#protection
1 messages ยท Page 1994 of 1
Like I died on Shadow dog because I stepped out of healing range to dodge a fire puddle
only matters for leveling gear and mounts
but overall the DOTs seem totally manageable like they were before
Then don't do it, @astral crystal
It matters for learning your specs, YOU THINK ULDIR WILL BE EASY?
I've been tanking sans legos
to get used to it
course its not like the prot legos are a huge survivability boost unless you're popping archimondes
but yeah I Went stat sticks and sans legos lastnight
yeah wrists took a huge hit
Wrists have always been somewhat of a gimmic for raiding
95% overhealing from them most fights
cause we were either full HP because of IP
or dead
Now they have a minor impact
better than nothing when we're outside of healers range
I'm really not quite sure why there is a perception of the raid being hard now or something.
Pretty sure we killed the bosses we did faster than before the patch.
There were a couple of abilities that weren't squished properly and have been hotfixed by now.
The only real increase of difficulty is in healing throughput which is intentionally lower across the board. Bring an extra healer and you should be fine.
very minor, was healing for ~2k when i cast IP
well meiffert im not talking about bosses being harder
just dogs being ridiculously overtuned
and it's a fact that aggramar had pretty broken damage too
like I said I'm intentionally going sans legendaries and no flashy trinkets because I'm just getting used to the pace
ok, not dogs, the dog debuff
๐คฆ
Dogs have always done more damage than other bosses tho
like, they had double the DTPS as Aggramar and Argus
I Mean the dogs were killable prior to the fixes
there's just no need to get touchy about it fam, bring an extra healer is a fine solution for most situations, bring a bunch of extra tanks is not really where a fight should be
i m o
without 3 or 4 tanking them
but that made it easier
So that is what most did
What the major issue on dogs was, that singe was one shotting the DPS and healers it grabbed
so you lose a healer or 2 to that
suddenly the fight is worlds harder
and thats when the tanks would die
i feel like i'm having more trouble holding threat than old skittish.. you guys doing anything beyond thunderclaps during avatar, maybe alternating TC/revenge without avatar, tab targeting for each shield slam?
i'm competing pretty well for overall dungeon damage. might be a timing thing
Are u beating the DPS to the mob packs?
we get there at the same time i suppose
Try to get there a few GCDs before em
It'll help
TC and tab SS should be enough after that
hm part of the issue then might be that i'm letting my healer catch up on grievous
so dps has a chance to sprint ahead
Also nameplates that show when you're losing threat, not just when you've lost threat
that i do have (elvui nameplates)
heh can confirm
i hadn't had this trouble before, so i thought it was something i was doing wrong
You could probably do better but threat is nerfed to the BFA multiplier now so it is actually possible for DPS to rip
Especially on pull if they're there ahead of you
IP on the gcd makes it harder too. that's one gcd i'm not using to hold threat with dps
just learning to work with the new kit
+900% -> +350% threat & some extra GCDs on mitigation (all tanks, to be clear) definitely stacks up. Mostly a problem with PUGs.
Yeah, you need to have threat before the DPS goes im
If they are hitting a pack before you on skittish, then you are pretty much hosed for that pull
U can recover with Avatar TC
But
If that's on cd GG
Also pocket rogues
(for skittish)
that's why you avatar before you go in
so it's not all that outrageous to ask them to wait a couple gcds before rushing in?
Lol
You have to play around it
i haven't tried warr but on pala, dh and monk i didn't really have issues
pugs yeah dps is often hitting first, especially if i'm waiting for the healer because it's grievous
If they are pugs and it's their key, just let them die tbh
it isn't as bad as i'm making it out. i just lose aggro here and there and feel like i could do better
Just sounds like they're getting big dmg ahead of yours
yeah the damage i saw myself do in raid with warr was higher than the pala
but pala has more frontloaded damage though
SoTR aoe off the gcd
is so good
Eh, it's not like you suffer any consequences if someone else overaggros
multiplier for what?
damage
compared to legion you mean?
oh like that
Although I guess with armor it's close
i think the main issue with warr is that IP is more pro-active than reactive
compared to LoTP
so it's a "wasted" GCD early into the pull
if you got plenty of aggro
its worth it
yeah
but doesnt exist at 120 does it
so no matter
True... Might as well have fun with it now?
ofc
but
if you have too much fun
it'll hurt your soul more
when you hit 120
and you get shafted up the bum
Tank heroic no set bonuses legos or fancy trinkets
get used to that balsawood thong now
our selection of tanking trinkets thus far looks uh
well
stat sticks STAT STICKS FOR EVERYONE
Stat sticks with stat procs
Only ones worth anything
Oh, or stat on use, sorry
DMD:B is garbage too
Dark Moon Deck: Boobs
we โค boobs
And dmd
Sure
Dmd and the tw trink
the str haste one?
But dungeons had ones to makeup for it
The armor on use one
o rite
And yeah EN trinkets were bad
But we had dung ones
Now those are trash too
And there wrote trinkets like Statuette and the vers proc one
Goblet
i mean, hopefully they just aren't putting the bells and whistles out in this tier
feels wierd calling it a tier without tier gear....
tier is just another way of saying level
its "pre-tier"
Why is DMD bad?
Pre teen
yeah, strength + stamina; boring, sure, but bad?
wasn't its budget like complete garbo
Nah, its more or less last I looked at it
maybe, I don't know
I know that all the crated items are pathetic item level, I thought they might be upgradable
It was generally on the low end of being useful. although with the str buffs to Vanguard
it might have merit now
yeah, it's 300, maybe there is some obliterum system
but its no immortality
because the other crafted items are also 300
I haven't seen anything about an upgrade system yet
actually its below average
The salvage stuff doesn't work the same
If you want to survive you can only count the value on the minimum
I still think I'ma wear the engi helm for early prog
hmm
crafted items can forge too i think
let me check my dude on beta, im sure i had a forged piece
nvm i scrapped my old stuff, rip
tit's mcgeee! 230 shield from a darksore
eu?
NA
sadface... they rotate every 8h or 24?
looks like every 24 hours
one is way up at the top for me today
like almost outta darkshore off the map up there
maybe i'm thinking too far ahead, but for a ticking magic beam (krosus-esq) that we'd have to eat as a tank, pooling up rage and keeping IP up would basically be a 50% DR if we could keep the IP up for the duration of the channel?
odds are the damage would eat through the shield faster than you could build rage for it
but i also dont think there will be heavy sustained magic damage in the future
i agree, i just do "what-ifs" a lot ๐
unless its a mechanic designed in such a way that it is on the burden of the healers or something instead of AM
future azerite trait ๐ค
Nice. Take Devastate off your bars again.
two shield build WHEN
Plz blizz we need
If blizz is planning to make snakemans and foxmans playable they can give prot warrs 2 fuckin shields.
So are there azerite traits that aren't listed yet in the database?
Lioe higher tier ones dependent on higher ilvl gear or somethibg?
Or are the ones available to look at all of them
Well I'm not saying it's not exciting, I actually think it adds a ridiculous amount of build potential
Given that a lot of shit stacks too
I think I'm going to skip the azerite armor
lolwut
i remember when blizz devs talked about azerite armor being this huge gameplay changing system
beware ion's lies
gameplay changing LUL
yeah, not thrilled with the azerite stuff. Going to pass
lol
"There is a lot of depth with Azerite traits." - Ion, literally a week ago
i mean depth is mostly just a buzzword
i think azerite has potential to be really cool, but atm the bonuses are a bit lackluster or not impactful enough aside from a few good ones
nothing class changing, nothing meta changing like 1button DH helmet
maybe that stuff has yet to come, who knows
same as trinkets
for instance, crushing assault for arms. the free slam proc trait is an amazing design
but a lot of the other ones are very plain
yeah, it's okay, I guess, but I think I'll just raid without the neck. How bad could it possibly be?
๐ค
invasion weapons op
i ignored ignore pain
lol, "I blocked Shield Block"
hah
i put a wall between myself and shield wall
I made a last stand against Last Stand
Demoralizing Shout made me so sad I couldn't use it
I did a chargeback against charge
i leapt away from heroic leap
on my druid I swiped left on Swipe
totally unrelated, but WPL is a great zone if you have fast riding ๐
Guys...I saw the cutest pic of a dog ever and I can't function.
LOL
I won't meme it here but I rly hope more of u stumble upon it holy hell I'm melted.
put it in #off-topic
hmm...I just got a lvl 210 shield from the world quest. I put on a hammer that has a max damage per hit of 1 (smithing hammer). the damage difference compared to the artifact is not even 30% on shield slam and the artifact has 80 avg damage per hit.
is weapon damage obsolete?
outside of mele i think so?
but mele is a larger part of damage from what i'm seeing in arms/fury
which prot warrior abilities factor in weapon damage atm?
or do they all scale with AP now?
I think everything scales with AP now
(strength + weapon dps * k) * mastery * versatility * ability coefficient
so in other words "stick your highest ilvl weapon in your grubby little hands and hit things with it"
pretty much
ty
so.. how many are going prot warr for HC and Mythic BFA raiding
Prot every time baby, doesn't matter the tier.
I just got Voluntold the other night that I'm tanking for the HC and Mythic teams
I thought they were gonna do Monk Pal
but the MOnk decided he wanted to be a warlock
monks always do
and the GM is the other tanking option out the gate~
So I'm getting my Paladin and Monk on that server ready
just incase
Altho
after tanking on the war a bit more
using no legos or tier set
I think we'll be just fine for BFA progression
I mean, I was only 227 and took less damage than the 248 pal I co tanked with lastnight
so~
damage taken does not equal external healing attention.
I understand your point, but don't use that as a base.
It's also legion dmg patterns
well.. we are at 250+ ilvl and tanking.. seems like we take a bit more dmg but not much
So any comparison done talking Legion content is worthless
As always I will main warrior and keep all 6 tanks raid ready for bfa.
just hoping spell refelct will be enought.. we are going to get more magic dmg in bfa
How do you know
have you actually looked at fights?
I feel you just made that up
looked at the bosses abilities yes
Having tested I'd say it's less... but what would I know. ๐ค
compare all the abilities and attacks.. its around 30% more than legion
Because coming to baseless conclusions with no actual context or testing is the proper way to determine damage type variance.
I'm sorry
but you're just making shit up.
Now you made up a % for it
Now it has numerical value
It's not more magic btw
You can't tell by dungeon journal either
sure.. lets se what you say after doing a HC run.. then you can come and say sorry.. omg..
LFR is so fun LUL not even dropping 1 IP over the entire duration
tmogs boy
@main vault I love testing and it not actually meaning anything! ๐ค
gotta get em
LFR ToS mog is actually cool
A 10k attack casted 10 times or a 15k attack 6 times
Probably the second because it's more magic in the journal
Right?
Did I win?
not sure what that question is about
No Nexii
10k*10 is 100k
15k*6 is 90k
look at the base value /s
Haha
All in all Warriors would prefer the 15k 6 times
@strong forum you got baited so hard
just hoping spell refelct will be enought.. we are going to get more magic dmg in bfa
feel like i missed part of the question ๐ค
compare all the abilities and attacks.. its around 30% more than legion
I just like arguing
saying theres 30% more magic dmg than in legion?
Yes
๐คฆ
Cause journal said so
we are going to get more magic dmg in bfa ๐ค
monkaS
Or don't.
what encounters have magic dmg?
we no bully here
There is explaining differences contextually, and then there is just being an asshole.
let me check this out
Oh he's not so bad. Let me just pet him with my sword.
200 iq conversation in m+ "tank why did u die?""because i was low hp"
Nim almost all encounters in BFA have magic damage
for the most part
its very nicely timed
and bursty
Yeah
so we can slap it down with a DSSR combo
Because I used every cooldown at my disposal while praying for a heal from the amazing healer we have in this party but he appeared to be busy doing damage.
It's pretty easily dealt with by most tanks
40% + IP Magic reduction suckit
they dont want another like star augur problem, where its like 90% consistent magic damage
so magic damage is being more closely looked at with encounter design
It'll be fun
I think I'ma beg tobe llowed fury for that, let the monk deal with that crap
as long as its not fucking spammed like yeah Star Augur
Man that hurt lol
The worst part of Star Augur
progression
was you'd always hit him late night
unless you were extending lockouts
and folks would be totally colorblind
WHAT DO I HAVE RED OR ORNAGE NEEEEEEEEEEE
Colorblind
lol or they were like me and forget to turn off F.lux
Odyn runes
When everyone's tired and cranky.
Odyn runes was epic trolling on blizzards part
"guys why is this alliance dude grey?"
lets make these runes yellow orange and red
"TURN OFF F.LUX"
on a ornage yellow and red floor
at least Star Augur you could see them
cause the floor wasn't color coordinated
yeah but that's always been a stupid problem in virtually every single raid
green beams on portal keeper
blizzard logic lets make the fire the same color as everything else
"did the floor change color a bit?"
"I think it did I'ma move over here - directly into the beam cause contrast"
if you cant see beams on PK then you should get your eyes checked tbh
Storm
damn, i missed the frog fight
Like the spikes on Gul'Dan. If your camera was at the wrong angle it would't show up.
I think Storm of Darkness
was the worst tho
before they made the circles easier to see
IDK void bolts in Seat is fucking cancer
You guys might just have a shitty monitor too. A monitor upgrade is a better graphic upgrade then a Gpu. Unless ofc your Gpu cant keep up
or
breh i have a 1440p Gsync monitor
Lol no
New monitor does wonders
the game isnt optimized at certain moments
it is rather low
however I had the brightness/contrast lowered because I play in the dark
I have an Asus vg248qe 144hz.
so I turned it up
and have a lamp behind me now
so I'm not burning my eyeballs out
i have a dell s2716dg and my 2nd monitor is a crappy viewsonic but i dont use it to game
its a great monitor
Trash*
uh ok
Asus/predator or nothing
rofl okay
Not for that price
have fun with your freesync
they are now
minotor wars
You can get the Asus Swift PG278QR for the same price
monitor also
G sync and all
implying it even matters that much
their brand is trash but their monitors are great
Dell buys the same IPS panels that Apple charges 4000$ for
So
I mean, they're the best monitors you can buy
Dell?
yes
Their TN is garbage
Just because apple overcharges doesn't make them great
but their IPS monitors are some good shit
Dell monitors dont even have a 90%rgb rating
my best monitor experiences have been with ASUS
No wonder you cant see mechanics
I don't have a dell monitor
???
jesus lol
this guy
the one person that agrees with you also has problems with mechanics
i have an old-ass asus laptop with a 560m graphics card and i'm pretty fucking good at staying outta mechanics.... i think this argument is tomfoolery ๐
Asus,evga,corsair,msi are the only brands that should be in near or around your pc for optimal pc gaming. Plain and simple.
OH
Who has problems with mechanics?
and i'm running wine/linux for my wow
you nexii
it's epeen measurement on a cantonese voice cryptomining program
you said
Like,
saying u cant have good pc gaming exp
I'm not even sure why folks are arguing about monitors
if u dont buy certain brands
Does that mean I've had an issue?
I said for optimal
Purple on purple is bad
doesnt matter
when I specifically said - I had trouble seeing green on gree, cause my brightness/contrast was down (nothing to do with the quality of the monitor)
that's obviously what i meant
my point is, the problem is not the monitor
i dont need to see khadgar's testicle in 4k
hell this whole argument started because we were talking about late late late night progression
nope
furry RP outside of goldshire in 4k
also current year
I didn't spend 6k on my computer to see it in 1080p like some pleb
Ok I'ma convince my wife to let me setup in the living room, 65" UHD monitor here i come
Do it!!!
Incoming ms latency
4k World of Warcraft
It's so big who cares about latency lol
good enough to beat battletoads
if I can beat battletoads on that TV
I can deal with the input lag
hahaha
IP is my input lag
Won't notice gcd if the screen doesn't react
200iq
wp sir
VR ftw
he and his friend have helms
On a rogue too
i linked them earlier in fury i think
VR WoW... the dream
Cleared raids too
vr wow would be a disaster
Daredevil: Gamer Mode
will i finally be able to get milkies from mommy Whitemane and die crushed between her enormous muscular thighs
Only way to make Tanking better is to make it VR

lol
As someone who tanked first person view in other MMOs
Making tanking first person
or VR
does not make it better
it just makes you stare at monster balls
there's an audience for that
rule 34
here's an article about those:
i mean
how much do you have to interact with the general public daily ๐
the average is quite dismal ๐
hold up, you guys lied
that's a plate and a mail helm
OP rogue wears plate or mail
he went to rogue for MoP i think:
https://www.engadget.com/2013/03/07/blind-player-ben-shaw-on-raiding-and-wow-for-the-sightless/
???
could be just perfect
no i mean now
Such meme
oh because dhs are blind
thanks for ruining that Levko
yea
There's an all deaf guild that cleared mythic in Legion
And some people can't clear LFR
"I can't hear your complaints about LFR..... and even if i could, I'm too busy clearing mythic"
I believe it
i'm fucked without auditory clues personally, but i can see how something like WA could compensate
i just have WAs flash screen till i am dead
I play without skill anyway. Where is my article ?
Lol
no sound, no voice, just text, and typing during a raid is a bitch ๐
how is being deaf a huge handicap
^
Can yell for cds
voicechat is 90% morons yellin anyway
Taunt swaps
macro whisper spam
WAs, bigwigs
And then leave a funny message on your screen when you mess up and die?
not sure where you've done progression raiding, but i tend to stick to places that keep voice pretty fucking clear during attempts then ๐
we play warriors, where is our article: "worst tanking class in BFA according to people that randomly pop up on discord after watching Sco's rankings, clear some hard shit"
i played with same healer for a while and i had a macro spammin him "piss my face" when i needed a pain sub
You can run Dragon Naturally speaking and type into an overlay
playing wow deaf is essentiallt playing without voice and sound
People in here asking how it's hard
But I mean
Can't clear mythic while hearing
but I mean, there was raiding before VOIP
*shrug
just setup macros
to flast keyphrases
i remember raiding with smoke signals and discreet ethercasts into the psychosphere
to trigger other folks WAs
those were the days
text message is still off GCD.
it soon wont be
luckily.
too OP in pvp, will nurf
nerf all the idiots macroing their bladestorm to yell some shit
or a ttrpg!
already feels like it. Levko used Avatar, mob used melee, Levko used DS, mob used spell
to counter the gcd crap im like
pinnacle of skill
2 hours later..." Levko uses Shield Slam"
jokes on you, i dont even do world content as prot cuz i fijnd it so unplayable
casts thunder clap
๐คท
some1 know if the 10% damage reduction on ANTORUS is applied also to BOSSES?
mmmmm
Crackling thunder+avatar+tclap is God like. I absolutely destroy parses
Parses ?
Found the old EQ player
You bet.
Wath is that ?
Bfa brought me to wow- glad I finally gave it a shot
Parse being the damage meter stuff
All that the hate in prot- we're gonna show them
parses are generally the term related to warcraft log percentile ranks
Ah, gotcha
part of me is tempted to level with Punish / HR / Sword and Board / BV and leggo gloves for the massive SS hits
movespeed: wheelchair without wheels
lol
hmm
Thanks think it's safe to say it's out, just needs the flip switched to unlock content
๐ฑ
so
how is it prot
as a main tank in legion and previous xpac i was sad after 7.1 and the nerf bat
the best part wasn after NH
I was not much a fan of NH but I enjoyed the "criticisms" of prot and the revolving door of the second tank spot for ToS and abt.
the NH tier was nice, but there were a couple dick punch bosses in that raid
when they added devastator, the class felt much more complete imo
even if it was super OP in EN
I thought that was Fury?
all warriors rage
We are the steadfast and calm ones :0
i see a lot of warriors still go devstator talent for Antorus with hands lego, is that better than booming voice , or its good only in ST ?
RAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAGEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
i don't like devastator, or the similar dh talent
like... at all
@wild sandal no, any1 still using devastator just doesnt want to let go. or they havnt been keeping up with balance
Now if they added decent rage gain back.......
ok, and the hands lego still one of the best, i hardly ever press devsate since i dont really have the gcd for it, or a m i doing it wrong ?
nah you are fine
ok thank you
is the 4 piece worth using or is it still garbage?
no
its BIS
a MUST USE
u use IP than 2 x SB
and ur shield become more than ur health ๐ฎ
when IP expire u restart with that
thats ur rotation
for defence
then use TC + SS to generate rage
avatar + DS too
and LS when needed (100% block (not crit))
SW if needed
devastate when u dont do anything of this (never?)
thats war bfa up to now
@long phoenix
one could argue better to get rid of it and start learning the new ways sooner rather than later ๐ค
Hey guys, ive heard people saying prot is bad in bfa, is that true? I was considering rerolling, but now im not sure, what spec would you recommend instead?
It's more than fine for a mythic raider.
Pushing high dungeons(25+) is still reserved for the meta specifics whichever it'll be at the time
So I've been practicing M+, and I have to say that I'm really struggling with threat management when I open on a pack, depending on how many targets there are
avatar + DS + TC
Idk how i feel about Demo shout being on the GCD
but not Int
and Battle Shout is on GCD as well..? Lol
Well battle shout doesn't really matter unless someone dies mid combat in a boss encounter
Defensive abilities on gcd KEK
But Last stand and Shield wall aren't on the GCD.
Totally disagree with that, you want major defensives not on the GCD .
Some fights you have limited time to use an ability to stay alive through some massive spike.
The massive abilities are the oh shit button and since you don't press them that often putting them on the Gcd wouldn't make sense
Demo is really strong in aoe pulls in mythic + and i find i use it more for dps burst to get agro on packs than as a defensive CD. The DR is just nice in addition
New demo shout with belt is so nice
Trying not to get too attached to it...we wont have it for too much longer!
quick question.. stand your ground buff.. what is that from?
4set
says who?
If you hear someone say 'x class isn't good at m+' they're talking about very high keys that require meta comps
All classes and specs are fine for normal/heroic/mythic/reasonably high level M+
If they say otherwise they probably watched a tank ranking video taking 30 second intervals to hit their head on the desk
Anyone know if shields have the warforge cap too or is it just weapons?
weapons can tf not sure about shields
fairly certain the only thing that cant is azerite gear
my darkshore one tf'd
they still tf
blizzard got rid of the wf only
u sure?
last blue post i saw was a weapon TF cap
if you mean the q and a they said their current thinking was to only let them wf
but they changed their minds
I dont recall a blue post
i'm.... recopying over data... the joys of linux... or i'd log in and check my shield, i know i got a 220 weapon, i think the shield is 225 or 230.... but i have CRS
I would like to to have this one but sadly only the Axe dropped
Shame they aren't new models
Also don't know if those count as BFA gear
my personal experience prot war just isn't quite as stronk in m+, i shouldn't have said not good
wrong choice of words my bad
i love my prot war
but in mythic+ especially in certain ones like halls of valor i just dont feel that powerful like i used to ๐ญ
sblock is still pretty stronk
Yeah my experience is also certain instances such as HoV and Arcway do not favor our particular toolkit as much as other tanks. We need to rely considerably heavily on IP in HoV for the the 2 big packs leading up to the first boss. It gets easier after that but if dps do not interrupt its very punishing to us.
If dps help interrupt its not so bad but in pugs at least people like to hurr durr just about everything so thats likely my own fault there.
It's more a issue of people in pugs thinking they can power through things and not pay attention to well really anything, and that is what you get in pugs
The answer would be don't pug but sometimes that is not a easy answer if you do not have people on who you can run stuff with
as long as you don't have a braindead healer, reports from beta are prot warrior is solid in m+ not FOTM, but solid.
Yeah I assume Fuzzy is talking about live though
solid bottom of the pack
Which hardly matters in truth but if your bored and do not want to stay bored people like to run dungeons to take away from the boredom
yeah def live
On live rather
I just don't log on WoW, helps with boredom lol
๐ฅ
same
Rocking that ffxiv to cure the wow boredom
i swear wow is copying their tank mechanics...,
Just have no interest in prepatch
same
farming those MoP lfr sets
I mean if you have beta you could log on beta but now with BFA live launch so close also it feels pointless to log on there as it will be over very soon
Sure. Farming + or raiding is equally as pointless though lol
i mean if you do it for fun
yeah i stockpiled mats to lvl all my alts professions up.... but yeah thats useless now.
Most people have played them on beta and live is dead content
And its not like feedback on the beta holds a lot of merit at this point as class changes are certainly moved to the back burner so not point in that either. However when I talk about the point of it if you have decided what you want to play and have already spent months getting used to the changes to your class then its either log on live and gear up alts or find something to do until BFA launch
sooo bummed over 1500 primarl sarg and nothing to do with it
Never hurts to gear up alts and what not during pre patch and that is what has consumed most of my live play in the past week or so
Ultimately how we "feel" in M+ is not a representation of how we will play or "feel" at 120 when BFA launches
How we feel on live I mean
While most Azerite traits are passive and not as "game changing" as we were lead to believe they do and will make a difference
Well gameplay changing to be exact
yeah none of the az traits are that cool or fun. More just gap fillers.
BEEP BEEP Fun detected Kill it... Kill it with fire
Deafening crash and keeping DS up as long as possible is fun to me ๐คท
Yeah agreed was just a little slight on how subjective a term fun can be
I agree as I find DCrash fun and how it extends DS duration a fun trait
One thing prot is lacking is the ability to group mobs up. Now, I'm not saying warrior lacks utility in other aspects but I think this is a Big One when it comes to perceived usefulness/viability of prot warriors in dungeons. People have grown accustomed to the one man army that has been Blood DK in Legion with group leech, battle res and mass grip or they look at protection paladins and see spellwarding, lay on hands, sacrifice and protection and just 1:1 compare this to a warrior. I was thinking we should get back AOE taunt nanner from MOP to get something more but i think it won't happen as blizzard has basically said they dont want to give every class the same tools.
inb4 vacuum effect on leap azerite trait
โ๐พ ๐
I can agree, but also @eager phoenix they also stand behind they want certain classes, and obviously tanks to excel at certain things and not so much at others so there is that.
By they I mean Blizzard, but you knew that I am sure
it's kind of weird to think like "yeah we dont want to give everyone the same tools" when the gameplay literally calls for those tools
the M+ gameplay in specific really wants tanks to be able to group mobs up fast for destroying them asap
the ironic thing is that bdk isn't that uber anymore... gorefiend's nerfed radius, no more leech aura, and not nearly as sturdy as it was in 7.x
Any mass grip is going to be strong in M+ even if the radius is small
That's just how it is
in my opinion the differences between tanks shouldnt be "oh this tank is good in m+ while this other one is great in raid boss tanking"
i feel like each tank should have their own desired toolkit for multiple types of content
and unless yer doing MDI/pushing keys to the max, and/or mythic progression, that's really the case for bfa from all the non "chicken little" reports i've heard
You are correct
I think maybe they tried to make Menace attractive as utility to make up for the lack that we have, but honestly it does not and will not compete for a shorter cd on a stun in my opinion
I liked the small niches we had like shield slam being a purge
I miss disarm in pve
i do miss when heroic throw could interrupt/silence casters ๐
I agree that it is super relative. Like, what is your ambition level? What does your group really need? I mean, perhaps your healer/dps covers most utility needs and all you need is a tank that can do damage or your running with dps that lack immunities so the relative value of commanding shout shoots up. Besides: come 8.1 and suddenly blizzard buff the shit out of warriors and there we are with our warriors ready to juice it out.
my ambitions? casual everything ๐
Buffs won't do it
8.2: azerite trait gives us back lego bracers or non-gcd IP ๐๐พ
but i'm gonna be that casual that people go like "holy shit that was awesome" ๐
about 90% of the azerite traits are garbage lazy passives that clearly had little thought put into
The real irony I find is that our PvP talents contain multiple things that could significantly give us greater control or more utility in M+ content, but that can be said for many tank classes
in these days of gorfiend.... people forget the easiest way to group shit up....
LoS baby
honestly though if you have to cover up the lackings of a tank class by taking a dps class with utility you need isnt good design either
eh gorefiend 15 yards and 1.5min cd (talented) are kinda meh now.
then you're stuck with "well if you have a warrior tank then you're gonna need this and that"
That's the point of the game though...
that makes non sense eikka. we ain't playing chess of course classes can and should offer different things.
That's why you build a comp
i feel like blood dk was just gutted, the self healing feels worse than a dh now.
Using LoS in a pug is funny as shit... now granted the answer there is don't pug, but you can tell in pugs really fast how used to DK's dps are when you try and LoS and they stand there and hurr durr
mythics were not really intended to be pugged LFD style, hence the group finder letting the leader pick/choose
Blood will still be top m+ though
blood and DH are going to be the pushers for m+ so if yer MDI-aspiring, go that direction for sure
my point was that if there's other tanks that arent handicapped in such a way it's not really good design
leads to "why would you ever pick tank x"
blood has shit mobility, not as bad as legion, but it's still garbo
i kinda like the monks mix for raid/m+ but just cant stand the throw a keg stupidness...
For MDI M+ you never would is the point @west vigil
i don't like monk or druid due to the "mandated" 100% updtime stuffs
yeah, for sure. i'm just troubled by the fact that there'll be a ton of mdi wannabes who follow the "meta"
and i don't like frost or unholy, and holy pali/bdk doesn't seem like a strong 2s team to me ๐
the reality is 90% of players probably haven't picked their class based on fotm but what they've played throughout the years and its basically happenstance if their classes are strong or not any given time in wow. so the question for them isn't whether what classes on paper is the strongest and how shitty it feels when if they didn't end up with current meta top choices but how the fuck they can make prot warrior/2x feral + ele shaman and disc priest work in practice for their m+ adventures.
so, i started hunting around and warrior fits my needs the best
That is just a vicious cycle though because then you just run with guildies or friends
i'd rather run with guildies and friends any day over pugchamps....
or should i say pugchimps? ๐
and unless they do something really bad
warrior will be fine, without having to bring along x,y or z to general mythic stuffs
idk i used to love prot warrior back in vanilla. bfa prot war feels like a dps class that just generates extra threat and tries not to die.
people were getting 90% + coverage between CDs and SB/IP during active tanking time, in early raid level gear as a warrior
that's fucking rock solid damage reduction
To be honest its why for well the past 2 expansions my first alt has always been and will always be a BDK because if I want to really push M+ I go to my DK
well pushing keys fast = better raid tanking = better raid progression and it snowballs
i just "main alt" my bdk because i like it thematically, still can't stand frost or UH though overall, between the "feel" for frost, and the fucking petshit for UH ๐
again, if you are in a progression world, you can't ever go in thinking "play what i like"
you play what the team needs
that's how progression has always been
from vanilla on
nobody approaching raids/m+ as something fun to push a little and challenge them, but still remain casual, will have to sacrifice "play what you want" unless your guild doesn't need more tanks/healers/dps
"man i really want to progress in m+ but my only tank is my prot warrior and everyone's picking dave and his sickass blood dk for their m+ push runs"
eh people pick good tanks.
then run m+ as a dps with dave to get the gear
a noob dh vs a good prot war in a key matters
there's always options
a pro dh vs a pro warrior. pro dh wins m+ atm
yeah but if you dont have a "pro dh" what then
the fotm spec always gets noobs.
or is the general wow-populace so fucking brainwashed by youtube drivel that nobody thinks for themselves?
doesnt matter if there always is a theoretical "pro dh" to choose from unless you actually have a person playing "pro dh" in guild or group of friends
People are too stupid to think for themselves
people go on wowhead and see method's m+ ranking and form a team based on that
obviously i want to play m+ with Jesus to always win and be saved but he aint always available
99% of the players watching videos like sco's will never be in a situation where that shit that came out of his mouth could even matter, if he was even accurate to begin with.
My gf plays havoc so i'm thinking monk just for the perks of double buffs.
I can guarantee you 10% of this discord left when Scos tank rankings came out
rofl
good riddance
honestly if shields get massive titanforges still i'd bet on Paladin
wheelchairadin?
Bye Felicia
15% rnjeesus
How do you know you'll block
that's right
at 120 anyways
You willing to be progression in a coin flip?
still rng, still not gonna block boss baddy spell things (just plain shadowbolt shit i think)
am i the only one kind of excited on getting weapons as loot again
Cause if you don't block that spell it doesn't matter if your shield is TF to 9000
^ true
I know I already stated this, but has anyone looked over our PvP talents and prot and got nostalgic to the good old days when our talents did that anyway. At least got that feeling lately I mean. I know this is not really our discussion at the moment but I do for one get the good ole days feel.
i'm very excited for a lot of things in bfa
all the pvp warrior talents make me nostalgic for days of the past alting on my warrior for funzies
i miss the old talent trees tbh
could really play the spec you wanted
vs pick 1 of 3
no other class has the same amount of pvp talents that make me like "hmmm, i might actually enjoy this shit"
specing for just enough to get hit cap etc

