
both warrior and monk are very different, where a Prot warrior will excel in massive accidental trashpulls with a lot of defensives and damage reduction, a monk will struggle, whereas on a sustained heavy physical damage on boss, monk will severely outperform
I suspect the scaling of ShBlock is such now that gaining a lot of STR in a short period of time is whats making it feel amazing for me suddenly
havent looked into the exact math of the reworked block mechanics
Blocking is mostly depending on the item level of your shield
As iirc meiffert once said, monk is prot warri in cruise control mode
That wasn't me 😃
Ah well. Was someone yellow
kinda right, monk is tbh pretty dumb to play and my monk main is 345 atm
As monk you can't just not midigate
actually Im going to echo sickness and say that on huge trash pulls, my monk actually feels squisher at 340 than my warrior
As warri you can fuck up
the real strenght of monk is like DK, the 100% AM uptime
I mean we have that
as prot, pally, dh etc
press ISB, you have that
but I find that I can do one of two things, 1. "Weave" IP in between ShBl to offset the uptimes to be at 100%, or if I have huge incoming physical damage, used 2/3 ShBl in a row followed by some IP spam
With IP, in between, is really strong
Can prot use fist weapon to use all abilities like back in wod or it's not counted?
I frankly am not having periods where I dont have 100% uptime on AM atm, that will likely change in M+ when Ip gets taken off in a global at times
Yes you can, just get a fist weapon with str is the hard part
I just got a WQ with it
and i remember when i fucked up and bought dagger instead of 1h sword week ago
dont understand the IP nerf + on the GCD
could not use revenge
they could just have nerfed the value
they added a gcd to just about every tank, it's not news that they wanted to slow down the pace
which is what the gcd does
the way IPs are stacking now and demo off CD as much as it is, as well as a point in the bloodsport trait, my IPs are making me feel quite safe
its a lot more noticeable on prot, thyme
except monk
adding a GCD for some spell is one thing, putting it on your AM is another
does anyone know if you genrate rage when hit by a cast ? cause it feels like you dont get any rage
for uber cup-drooling brew spam
no more scandalous than IP is imo
true
anyways all this to say Im feeling a lot more confident in the face of the folks who laughed at me when I told them I intended to do M+ as prot
so well see how I feel after trying some +4 keys
hopefully higher
fingers crossed
tanking should be good, depends on your group
very true
also the self sustain traits on az armor are fantastic
even the minor sustain added to warriors mitigation is so good
more for open world stuff than dungeons
had a mate play vampiric speed (?) on his tank monk, insane self healing on trash
same im only 20 ^^
Won't be seeing t3 traits for a while when m+ comes out
385 needs like what 28 or 29 for 3rd row
Hm... Are large raids inconvenienced on Mother? Guides are suggesting 3 chars run through the walls at a time, that will take a while with 30 raiders
so i have been leveling as prot doing dungeons , first warrior
i main a dh tank , i got a question
on the dh i have a fairly low cd on my jump , so i can actually use it on most pulls (sometime even twice) , how am i supposed to "start" a pull as prot warr when heroic leap is on cd?
charge
avatar, charge, sb
Tests were made with ilvl 320 on normal
You should be safe with like 5 people going in at once NP
If not more
so charge , avatar and thunderclap for a first burst of agro and move from there?
Or Avatar charge Tc Demo revenge
I usually just go with charge demo TC Avatar SB IP
And heroic leap when I have enough rage before the pull
Ye it is
im also really rage starved , i dont know if im using revenge too often (outside of free procs) but i find myself really low on rage to keep sb / ip up
combination of that and prob missing a lot of SSs
rage should overflow in trashpulls, you're doing too much revenge i'd say
and i legit dont understand how IP is on the GCD , its so awkward to use
Idk im fine with IP
It's awkward to start a pull by shouting 3 times though
Avatar Demo IP
That is awkward
my mag'har screaming to death during trash
im fine with all the other skills on gcd but IP always feels weird to use , w/e i guess i need more experience
the icy veins talents in the pinned msg, is still up to date?
yes
what's weird is when you ava, you can't effectively use your TC with all the GCD
that's where IP is, i feel, breaking my rotation
I often just don't feel the kit is cohesive. That's a good example of it, where you can't use IP with TC with proper effective play. Feel like you are always just borking something
Or the various stuff on pull so lose out on SS and therefore feel SB is losing something, but that's just how we work, which isnt ideal
what are you guys running as tier 5 talent?
rumbling
Same, you can fear and clap to break if need the aoe interrupt after Shockwave
mb blizz will do something on the first patch after the raid
not normal when you have to use your spells before pulling bc you won't have time to protect yourself otherwise
could say it's the same for dps as prepull but idk, doesnt feel the same as tank imo
Do dps prepull like that? Prepot yes but yeah
Some specs will then, Ret pops wings a few globals in to get inquisition going first
Feels so wonky for prot war mainly because you feel like wasting deafening crash value. At least that's the case for me
well you have let's say 2.2 secs CD on TC
you use it, then IP, SS, just this you're at 3 seconds GCD
anything you do further is time wasted on your next TC which is already available
Problems worse during Ava too
The cooldown of Thunderclap is always 4 GCDs (and 2 GCDs during Unstoppable Force.
(The cooldown is reduced by haste at the same rate as GCD)
Other tanks' secondary AM are also on gcd, but none of them are used as often as IP so it feels bad
While others dont
Yeah, if it was significantly larger, randomly going to say 4 times, but had the 1.3 cap still, so recast was much less. Might make it feel better
Duration could be slightly improved too
Yeah when I said 2 secs CD, i mean under Ava
4 times cap wouldn't help, currently it runs out more often cuz of duration and not amount
Well, it runs out on duration because we outgear the current content (m0s)
It'll get stripped faster on raids/m+
Ofc
I wonder if it will be the same as legion, like stack up rage to pop an IP which get destroyed in 1 or 2 autos
Usually it won't unless it's a big magic hit or mechanic
You have to take upwards of 50k in a single hit for it to get chewed through in 1 attack which is quite huge
right, + supposedly you'll have shield block up if such a hit is coming
Seems like a valid number to get chewed in a couple globals on a higher key maybe
Not in 1 or 2 autos but the scenario is the same from our side and IP usage/feel
we have a shamy in raid, and we love her mastery
my RL is weird and switched from disco legion to rsham in bfa ^^
And Sulphate (our Raid Leader) was a Holy pala the whole Legion and wanted to play disc this time
guys. Its darkmoon a good trinket por prot warrior to start uldir ?
bis defensively iirc
thanks! I read guides but each one say a different thing 😃
pre-raid i mean
Really good and Really cheap (compared to others)
then after launch, there's one on a WB iirc
mind if I drop the whole roster?
even 2 tank warr is not a good idea
i like having diversity in terms of tanking classes
I asked for the double tank warr
oh rly ?
because our Prot pala left the guild
because she wanted to join an all swedish guild
well im main BrM and my mate is blood, that's our comp
he compensates my flaws
double warr you'll have the same flaws
no magic damage mitigation is our major flaw right?
except the 20% from spell reflec I guess
tbh i didnt look much at raid strat yet, but it reminds me of Vari MM where as a monk it was extrememy difficult to perform as BDK, pally's and DHs as a main tank
I had to be the rotation guy for the debuff bc they main tanked the boss much better than myself
tbh we have a monk that has tank offspec because he was tanking dungeons start of bfa
once you get the feel of it, I find tanking less stressful tbh
it's more responsibility
it's different tbh, every role has its obligation
I am really lazy tbh 😛
because I am leading guild dungeons groups and it is easier having matters in your own hands
tanking is difficult to get in because of appreciation of the role, tbh I was scared to start tanking bc it implies responsiblities
True @sick sentinel
you lead the grp
Yeah
but you should know that there is no better time to start tanking than an early xpac
Just expected to have more knowledge but a little communication goes a long way and very true about expac starts being a learning time for all
also, I do dungeons almost exclusively with guildies
so we are on discord like 90% of the time
tanking is great also when pugging like for example the totem boss of atal dazar
Even though what we say the most is "insert any curse word, I pulled "
you're "you go on this totem, you focus this one, rogue the last" etc
fathom or blockades?
Blockades has 1/4th the price of fathoms
and it is the best pre-raid trinket
and it also gives you Some kind of healing (although minimal)
well it was 50 k on my realm and I bought each card individually and it cost me 36k
GET IT
Been playing with the trinket that drop 2nd boss of Sethraliss that spread poison In a cone in front of you
Dmg is so insane when ava's popped up
do multiple deafening crash traits stack?
The damage stacks but not the duration
@formal kayak One trait is enough.
yeah it's just behind TC on trash where ava is popped
only downside is the channelling time, you have to pop a SB and/or IP to be safe
Today at 8:46 AM
@Achiron One trait is enough.```
yeah but I have two because of item level
was using the shield slam one before
is the block tooltip IG bugged in his display ?
i have a "blocking reduces damage of an attack by 3622.00%"
I want to get Azerite veins so much
but it is in shit outer pieces
so only from uldir and exalted with champions :/
Well I got insane shoulders from WQ with Iron fortress and azerite veins
And using chest from underrot isn't half bad
So I can use double AV if I want to
well my ideal is DC and 2 Brace for impact with at least one AV
brace for impact is amaz
but its so wierd to play w/o that one DC , you just gotta have it so good.
esp. during avatar stomp-session
the helm from underrot has iron fortress and azerite veins if you'd like
so im totally playing unoptimal.. but its brought me renewed fun into my prot war
and i mean as long as im not dying, im doing quite alright as a tank lol
and the healers have no complaints either
if healers arent complaining, and you say you play suboptimally
either you do too easy content, or you actually dont play suboptimally
Hmmm nah I agree with him, I feel I play sub optimally a bunch but it's fine with m0
The more the content presses me the more optimally I play though , I just lazy/unfocus when it's easy
Discord tank ranking: Monk>Dk>Druid>Paladin>war>DH. Its true or false?
wat
for waht?
m+, raids?
which encounters?
what is it based on?
some tanks can do much better in specific fights
Raids and m+
thats a real thumb suck
well by suboptimally i mean i just dont feel like using BV
and right now all i can do M0 since m+ isn't out and neither is uldir
monk and bear are the safe picks for raiding
as always
if u want to watch netflix during progression
for m+, it'll prob be dk, dh then rest
although ultimately, if you come here asking that question, that means that you arent in a guild where it matters
Nope. For nm/hc its ok...
for nm/hc it wont matter at all
i think it'll be same pattern as legion
in that regard
I've recently gone as dps to a few runs to see how other tanks do it, and seen well geared monks and bears get tricked into oblivion somehow even just m0
Trucked even
they must not be very good
But those tanks have a serious limit to not being good enough for a floor
Like I'm fairly sure a relatively well aimed facesmash will get your basics going
well, bears arent amazing at dungeons
and monks that play well are kiting more than facetanking
I figured defensively they would be ok with 100% uptime
meaningless
their self heal is small
and they are horrendous vs magic
like, anything
Some Info on Mytic+ for you guys
Mythic+ Rewards
Keystone Level End of Dungeon Weekly Chest Azerite Armor from Weekly Chest
Mythic 2 345 355 340
Mythic 3 345 355 340
Mythic 4 350 360 355
Mythic 5 355 360 355
Mythic 6 355 365 355
Mythic 7 360 370 370
Mythic 8 365 370 370
Mythic 9 365 375 370
Mythic 10+ 370 380 385
Mythic+ Number of Affixes
Keystone Level # Affixes
Mythic 0 0
Mythic 2 1
Mythic 4 2
Mythic 7 3
Mythic 10+ 4
Mythic+ Affix List
https://www.wowhead.com/affixes
-- Mythic +2
Fortified
Tyrannical
-- Mythic +4
Sanguine
Skittish
Necrotic
Bursting
Volcanic
Teeming
Raging
-- Mythic +7
Explosive
Quaking
Grievous
-- Mythic +10
Infested
Mythic+ Dungeon List by Time
01. The Underrot - 30:00 min
02. Freehold - 30:00 min
03. Tol Dagor - 33:00 min
04. Temple of Sethraliss - 33:00 min
05. King’s Rest - 33:00 min
06. Atal’Dazar - 39:00 min
07. Shrine of the Storm - 39:00 min
08. MOTHERLODE!! - 39:00 min
09. Siege of Boralus - 39:00 min
10. Waycrest Manor - 39:00 min
I hadn't seen times tbf, not that I've checked it yet
KR is pretty quick. Just compressed difficulty
well, luckily i wont pug
but i want to see ppl underestimating m+
they'll pull 2 packs on +2
then get pranked
That'll be me
Well I'll do it on my paladin first then lol
Has any of you guys an info on the weekly chest and war-/timeforge? Azerite Armour cannot war-/titanforge. But I read that weapons cannot roll war-/titanforge in the weekly chest aswell. True or False?
I understand there's a cap so they don't exceed 385
i do looooove /s the fact that u get 1-3 items
On anything that can
so someoen might have 3 items after 3 weeks
and somneone else 9
:))))))))))))))))))))))))
Engaging gameplay
and i will be that guy wiuth 3 items after 3 resets
I'm wondering how difficult a plus 10 will be week 1
That's a large ilvl gap
Although I suspect the 7/8/9 in time will be harder than just finishing the 10
+10 will be like
progressing m boss
or worse
+10 on beta with 370 gear was already challenging
Dunno, no timers so surely it's just a case of committing to pushing through
what do you mean no timers
Isn't the weekly chest based on completion not within time limit , been on break too long to remdmber
Only the keystone upgrades are time based
In my own world it was
But yeah that's why I think the keystone to upgrade to a 10 might be harder than the 10 itself
exactly
He says underestimating infested
noice
NOOOOO
I GOT 340 AZERITE SHOULDERS BUT I LOSE MY DC TRAIT
fuuuuuuuu
WTB helm with DC
This is why bags are dying
Gotta carry a grummles worth of shit with you for a swap around
mmhmm
Exactly what blizzard didn't want they claimed when making ilvl king
Along with the whole low stuff worse etc
It's not that bad tbh
I'm carrying like what, 10 pieces currently
And when you upgrade to 385s it will be empty for a while again
Yeah for real, compared to legion carrying a bunch of legendaries, trinkets, m+ avoidance/speed sets
Yeah but now you get more choice 😂
👀
@next goblet grind your rep with champions to exalted, the helmet has the DC trait
You lost me at grind rep. I just finished that...sort of
Still need my exalted HB for true warrior race and probably future quests
And the coa grind is ongoing on alt 
Hey guys, how much is avoidance worth it? Atm I got 3 x 340 rings and idk which ones I should use:
- 193 stamina 171 haste 181 mastery
- 193 stamina 236 versa 116 mastery + gem
- 193 stamina 201 crit 151 mastery 60 avoidance
usually I'd use number 1 and 2, but idk how much the 60 avoidance is worth
check the stat priorities in the pins my dude
avoidance doesnt worth dropping better stats or sockets
tldr 1-2 defensively, 1-3 for dps
its nice to have, i wouldnt actively try to get it
and they nerfed avoidance speed leech in bfa you dont get much from them like you did in legion
@amber siren I did check the stat prio in the icy veins guide but there was nothing about avoidance there unless I missed it
none of the tertiary stats are worth anything
you can't stack them reliably
and they barely give much anymore
I see
that's what i was wondering; if it's worth losing some other stats for or not
thanks for the answers
Nah it's a happy bonus if it happens
Don't use them in decision making
Leech maybe worth something for healers still? But doubtful and not worth on rest
@undone sun are you sleeping?
hey would u guys rather use jes on 340 or a gilded loa figurine on 350 im a bit unsure guide says 15+ilvl for the other trinkets
What's an easy mythic to tank? Im a little undergeared. Did Freehold and seige of boralus sof ar
ataldazar
cool thx
ilvl wins out mostly on pieces with str/armor on them @stoic kite
i think rings you try to itemize better to an extent
I thought so. I got 355 legs from Freehold o.o master crit though
actually mastery haste but mastery is the bigger number
i feel like i take no damage since i use shield block in fights
pretty usefull spell
I still take a lot of dmg 😦
sometimes I get trigger happy on revenge
or dump all into IP
yeah i'm trying to not spam revenge now
survavibility is really good now
underot and the dungeon with chtulu felt liek a breeze
thought on lingering sporepod ?
if u got high ilvl, the STR is good, the effect is negligible
i was adjusting some weak auras and just realized my shield block keybind had shield slam on it instead
seems like ive done 3 weeks of mythics without shield block
very nice
340 sporepod or https://i.imgur.com/FBhOkQx.png
and i never use the button active
as i forget
macro it in
Should I do str or stam gems
really like the maccro will shoot it on my target without me focusing it ?
i been using haste gems
oh good idea
also is there a way to make it more obvious if I lost agro
the nameplates are kinda small
i can see them glow sometimes if I lose it
Macro to avatar. It places a ground target
I have blood fury on bars still too so if avatar is popped earlier due to am I can see and hit the macro again for missiles n blood fury
Hey guys i need a azerite trait ranking or something what is better avoidance with life leech or a chance of mastery proc
or or or
Elv or any nameplate add-on seem fine out the box flash means getting close and goes red if lose it
Icy veins has it
It's basically take a specific 2 or 3 otherwise go for the stats boost
Although winds procs a lot so not bad
you all prefer arms or fury as you roffspec? why?
Arms, it's better
Fury is pretty fun but feels super spammy
I'm happy with either so I just play the stronger spec
I guess not needing to maintain 2 up-to-date weapons is nice also
Fury is way too button mashy for me tbh
Hail!
I got 2 ?’s
- Is it fun to protecc atm?
- Is it any difficult in m+Os?
Yea, no
arms is much higher dps over fury too
and you can make a marco to cause ground effects to be targetted on your person right under you, or as a "mouse over mode" to spawn on your mouse, and idk but possibly on your target as well
Just leave it as default it's useful being able to target just put /use 13 /use 14 into macro with avatar n racial
@sick sentinel Sporepod is v bad
"much higher" if less than 10% is that then sure
would you use 340 rezans gleaming eye over 340 socketed ritual bandages?
rezans probably, bandages look like they're awful
Is the tuning patch tomorrow?
I guess? I mean, it's the raid release as well
I'd say a week after raid release
or did they talk about a tuning happening that I missed ?
Nothing that I'd know, but i'm usually bad at reading sun-wed news
they said a week after Raid release.
Next week it is then
Tuning is always after raid release, maybe even weeks after.
There will be a tuning pass tomorrow (pretty sure) and then a sizeable one on the 11th
Outside of outliers, I seriously doubt there will be major tuning once Mythic opens
when you see item upgrade from a blue WQ item and its a prismatic socket 😦
Hmmmmm
So 5.5k DPS single target
In prot
Don't even know if that's decent
@muted crane @uneven mason they already said tuning is going to occur next reset when mythic opens
quyestion
im confused
about things
lets say i unlock a new shoulder power
does that mean ive unlocked it on my fury and prot shoulders
cause i use 2 different ones
or do i gotta pick one shoulder piece to upgrade?
wut
You can only have one power active at a time, per piece, per ring
but like
yea 5k as prot is what i do lol
see im still confused
Each azerite piece has a level it requires to unlock it says what it is
i have 2 different shoulder azerite pieces. one for fury one for prot
if i unlock a inner trait for fury
@pulsar drift what ilvl are you??
do i unlock it for prot too
no
You unlock it by AP lvl you got.
It literally depends on the piece
If both pieces require the same AP level
Ok. So on the tool tip for the item
It doesnt matter what ilvl items are
^^^^^
Its the level of your neck AP
That’s what we are talking about
i unlocked an inner trait on prot now im goin furyh
its letting me do one on fury too
thats all i was curious about
I see @chilly brook is a man of culture, as well. Hiding his shoulders for Saurfang
im neck level 19 now is that average
@chilly brook ilvl 340 as prot
I mean the answer to your question is just because you unlock an inner trait doesn't mean you unlock it on other gear it's all down to tooltip
but if botrh are the same ilvl..
doesn't matter
Forget about the item level
If your prot shoulders unlock traits at 15, 17 and 21
ok 😦
And your fury shoulders do that as well
i thought itd be all standardized
You will "put" traits im both
lul blizz standardize
If your AP lvl is high enough
The same company that said ilvl/mainstat over all and then you have arms where secondary stats are way more important
I’m hoping the next tier of gear has way more secondaries. It’s brutal
Or reduce the pool- like clip vers or mastery. In the post squish world, having both seems redundant
so what that mean when a ilvl 350 azerite drops it will be a stat stick lol cuz u cant use the azertite on it
It means depending on traits available might not be an upgrade
what in the world?
@sick sentinel you sure I'm a man of culture? :kappa
Panda race best race
i agree
@junior ivy sometimes you can get a purple warforge from wq's. That's all i can think of right now.
true i forgot about wq rewards
You can also find a good leveling guide on wow-professions.com
im dreading leveling engineering
i know it's gonna suck
so far ive done fishing, cooking and archeology
god I wish the 355 azerite piece from CoA had deafening crash on it
tfw it sucks for..every warrior spec 
but ilvl is king right 😛
to get into groups, worth jackshit otherwiose
I can't use the 355 helmet on prot cus i'll lose deafening crash otherwise i'd be using 3 right now
hell, I use a 340 azerite piece JUST for ilvl for lfgs
My shield luck has been siphoned off into my trinket luck it seems. I have a 350 briny barnacle, 350 venom spray thing, and a 350 of the thing from WQ today that summons a Dino ally. And a blockades. No idea which two to use so I'm just trying em all out.
LUL just had 3 anchor weeds on 1 minimap o.O
I've still yet to get a single 350/355 titanforge in a mythic
I've done... like 18 total on my warrior and 5 on my guardian
lol
30 here. No 355 TF
yet I have a friend who has done one week of mythics and has 7 355 pieces
i got a 355 tf ring from one, thats about it, another WF
check all the 340s:
Got a titanfoged wrist Ilv 355 from last boss Atal' Dazar on heroic mode.
yeah, I've seen lots of TF in heroics - on my druid yesterday in a heroic I saw three 355 TF pieces - and I got 325 azerite gear
lol
the horn of valor from HOV titanforged 55 item levels for me once
lol
didnt use it though
Oh that reeminds
i went and soloed withered jim otherr day and got my Archano Crystal
better late then never!
think thats as far as ill get this week
haha GJ!
das a lotta 355
what an ugly looking gear
wish i had that many 355
Y’all think there’s any chance for some prot buffs in the next week?
what buffs u think prot needs?
IP off the gcd
More likely to see a UF nerf than any real buffs
^
IP off gcd would be a massive QOL change
I'd remind you that Blizz doesn't make significant gameplay changes mid-expac, but 7.1.5 and 7.2.5 happened

UF nerf?
Prot doesnt need buffs.
would expect a nerf too on UF
Yeah why nerf it?
Yeah, UF nerf I would expect though too.
It's always your top DPS ability by large margin if you play right. Single or aoe.
ah so theyll remove the thing prot warr has a niche for
no reason to bring to m+ at all then
Even overshadowing shield slam.
I waste so many procs personally
revenge & SS
just bc TC is way too strong and needed in an AoE situation
Same, skipping SS procs during avatar still trips me up
Interesting, preach just posted a Prot warrior video
I honestly expect a 25-50% UF nerf
50% dmg 50% CD R
Anyone have good stat weights for Prot war?
I just wish they'd raise the damn IP cap
do you guys think M+ will have a fixed pattern, especially on dg that have different path each week
?*
IP cap is fine. Just get better gear.
Doesnt need to be OP high beginning of expansion.
Full rage, max IP, revenge proc, ss up. Could raise the cap a little bit...
Mindset: Survivability or DPS. You dont have to chase every procc.
Nothing stopping you from delaying if need be.
doubt it, sickness
i mean, we had a couple of those in legion already and they were still random
and I saw no mention to change that
Just feels bad. For a class with no self healing utd be nice to not waste rage like that.
I see I missed the character flexing?
Bask in the glory of a panda
@sick sentinel tbh 1.3x is a little low for a cap it’s not like the default absorb amount is anything crazy to begin with
problem being we will be "should I press IP or am I wasting a GCD ?"
@static pilot that moment when preach rips your heart from your chest by running Devastator
If they nerf UF prot will need it’s other abilities buffed quite a bit tbh
Why?
Because if it gets nerfed there goes all your damage which means there goes your threat lol
dont know about you guys but rn im gearing my warr which is 338 ilvl and when pulling, I have to underuse my defensives in favor to my AoE dps to keep the aggreo
so a UF nerf would be huge for me
You are aware other tanks are simming at 7k single target yeah?
Meanwhile 348 I’m doing 5.5k single target
Disagree. Because it'll still do plenty of damage and threat with avatar, after whatever UF nerf they do.
It's not like tclap the only ability I spam anyway.
A nerf to UF is an overall DPS and therefore threat loss if they don’t touch anything else
It’s not hard to understand
I do 7800 at 345 ilvl st.
sim or real dps ?
Real skada.
You’ve sat at a raiding dummy for 5 minutes and held 7800?
Nah, just from what I've seen on single boss fights mythics.
I’m not either but if they nerf UF other stuff is going to have to be buffed to compensate
Saying that it won’t need to be is obtuse
UF should get a nerf. But doesnt mean the class otherwise needs buffs.
Why should it get a nerf lol
That’s like arguing all of last xpac that DH should have been nerfed because it could beat DPS on trash in m+
Clearly Blizz disagreed
I dont feel the pressure or concern you're feeling. Sorry.
I’m not saying the class needs buffs right now
Nor do i
What I did say is that if UF gets a nerf then other things will need a buff to compensate
Although I don’t see an issue with UF at all
Why do we need a buff to compensate for a spell that is already overturned?
It doesnt need compensation.
How is it overtuned?
Same as doesnt need buffs.
Considering Tclap is a majority of your threat and damage in single target yes you would need them if UF were to be nerfed
UF is outright op. You'd never consider anything else in that talent tier. It overshadows all other abilities by large margin ST and AOE.
Because a tank doing more damage than DPS is abhorrent. Why do we need this? TF already does a fine job of holding threat
Doesnt need class buffs following it lol
It also stagnates the entire talent line
You guys are new to warrior aren’t you?
^
Aye mate, 13 years new. I guess everyone's new that doesn't agree with your rehtoric
Long as it's just UF.
Has prot warrior been officially gutted in bfa?
yes don't play it
In a raid environment you nerf the one ability that composes 30+% of your damage in single target and then expect you to hold threat against other tanks which are already doing more ST damage than us?
/s
That’s a joke
Just because avatar tclap is impressive in aoe doesn’t mean it’s broken
@copper basin again pretty much every tank in legion wants a word
Since you know I out dps’d a lot of dps in aoe as BrM
Not to mention did you ever see a DH in legion?
If it turns one spell into an ion cannon - yes it does. It stagnantes the entire talent row because it's a no brainer choice. It's a problem talent.
they still pull impressive numbers in bfa
Everything else in that tier as ass to begin with
Don’t blame bad talents on the good one
By that logic, Bolster is also a problem talent.
It is a problem talent, it makes an already strong spell stronger and becomes a no thought talent
Might as well throw Booming Voice out of the spec
yeah there's like one on almost all rows that significantly outperforms the other choices but the problem is mostly that they are very bad
And while we’re at it throw Ignore Pain into the gutter
Oh and we don’t need shields either
Get rid of those
This strawman is real
No the obtuseness is real
One good talent and two EXTREMELY subpar talents=/=that good talent is overtuned
To say UF will destroy Prot is nonsense, but the point that the other talents are, at least currently, lackluster is spot on.
but I can easily see UF getting nerfed by like 25-35%
It should be, damage needs to be shifted from that talent to the base of spells.
@somber summit no but to say that an UF nerf would most likely cripple our ability to raid tank without a buff to our other abilities or asking out other tank to handicap themselves isn’t untrue
Problem rest being bad, and that those superior choices all synergize too.
Best Served doesn't provide extra rage, and the rage gen/damage from Roar just can't mathematically match UF.
As it is BrM is seemingly capable of 1.5k dps more than warrior in ST
At least if I were to look at myself and my GM
the cookie cutter talents in prot just synergize way too much with each other
Monk is also overbuffed by Blizz cus no one plays it as well. All 3 of its specs are super strong.
BrM is an unattractive spec to most people.
Blizz has always buffed classes or nerfed based on how many x play y class for most part.
If you call one raid healthy sure.
One raid 😂
It was used in ToS to cheese
Uhhhh
Based by population % and % in raids.
It was used pretty prevalently in Antorus
One raid.
BrM was in a pretty good spot practically all of legion
Yes mat
No one is saying it's shit
People don't like the spec is what we are sayig
^
there is merit to the idea that the way BrM plays is off-putting to people
no doubt
It's not popular in design to most.
So the % of people playing it is low so they buff it thinking it's poor
Compared to other classes
BrM is nuanced. Generally it's fun to play but it hurts when burst damage hits.
BrM is a beast. Just not a popular tank.
I for example mained monk last expansion but don't like how they play at all so playing warrior now
and enjoying that much more
PvP & PvE rankings, players rankings, best guilds, classes & race rankings, gear, gems, enchants, talents & builds stats
Seems to have been a very healthy amount of BrMs
I've always and majority mained warrior only past 14+ years. 😛
More BrMs then warrior tanks according to that 🤔
Just enjoy how it plays and it works for me.
Probably due to stigma from beta and pre-patch. Or it's horribly off due to not counting active vs inactive.
Who said warrior was more popular than anything? No one suggested this. I'd say 1.9% is still rather low.
I'd say warrior is purely down to stigma from videos from method etc going on about how poor they are.
By the current logic train
In fact shouldn’t they have been buffed out the ass after they became one of the least played tanks in legion?
I don't feel weak as a prot, bit I'm not sure if that echos what's actually happening in the community
I don’t feel weak at all
Yeah basically. Thanks Sco
I also don’t feel broken in terms of damage
You get 45 seconds of high aoe
Then it normalizes
I don't think we need a buffet, but if they nerf UF then possibly need to shift some of that damage to TC etc
That’s literally all I said and everyone went full autism
That if UF gets nerfed other things need to be buffed
Which it really isn’t
I wouldn't call what people were saying as autism because it was a counter argument
But I guess that's just our personalities showing.
I mean when people sit here and say that UF needs to be nerfed and that nothing else should get compensated after a UF nerf that’s pretty autistic
No because the numbers say so
Look it’s simple
((the numbers))
Take your top ability as a tank
Nerf it by x amount
You’ve now lost 4x of whatever the number x represents in terms of threat
No one said it should be nerfed, btw. It just feels like an inevitability considering Blizz's track record.
If you don’t shuffle some of that to our more single target abilities you’re going to run into threat issues with other tanks
The only thing our damage is “insane” in is aoe
Thus, discussing around accommodating to that potential change.
You know. Discussion.
I mean you thought a 7800dps meter reading after downing a boss in a Mythic 0 was equivalent to a 5 minute sim
@vocal nimbus 
😬
I think that if any talent is a no-brainer, 100% pick rate talent, it's a problem. Talents are supposed to be malleable and adjusted to fit the needs of specific scenarios.
Odd that you say no one said it “should” get a nerf
So yeah, prot has a lot of problem talents
Right.
We’ve had 100% pickrate talents since vanilla come on now
That doesn't mean they're not a problem
"no one said it should get a Nerf"
He also said that
Define problem
Because it’s not impeding my ability to play or play well
And I couldn’t give a care in the world which talent is best because regardless of what I have to do I’m going to use the best talent whether it’s a 1% gain or a 100% gain
As will most people
@undone sun ❔
Really blizzard is the only entity who has an opinion that matters when it comes to balance. I believe they did say during Legion that they don't want tanks beating dps at their own game. So it would make sense that they'd lower our dps in a way that puts us in line with the dps of other tanks (for aoe and single target).
If that means that we strictly get a dps nerf, I'd really hope that we'd be buffed in other areas to compensate (since the tanks are allegedly balanced quite well right now).
Hum.
I mean we don’t beat DPS at their own game IF the DPS is actually good and has the proper gear
@vocal nimbus you pinged me asked if I was sleeping
Sure I can burst to 40k on a big pull but arms can burst and sustain higher than us for example
It’s rare that I finish a pull on the top of the damage unless it’s just undergeared or inexperienced players
Well then according to blizzard, they have no reason to lower our dps with no compensation.
TBH I just wish they’d make Devastator baseline
Or better yet just make BV baseline
Would be a nice compensation for demo being on the gcd
well i'd say a dps nerf would be compensated by a threat buff
Our DPS is our threat unless they just want to throw the BFA threat changes out the window
I still believe that auto-pick talents shouldn't exist. I wish the other talents in the auto-pick rows were powered up.
Better yet, I wish we had synergistic talents/traits for other abilities. So we could spec into the "thunderclap+avatar+demo shout" build or the (hypothetical) "spell reflect+ignore pain+charge" build or the (hypothetical) "shield slam + revenge + crit block" build.
1 dps=1 threat for dps; 1 dps=~4 threat for a tank
Isn't 1dps=0.5 threat for a dps?
Edit: you're right.
"As a baseline, Tanks will generate 4 times more Threat than DPS." - wowhead
I’d love a Blackout Combo type talent for prot
Not to my knowledge
Whatever it is our dps as a tank generates 4x as much as a dps’ dps would
But that also means being able to keep your tanks relatively close in single target in terms of damage is fairly important
are people going devestator or booming voice this tier?
@chilly brook
Yeah, running devestator instead of BV surprised me too. I guess the rotation feels a bit nicer since there will be gaps when you dont have anything to press so you might as well IP, but emphasizing the Avatar thunderstomp build and ignoring BV is really odd
Taunt multiplies threat by 5x and high threat abilities (heroic throw) generate 4x more Threat. So heroic throw on a taunted enemy generates 20x the threat you normally would, which is 80x more than if a dps did the same amount with an attack.
Right but if all you’re doing is heroic throw you’re gonna be out threated really quick
I was wrong again. "
Abilities like Heroic Throw and Throw Glaive deal bonus threat due to their low base damage. If a Tank deals 100 damage using Throw Glaive to a mob, the tank will get 1,600 Threat for a total of 16 times the base damage."
ye, tought so
My worry with a UF nerf isn’t our threat in regards to DPS in the group
It’s our threat in regards to other tanks
Since tclap makes up a significant amount of your damage in st
Iron Fortress is basically equal to brace for impact, just a slight favouring aoe vs ST right?
Just use taunt in groups. Not that big of a deal
thinking DC then 2 IF for mythic+, 2 brace for raiding
It’s not that simple
I’ve raided with weaker tanks before and I basically had to sit there hands off the keyboard or risk an inopportune threat rip
That's only happened to me in lfr
thats what i did
i had bear cotank on HC
i jsut wiped us till he got good and did dmg
im not gonna hold back for someone who cant play
HC=High command
That's not necessarily the best progression attitude...
i jsut said in discord"oh mark lsotaggro again"
whoopsie
i dont expect DDs to do half work on a boss
so i wont from my cotank
anyone? brace vs iron fortress?
I would never intentionally wipe a raid because I wasn't willing to ease off the gas pedal for a bit.
I mean I don’t think the guild would appreciate it that much
TBH most wouldn’t deem that his fault
@tawny panther they are close, yes. I prefer brace all around because we already do really well at aoe dps, so we don't really need much more.
yeah i guess thats true
just not sure on the dps difference with shield block guarenteeing the reflect
Either way my concern is that prot wouldn’t be able to hang in st if a UF nerf went through without compensation and without cheesing taunt every CD
We're in a philosophical debate now. This is the trolley problem. If you let the trolley go as is, you wipe the raid. If you pull the lever you save the raid.
If the raid wipes, is it your fault for doing nothing?
Or, by having the potential to save it at all, do you shoulder the blame?
It’s on both parties
One should play their class better the other knowing that the other wasn’t as competent shouldn’t have chosen a time that would wipe 19 other people to fix that problem
I mean don’t get me wrong I partially made our prior GM rage quit because I was vocal on his extremely bad bear DPS when I pulled up his analyzer and saw how much shit he was doing wrong
From a Kantian perspective, we must use logic and ask, if we apply the rule; 'every tank that out-dpses the co-tank will go ham until they lose threat and the raid wipes.' is the rule sustainable or will it end itself?
I don't know the answer, personally.
From a Hobbesian perspective, it depends on what you desire, levko. If your goal was to finish the raid, you were acting against that. If your desire was to improve your co-tank in the long run, you did well.
Ethics is so fun.
Well then it depends how early in the raid cycle you are
Whether you're improving Co tanking in the first raid to gain the benefit of it through the expac
Or if you're in a mid raid or the last raid
Yeah, there's no right or wrong answer here. It depends on the situation and ethical philosophy you want to apply.
Aye
#RelevantProtWarriorDiscussion
Well during my Pug i saw ppl running taunt in their rotation
kinda worse than average dps tank :^)
Anyone using the engineering helm instead of the ones in the guide? Think relational gizmo is solid for tanking?
hey friends, can you guys help me out? 325 Vial of Animated Blood or 345 Ravasaur Skull Bijou
At first I thought I was bad, then I saw this 
it's like "let's take the worst out of the talents and try it in a build"
2,5k dps on bosses, 5k tops on AoE
RAID IS T OMORROW. i'm scared.
not for us EU plebs :/
US has to have advantage to have small chance in raid race vs EU Kappa 
I mean it's not like EU hasn't had so many legs up over NA these last two weeks
Still haven't gotten a weapon emissary on NA horde lol
annoyed - did my first mythic on my guardian and got a 350 piece.
Shouldn't the "Graves repercusiones" be repercusiones graves ?
Since adjectives follow the noun in Spanish, I thought
with raid coming up, are you guys gonna be using strength or stam flask?
Strength always.
Strength
I'd only take a Stam flask if there was some cheese where you had to take a gigantic magical hit for some reason and you desperately needed all the Stam you could get
Yeah, vanguard and more damage is always nice for keeping up with the co-tank threat-wise and killing faster
Vanguard, buffs damage, buffs IP
last time i used a stam flask was... uh... gruul's lair, or maybe brutallus
Oh yeah, IP too
Stam just makes you fatter sponge. Nothing else.
Use strength bountiful captain feast too.
sethraliss is a real shitshow with pick ups
never again
Is that the one where you need to swap to fury/arms to get the str buff?
Sethraliss is a real joy when you have no heals and a disc priest...
someone said something about spanish?
pinata
did they fix or even address the issue that you can lose an orb in sethraliss and be unable to finish?
Yeah, the screen cap a bit above, the talent on the bottom row. Shouldn't those words be in the opposite order?
Shouldn't it read "Repercusiones Graves"?
It's more about the elemental boss
Graves repercusiones
with nobody knowing the fuck they are doing
Nifty
although grave isnt exactly heavy
I always thought the adjectives follows the noun
but its a correct translation
TIL
Five melee specs can heal, right? Did you have any of those?
trying to gear my gaurdian as well and my god mythics with pugs are horrendous
second pull going right in atal'dazar and the healer walks up and moonfires the pack that you don't even have to pull on the right
ignoring the fact that I was just waiting for that pat
well yeah in BfA pugging is horrible
Nice
ppl dont even know what a kick is i feel
Pugs dont wait.
Yeah they dont.
Pugging heroic shrine, no one but me trying to interrupt unending darkness
Or consume essence
Or the trash pack heals something rapids
that's the only thing why I like my tank DH
dispell
ppl dont know it too
like the mob will have 5 stacks of a buff granted by his allies, dmg +50%, haste +50%, no one will have the idea to dispell
(when playing with classes that are able to do it)
Mhm.
So which 340 trink is better for prot? Merektha's Fang or Razdunk's Big Red Button
cool thxs
I've been playing with Button but just got Merektha's Fang and was wondering
^ this or pair it with a stun
wondering if I should go with a 355 boe haste + a 355 boe mastery ring, or only the 355 haste boe with a haste mastery ring
No clue how much I should blow on the mastery boe
Really wish we'd have stats weight or such lol
is there any way to math the number of tclap we could do per Avatar with haste and gcd tiers or alike ?
Like ''if you have 30% haste, you can do 6 tclap, but with like 47% you can do 7'' or what ever ? Is that something thats possible ?
which ring is better for tanking? https://www.wowhead.com/item=158314/seal-of-questionable-loyalties&bonus=4777:1482#guides or https://www.wowhead.com/item=159460/overseers-lost-seal&bonus=4777:1482
This blue ring of item level 310 goes in the "Finger" slot. It is looted from Captain Raoul. In the Rings category. Added in World of Warcraft: Battle for Azeroth.
Haste one unless there is a big ilvl disparity
are aberrations still unblockable?
Secondaries are a lot more balanced from previous expacs, raw stat budget is impprtant
ok thanks
But on ring its only stam
Stam isnt a secondary soooooo
Secondaries are close enough in value for tanking that the total stat budget is still major factor.
