#creative-discussion
2 messages · Page 114 of 1
nice nice

nice nice nice nice
oh sweet god this oneshot is legit being a thing
what in the hell I KNOW HOW TO WRITE AGAIN 
yessss writing
also it goes without saying, if there are contest winners and they post it on tumblr we'll just reblog that
i just mean like a general "here are our winners!" i dunno it's a owrk in progress i just thought of it 5 mins ago
i just think it'd be fun to involve the creative community a little more
modders have nexus n stuff
though modders are also welcome to be reblogged
no one is safe
Lmao of course. That one shot is gonna be amazing
I love the idea of domestic Stardew Valley oneshots
give me a moment 👀
CHAPTER DONE
WOOO
Man these massive chapters are coming pretty easily too, I'm happy
IT HAPPENED. for the first time since late september of last year, i did an art.
GOOD WORK SPOONS
WEW IT FEELS GOOD TO WRITE AGAIN
Domestic au gives me life
100% mood though
hey fable i'm gonna signal boost your fic or at least try to
spoony maybe u should post ur fic on tumblr so i can reblog it
ok hang on
@slate yoke your fic is mainly farmer/alex right?
i'll be honest i haven't read fanfic lately but don't take it personally
i need to sometime
DANGIT HE WENT TO BED
but i found the tags anyway
got u fam
thonk
tottaly didnt have to do forgot my password cause holy fuck i havent done anything on any artistic medium in ages nope ahahahahah
Wolfs spoony...what is a spoony?
would i tag this as farmer and sam since it's mainly about sam?
sure, i left the S/O nameless also so anyone can use whoever they want to have as the cheater lmao
ok this one is short i should read it
IT MAKES ME FEEL GUILTY i like take a lot of time out of my day to read stuff but sometimes i'm just plain lazy
UGH I'M SO MAD I QUEUED THE WRONG ACCOUNT
RIP
i love drawing tegaki...so fun!
@unkempt tinsel hey hey Yes it's intended to be a Farmer/Alex fic
But I openly embrace slow burn slice of life so it'll be a bit before actual romance happens lol
Slow burn is great
Slow burn realistic tbh
And I'm also not afraid to take on the idea of someone having a crazy crush at first and getting over it. I don't ever see that done in literature
That's true
it's a rare trope, but ive seen it once or twice
tbh some of the best are OH MAN I LOVE YOU AND I JUST MET wait maybe i dont.... and then super slow burn to love again
It happens so often irl. Someone falls for someone, gets over it, and then slowly falls for them again
EXACTLY
That's what I'm trying to do here
i'm a sucker for from enemies to lovers
same tbh
I don't know how to write that lol
i write a lot of R18... but i love domestic stuff w
domestic stuff is fun
Domestic and Domestic AU are always nice, or way to over done.
there isnt just a 'hey that was ok' imo
not everyone has a eventful life www、i like to write that
I just keep writing the various ways Jackson gets himself thrown in Harvey's office
also、my characters...i love them to have realistic live! w
so what you're saying fable, is you are writing Jackass
For some reason shane and Nora just get in crazy things
Elliott asks for advice on romance from them and they end up being the main characters in his romance novel
Jackson has received head trauma twice now and it's always Alex's fault
the one i write now、3person of sam sebastian and farmer (・∀・)
Shane doesn't know Nora has a cave filled with fruit bats until it's too late
poly relationship! is the type I think
Shane doesn't come back home until late at night. Nora thinks he's cheating, but he's just spending time with the chickens in coop.
that's always what shane is doing and it's beautiful
You know what I'm thinking of
Could you imagine if joja mart tries to get the community center through a gridball game
All the young folks try to work together to beat joja mart and save their town
It's such a cliche, but I like the idea
Or maybe a friendly game between the townsfolk as a past time
gosh ive been wanting to write some fanficcy stuff forever but it seems
like a terrifying leap
like i find that i struggle to 'get' characters and write them in a way that resembles their canon personalities
i'm okay with descriptive writing. objective writing? where its more like fluffy stuff as opposed to
deep character driven
I hated how badly i wrote cannon like, so i just gave up on forcing it myself
I TRY to stay somewhat in character, but I realized thats not my style, so i just let it happen
@ebon briar no problem, Ill wait 👌
@ebon briar mood
Oooh he's really handsome
haha i've made abby in sims 4 like three times now
I wanna play Sims 4 again I remember hating it but I wanna give it another chance
honestly I always end up making my OCs in the sims 3 lmao
sims 4 is really shit if you dont have DLCs
its super dry of content
doesnt even have basic pool accessories =\
I tried the sims 4, not really my thing except for the CAS which is great
I like Sims 3 but Sims 2 is like my favorite
the cool thing about Origin is you can customize a 3-pack and get a good discount
honestly like the worst thing was taking away the open map??? why???????????
still forever confused
has she eaten any rocks yet
she crave that mineral
she is praisning the green diamond in that photo
lmao
PANCHAN
Also sims 4... i have SO MANY mods lmao
yes oh...maybe pansan, since i do not know your gender! i am sorry
I have...a LOT www i had to uninstall sims bc my laptop is an fossil... :(
lmaoo u can call me pankun (like a pancake ahaha)
i have an old laptop i bought on ebay and it runs surprisngly well
my other laptop is so bad tho
it takes about 30 minutes to load the game on that one oof
Omg
orz i tried to play maplestory 2... it was so slow and laggy i was unplayable x(
Stardew runs perfect since it is not demanding like other games
my other laptop couldn't even run stardew XD
omg orz that's horrible
my laptop can just barely run it, but its laggy sometimes
tbh ive been wanting to play more sims 4 but the game is so damn buggy???
every time abby interacts with our pet hedgehog she just kinda loses all of her brain cells and stands there forever
and i cant do nothin about it
oof 😭
in other news, elliot is being created
hows his face look?
also i have so much custom hair it's impossible to find anything ahaha
findally found his fair lmao
omg the game crashed
but thankfully RIGHT AFTER I SAVED
halleluja
shit it's 3am
better go to bed anythings, it's a sign
noight 😴
they hugg
schleep & hugg
lol
mood though
aaaaa so cute!!
(@dense bloom You leveled up to Villager! You can now join voice chat and all public channels. See #445729591533764620 for more info. Keep up the good work!)
oh shi
welcome to the real server now
Jfjdhd,, Yoba has blessed thee-
you’re perfect
🚢
i cant make loud noises in happiness my family is sleeping
It’s never to early
put a pillow on your face and then you can make not loud noises and not wake the fam
thats true i already do that
@fleet gazelle why are u killing me by being so damn smooth
How, I just copy what you said and put you in it pretty much

Thats still cute
im tempted
fine be smooth
idm but ok thanks lmfao 
Lmfao
I'm smooth as a roll of sandpaper
sketch
im drawing sebastian and my farmer cause i have art block™
its so cute.. I love how you draw Sebastian 💜
quick, Draw!
bang!
bruh this makes me feel so good though cause Im getting into art again
oh I know it looks bad trust me 😂
hit me though
the feet I'm guessing
Im just getting general shape
Actually, I was just critiquing the overall style. I can't speak for everyone becomes y'all have different artstyles, but generally creating flowing lines is better than creating multiple short lines. (Which is called "Chicken Scratch")
Though it is sometimes easier to create shapes with Chicken Scratch than flowing lines
oH! I know what you're talkin about. I don't chicken scratch with my line art, its just my sketches so I can get the overall shape
Ah! Makes sense 😄
sketch part 2- scaling to come soon. How do to do two tails this is hard oh no
throws out half of the piece I knOW what to DO
IM ScrEAming his FEEt
Lol looking good so far
I mean I usually draw cats but this is like different because its been so long
like
;-; I wish I didnt stop lol
🤷 It's from a year or two ago
kitties
Im gonna be drawing arms and hands later and im very afraid
But Im super happy with my current work so ehhhhh

im trying to figure out how to handle abby's left arm/hand here
idk where to put it
it could go underneath erin and extend to the otherside, but its not comfortable for someone (especially when they are bigger than you) to sleep on top of your arm
Curled up by her tummy? Sometimes I do raptor hands when im sleepin near someone
i have an anatomy freak in another discord telling me it wouldn't be very convenient because erin is slightly on top of her but idk, my intention was just for them to be super duper close
See, this is an example of anatomy over style. Sometimes you're gonna have sacrafice something
thats fair!
still, im struggling to get it to look good to me when doing that. im trying something else a bit goofier
abby looks like she's throwing a spear
LOL
also im not really sure if its necessary to speak to me in that tone, Arcfire.
you could've told me that in a much nicer way
@devout stream Ah crap, I honestly didn't mean anything bad on you. I only now just realised how poorly I worded that.
its all good friend! it just felt a bit condescending
What I meant to put across was that I personally feel like sometimes when it comes to anatomy and style, one might have to give way a bit. It was just since you mentioned your anatomy friend who was concerned about the pose
But I'm probably talking nonsense anyway. I'm the least qualified to make a judgement on someone's artwork
So apologies if my tone sounded off
I don't disagree! and you saying that made me realize that. :D
Ultimately, you do you. To me the pose looks great but again, someone more qualified might have a more worthwhile opinion
hmm? I haven't made the pose suggested yet. :P
Ah my b, I just meant the last one you posted
with abbys left arm being on her tummy n stuff. instead if what I tried right there
my farmers boob looks like its being squashed LOL
why do u think it'll turn out bad !! it looks super cute so far turret
oh ;p ty
forever mystified and amused by how we all automatically put “no mecha” on our commission posts no matter what kind of artist we are/fandoms we’re into as if we think someone’s going to come hurtling out of the abyss and demand an optimus prime pinup
3750
10995
LOL
I mean, don't they?
mecha is fun tho
LOL thats so tru tho
that always mad eme laugh sdfghjk
Arms are a pain. Thankfully the outfit doesn't cling so muscle tone isn't important.
The other arm though will hurt. I want it bent upwards as she's holding an axe but eeeeh
Also ignore the dumb doodle in the top left lmao
Gonna have to make the torso part of her clothing more baggy - while making sure she's covered up obvs
damn wood burning looks so cool
So apparently I've thought about that murder mystery au a lot more than I'd realized
literally took me 10 minutes but this is me when people talk about that italy trip i got banned from going on
Wait why did you get banned
this is my friend alice in this drawing style im kinda addicted to
ok yes it was
everyone was slapping each oither
other*
literally
and im a bit too strong
so...yep you know what happened
oooh lookin good sakura
Oh neat
In that case I suggest you wear a button microphone, and a video if you can get it
it doesnt matter anymore
and this is my friend jacqueline (the head is creeping me out)
yeah ig
idk why i drew her head so long
thank chu!
God I cant draw hands or arms to save my life but this is going well
thats wonderful
That looks pretty good so far!
If I did some SDV woodburnings would there be a markett for them?
maybe on etsy
but it’s kinda eh
i would advertise them on the subreddit before hand
I guess more specifically if ppl would be willing to commission em :0
ok so uh
I mentioned this before but not in this fashion
I have a gigantic fictional universe of mine; what'd be a good way of representing it? (I have a webcomic planned but I'm more than happy to switch to something else if I like it more)
game? if you’re up for that
ehhH
the game I'd like to make would require a.. more than sizable team and funds >.>
Dani, that's a complicated question, but a webcomic seems like a safe bet. If you're confident in writing prose, then try writing a story about the world from the perspective of one of your characters- although, as always, you'd have to prioritize writing a compelling story over world-building your universe, and if that's a compromise you're willing to make, then go for it.
I already have a story and decent worldbuilding, everything is set, I literally just need some form to represent it.
:y
If you're good at/confident in your drawing ability, and can pump out work you're proud of at a rate you like/that will satisfy your audience, then a webcomic would be best. If you're not quite there yet, then go for writing prose. Or do whatever- I can't stop you.
Judging on the fact that you're in the "creative" tab, I'm guessing you can draw pretty well, but that's just a guess.
I can't say if I"m good or not, rip
damn i feel bad for all the brazilian artists rn
Care to elaborate, Jev?
apparently they made changes to paypal so that residents of brazil cant send money internationally
ive only heard this from one person so far though
so i dont have a huge grasp on it yet
heres what they said
i made abigail uwu
oh thats cute,,
thank bless u
shane and elliott are my faves so i'm makig everyone else but it's not as fun lol
that hair mod is gorgeous
he
has
been created
I am in a state of immense fear
14kx image dimensions
for reference that's a world map so it's somewhat justified???
prayin for u friendo
me, ten minutes ago, naive and innocent: abigail's hair looks so fun to draw!! :D
save me
o o f f f f ff f f
I'll set you an alarm, so you can be woken up inside.
ty jv
And if you can't wake up, I'll call your name, but I'm not sure if I'll be able to save you.
Woo my essay is done so now I can stare at a new document and not actually convince myself to write
Or suddenly start writing
One or the other
@fringe coyote that stuff you're doing with people in the Sims is inspiring me to do some character creation of my own in another character creator
speaking of which, hey Fable
what is Alex's eye color?
Uhhhh well it kinda depends because it isn't super clear. I think it's green but I know some people see hazel
that's what i was thinking
green?
green
I think green is the prettier option
Oh my
tried to keep it faithful color wise
game is XCOM 2
i actually posted one for Abby about a week ago
What happened to his hair :U
Nah it's more wavy imo
like I don't want it to clean, cause I'm trying to find something that keeps with the sorta spiky ends his hair has
this a little better?
I'd say that's def closer
She looks like she'd stab me with no hesitation
she has a machete and a knife
Dear God
hanging off her back
@pastel iris hope it isn't rude to directly ping you, but it kept saying you were typing something
is there something you wanted to say?
rofl
@frozen plaza wait what game is that?
XCOM 2
ah, never heard of it, the characters look good!
forgot to remove the soncihu from my name, that's done now
lmaoo
also it's an alien invasion strategy game
and my idea with the Abigail was to give her a sword of sorts, cause of that one heart event
dude hell yeah i did the same thing
when i played XCOM 2
mine looked different than that
Damn, was not expecting that
Commander's Choice helps a bunch if you wanna consistently give someone a class
great mod
:000
😮
im not really interested in making the game harder
I'm gonna finish harvey, do one of my oc, then maybe maru or penny
that's fine, WOTC is more fun then base, and some of the stuff can make it easier then base
i rage really hard at RNG mechanics so yeah
i try to just sorta keep the game the way it is in terms of difficulty
I can share a few of the things if you want me to take it to pm
i thought i had screenshots hmm =\
cause i've probably taken this channel way off art topic
DAMN
thats nuts
the character is rena from granblue fantasy
damn the only character i know from that is ferry..............
and ferry is cute........
yea ferry cute
I'm thinking of drawing bachelors and bachelorettes as professional (based on vanilla aspects) do you think that my ideas make enough sense?
Abigail : Sounds out of realism but professional monster hunter does suit her for me or professional drummer if sam's band is implemented very well and successful, then a traveler, the last choice is simply shopowner, inherited from pierre
Emily : from her hobby, most obvious choice is clothing/fashion designer, then model or psychiatrist, I could even picture her taking over gus' saloon for reason as the last choice
Haley : It's not that much different from her sister, most obvious choice is photographer/fashion designer/model, I couldn't see the other choice besides those
Leah : everything's about her hobby no doubt, 1st choice is all-around artist who's creating whatever art and the last choice is specialised on certain aspects like just painting/sculpting/any sort of arts
Maru : a bit of combination of leah and maru, she got a hobby and I could see a possibility she could have a skill on teaching someone, so 1st choice for me is robotic mechanic, then the last choice could be scientist just as her father and might be possible to be a teacher just like penny
Penny : teacher as the topmost choice ofc since she loves children, last choice is lecturer based only on her teaching skill, I couldn't think something else on her lmao
alex is professional cuddler
penny could be librarian I always get that vibe with her in the library
I'll post bachelor on different post cuz of limit discord length of post xD
@pastel iris what about a nurse practitioner for Maru? or anything medical related
alex - instagram thot
BE NICE!!!
tbh, I can see Haley as a photographer turned social media influencer. I just
imagine Haley as a youtuber
I can totally see Alex being an instagram thot
spends all his time at the gym working out or taking selfies
imagine any of them as youtubers. it'd be a travesty
harvey is a better househusband
Lies
my househusband will beat urs in a househusband fight
Your househusband is 40 and dying
Sebastian has a youtube channel dedicated to dnd
Haley: hey guys welcome to episode 57 of my minecraft asmr lets play
why would you say that
urs is like 20 and has dozens of gridball concussions
It's the truth
alex peaked in highschool
well we don't know if there are youtube or instagram in sdv world, it's hardly a choice
social media seems likely, though
oh and about maru's nursery stuff I'd like to agree on that
I've come to the conclusions that my lizard brain thinks concussions=love
I mean Jackson has now been concussed twice in my fic
Concussions only equal love if you love your doctor.
it happens
concussions=love
my househusband will treat your househusband's broken bones
I mean, I doubt gridball is any safer than any other contact sport
fanfic where Harvey sits down with Alex and explains the dangers of repeated, minor head trauma
ive stopped shipping my oc w/ morris and now ship him with harvey and god
my oc is a little dirt gremlin who eats bugs
harvey is very concerned
I don't mean to be rude
all day
But I can't tell how serious any of y'all are.
'wash your fucking hands you were just outside in the dirt'
wdym
I'm about half serious at all times
the other half is chili dip that I eat like soup
Honestly Spoonie that's just where my fic is going rn
Harvey is going to have to sit Alex down and go "please stop hitting this boy's head with things he's dying"
I dunno, I just can't tell if any of these fan-fictions are real, imagined/not on paper, or japes.
Mine is very real
Good to know.
In my fic Jackson has been concussed twice now
my ideas are all Linus and Wizard kissing and they don't exist yet
but they will
one day
Alright, I suppose I'll give this "fanfiction" thing a shot...
Concussion 1- Crashed headfirst into Alex's chest while blindly chasing a slime at 12am
Concussion 2- Playing catch on the beach and someone had to be a clown
Concussion 3- ???? Bound to happen
how many ribs did alex break
No one cares about his ribs
cause if its strong enough to concuss its strong enough to crack a rib
not necessarily
It wasn't actually a real concussion lol, just enough to daze jackson and leave a bruise on Alex
Second was a real concussion though
Many "mild" concussions are just as serious and can cause similar side effects with less trauma
This is true!
and honestly, most of the danger of contact sports is the non-concussive blows anyway
All you need to do is rattle the brain a bit
yknow thats fair
I had a friend who's been concussed many times
i only ever hear about like,, high schooler gets slammed into wall sorta concussions
I actually consulted her on it
alex punches holes into the wall and shows it to the farmer
Jackson's first incident was a very very mild concussion, not enough to knock him out for very long but enough to daze him. Second was enough to trigger a stutter for a bit
I was amazed to learn that you don't even need a head injury for trauma similar to a concussion
and you don't need a concussion to have noticeable side effects
they're not necessarily severe, but they can be noticeable
for bachelors,
Alex : this is very hard choice for me, he seemed like wanted to be professional gridball player but I doubted him because of his.. Indecisiveness? I could depict him as gymnastic professional but back again on indecisiveness, sorry alex lovers, but I'd be open for any reason to refute my statement
Elliott : writer or pro fisherman, I could depict him being model because imo he's fabulous
Harvey : he's already a doctor and he seems enjoying it than his hobby on planes stuff, so pilot is the next choice, and the last choice could be scientist for him
Sam : professional guitarist and songwriter, if he could make his band into realism and successful, I'm not going to say just because his side job is cleaner means this is the last choice for him, if he prefer enlisted to the army just like his father? who knows?
Sebastian : from game developer, IT support, web designer, programmer, he could even be professional syntetizer if sam's band were successful
Shane : Poultry farmer no doubt, might even include butchery but i'll leave it to your imagination, last choice is he'd taking over marnie's job
My question now is how to treat this current concussion. I had Alex care for the farm for that night but honestly Jackson probably won't be well enough to run things alone for a bit
Alex needs to do a complete 180 and realize he loves. accounting or something. but I think he'd enjoy helping run a community gridball team. Published author for Elliott is golden.
Sam. Yeah, professional guitarist/songwriter works. Maybe with a military-based spin? Benefit concerts and the like?
Sebastian has a genuine passion for coding, so those work. And Shane is definitely just a farmer.
alex does accounting? xD sorry if it sounds rude but it's a bit off
CA really needs to overwrite alex, I felt bad for him
I can see Alex going into Philosophy based on that heart event
I just want him to like more things than gridball okay
Alex doesn't need a rewrite what :U
Eventually he won't be able to destroy his knees and brain cells anymore
not his overall
Alex's whole thing is realizing that his plans for the future weren't necessarily realistic
And that he can learn to be content with who he is, where he is
I have never actually gotten more than like. 5 hearts with Alex
jeez
I just realized that
All of his events are fine as is honestly, the only one that I could see getting changed is the catch event. All the others serve their purpose
the catch event is kind of cute, though
It is
like, it's very. sweet? it's a sweet lil interaction and I like that all the marriage candidates get at least one somewhere
but I think he'd enjoy helping run a community gridball team
I like this
And it's the event I turned into Jackson's second concussion
well perhaps it's like., there are some events on him could be combined as one
There is depth in Alex, even if it's tiresome to get to it.
like perhaps the catch event is combined when he talks about his deceased mother
I need to get to it. My first, full run was all over the place and I didn't even complete everything xD
That's way too early tho
I don't mind the catch event as its own thing
Alright, are y'all ready for some unrelated idiocy from yours truly?
Are you gonna be a clown
The only story I've come up with so far is one where the wizard, in his infinite genius, creates a staff that breaks the barriers between worlds and allows various other fictional universes to mingle with SDV's, letting all manner of stupidity happen, including, but not limited to: -Donkey Kong becoming a local philanthropist. -John Wick becoming a dating candidate who will only date women and will steal your dog if you divorce them. -Ripley from the Alien franchises has her hair braided by Jas as they talk about boys and space travel. -The anime girl from Death Road To Canada overdoses on anime and dies a horrible death in the town square. -Jake the dog escapes his dying cartoon universe and lives a quiet, mournful life in a shop tended by a rifle-vending skeleton. -Marnie discovers that she has occult powers capable of making her a demigod, but she just tends to animals instead. The working title I have for it it Stardew Valley: Horrible Meme Editon, and ideally it would be a huge content mod that would add late-game progression. It ain't gonna happen, though.
wh
Yep
You were being a clown
whew lad
why do you think alex's 10 heart is a total disappointment?
I would like to say I haven't thought about it extensively, as a sort of "Calamity Mod" for Stardew Valley, but I have.
I don't have the coding prowess, though, so I'll just let it be.
I'm really tempted to add in my farmer as an npc
I couldn't see it as romantic thing compared to the others, it's not like to made him doing kiss or whatever, but to my eyes it's just like a simple date for me
I mean, isn't that the most realistic though?
hmm that's fair
Just a simple date
hopefully the new update does alex more justice
not 10
he was my first 10 heart I didn't realize the others were more... intimate until later
sam
Honestly the simplicity and fairly candid realism was what makes it appealing to me. Everyone else is a fairly grand sweeping gesture of some kind or some kind of hijinks whereas Alex is very down to earth and candid
I was expecting harvey's 10h to be a lot more serious than it was
harvey's was cute
also how he ordered the food is a bit off
Alex was a reminder that he's just a normal dude doing what he felt was best to express his feelings
yea,,,
Ok I can agree that ordering for you was def odd
he took a steak for him, and a salad for me, alright :/
sounds like hes gonna fight
That is the only thing I'll agree with though
Ugh I'm def not gonna write anything tonight
'fuck i stress myself out way too much with the townspeople'
you have a little heart to heart
but still, I couldn't understand your view of down to earth somehow? 
I did like how he expressed his insecurity about liking another guy (if applicable)
he arranged a fancy date
That's part of what made it so realistic
He's a dude who legit struggled with his sexuality if you were a dude
Instead of just "lol playersexual don't question it"
alex 
Well, I'll let you all ponder about your stories about head trauma. G'night, and don't go to bed too late!
I'm mostly pondering where to go. I didn't actually expect to hit Jackson this hard. Originally it was just gonna be a bloody nose
alex is a good boy
Buuut the moment asked me to make it a full ass YEET
care to enlighten me about struggling with sexuality?
In what way?
ofc alex is a good boy, who said he's bad
well anything on your point of view?
just in case I might got it wrong
well for starters, george is very judgmental about alex dating another man in the beginning
thats hard on alex
So Alex immediately reads as a dude very confident in a heteronormative sense. He reads as very solidly heterosexual, and you see it through stuff like how he tries to bond with a male farmer by talking about chicks
ahh that george comment kills me!!! but I'm glad he comes around eventually
prehistoric tool,,,,
It isn't until the 8th heart event where we really start seeing some of his worldview brought into question. It's there that the emotional vulnerability makes him sincerely question his worldview, and though we don't see it his 10 heart tells us that he sincerely struggled with it
well for starters, george is very judgmental about alex dating another man in the beginning
perhaps I'll rummage george dialogue for this o.O
I literally have no idea lmao
10 heart implies he actually liked the farmer for a while, but didn't accept those feelings because he "wasn't allowed to" essentially
man i need to romance alex so i can see this LORE
this man has layers
In 8 heart you teach him you're allowed to be something other than what society expects
hell yeah
He learns from that and tries to be truer to himself
alex is honestly one of the best written characters, yet so many ppl write him off as a generic jock in the beginning and never take the time to get to know him
^^
I agree
He struggles with his sexuality because he comes from a culture where deviation from the norm isn't allowed.
Do any other characters have any like, struggles w/ sexuality similar to how Alex does?
I personally blame his father and that's what my story will explore
dont think so
Not that i know of
Uhh I think one of the girl bachelors and Sebastian do?
I want to say sebastian says something similar
most characters barely even reference it, besides abby who has 1 line in her 8 heart event
Sebastian was a passive comment though
Alex was the biggest "struggle" the others just kinda say "yeah I didn't expect to fall for you but I did anyway lmao"
yeah abby merely says "i didnt know i felt this way for other girls, until i met you"
which... i still like
makes me blush every time
.>
Is it consistent with the other bachelor/ettes that they make 'i didnt realise i was gay' comments
if harvey doesnt have one im gonna shit
Most romance candidates don't reference it
harvey comment on me being a big gay already
):<
I think Elliott does as well
smelliott,
i think its easier for girls to like other girls too than it is for men to like other men. not trying to belittle the struggle homosexuals experience, but i feel like men get a harder time for it? does that make sense? im sorry if this sounds ignorant. im a gay girl
I actually rly don't like Elliott's 10 heart at all
@devout stream there's a huge discussion there but tl;dr you aren't wrong
You aren't totally right but you aren't wrong
^^
Buuut not really an art convo lol
harvey doesnt comment on it at all
i think sam might've said the same thing as abigail says too
true, its slowly drifting away from stardew xD
so do the other older bachelors
Yeah iirc Sam did
Elliott does
abby's line is specific to her 8 heart event, its not generic dialogue so idk
a h really
Gah I've only romanced Alex and Sam so I don't remember who else said stuff
Not sure about Shane?
shane doesnt
ill have to relearn all this lore when i replay when the update comes out
this is random i skimmed, i do think the characters in-game are playersexual but i also think that just means you have a lot of wiggleroom with what you want to do and the stories you want to tell. they do recognize gay relationships though with diff dialogue which is really cool
i think most of them have different dialogue when you're with specific
sebastian does i remember
Leah is the only one that canonically isn't playersexual
...Ironically due to player influence but still
the fact her sexuality changes depending on the players gender kinda still makes it playersexual?
Yeah her ex is always the same gender as the farmer ye
she mentions being gay if you are a girl and choose (creepy) dialogue
It's a confusing thing because it both is and isn't playersexual
Because if you don't romance her as a female she still has a female ex
its a really cool detail
yee
i like it
i do like the aspects that suggest that maybe the world doesn't revolve around you
but even so there's still a lot to play with
Overall I do think CA really thought the world through
And thought the romance candidates out quite a bit
Emily is the only one I don't think really got fleshed out much and that's due to update reasons
i feel like it might just be harder for people to relate to emily
personally i love her because i have a soft spot for spiritual people
emily doesnt really have any struggles does she?
Its said often but ty CA for bein woke
but that is something that tends to be hit/miss
It doesn't help that her heart events don't really have a sense of progression and that one was a dream sequence the player wasn't there for
no she doesn't unless you count clint's thing for her as something
thats definitely more a clint struggle haha
yeah
let clint get the girl!!!
the player is also absent for the bird one too
The other romance candidates either have an overarching plot or a sense of actual progression in their heart events, but Emily lacks anything like that
Yeah the player being AFK for so long really doesn't help
people might disagree but i do feel like in general the bachelors have more progression/story than bachelorettes
There isn't any real interaction between them for a while
You're correct I think Jade
but it could be personal bias too, i never felt connected in most events
This doesn't mean the bachelorettes lack progression, but overall the bachelors have the more "memorable" stories
Shane existing there doesn't help :U
obviously you can call me bias but i think abby has the best heart events & writing of the females but i think thats also because she was one of the first characters implemented
penny, abigail, and leah have more story bits
Because his has full throttle impact
i would say the weakest for bachelor is probably elliott
but most of them have like solid progression in some way
Yeah I can't say I'm a fan of Elliott because I don't think his character ever actually went anywhere
i like my boy but harvey gotta be the weakest
elliott drinking and being a doofus during that one heart event was a TRUE fresh breath of air
I love the dude
he doesnt really have a storyline
but they just kinda drop it
Elliott was just like him writing,,, his book
Harvey never felt like he needed to go anywhere as a character, but Elliott was sold as this bookish hermit
Harvey was eh?
i think it also just depends who we like too and what we find interesting in people, our real life prefs do influence how we take stories and i think that might've been something CA had in mind too when writing, even if not super intentional
Of course
For sure
which is why i think the guys might have more story and the girls might have more events than stories
That's just how writing works
Not everyone needs an extreme arc either.
harvey i feel like was nearing the end of the his character arc before the farmer even arrived, and the farmer just ties it up in a pretty bow
anyone know what marus 8/10 heart was?
Sam has a great arc and it's super down to earth and simple
his events were cute but no buildup or a clear story line
telescope, jev
it was telescope or get- ok yeah telescope
but the 8+ ones are his best events
' < '
Sam is CUTE
sam is def cute
maru's 8 is the electrocution one
And I've decided him and the gang are gonna help Jackson with the farm in the story
It's gonna be GREAT
6th?
Oh my God Abigail can wrangle the loose slime
THAT'S WHO'S GONNA CATCH CHICLE IT'LL BE ABIGAIL
yeah telescope is 6th
I read a fanfic once where a bunch of the marriagable people ended up moving in with the farmer for various reasons and it was So Cute And Lovely
Finally I have a reason to do things with Abigail's character
discussing about sexual struggle is quite difficult since I haven't experienced that, I guess that's a fair point
Sexuality struggles are one of those things I recommend you avoid writing if you don't have any experience with them honestly. It is super easy to mess them up and make them less than stellar
There's a lot of cliches and tropes that can both hurt the writing and piss people off
hell even as someone who is going through sexuality struggles i have no clue how to write em
at the same time I think if I tried to write about it I think I the character's struggles would eventually mimic my own, even if I wasn't trying to do that on purpose
certainly a challenge to think about it in another person's voice I suppose
You write your experiences, it's just a part of writing
Your characters reflect you in some way at the end of the day
yea
although still, even george's dialogue about 'unnatural' seems appealing, it's still somehow.. how can i say this
I mean he only said that to the farmer, not likely he's criticising alex for doing same-sex relationship directly
so I couldn't see if that is 'hard' on alex
ahh I'm inspired to start writing!!
George's statement there says enough about his mindset
He's criticizing your relationship
if George can speak like that to someone not family, I think he'd be willing to speak like that to Alex too
He'd be more than willing to be ruder to Alex if anything
^^
Married
its really not complicated, azrael. it hurts when your family doesn't support your personal choices. and stardew valley is a flowing world where things are happening and conversations between people are happening even when the player does not experience them directly. imagine what george is expressing to alex when you are not around
That's an important thing to remember in any game. There's stuff that happens when you aren't there to see it
The world is alive without the player watching
and alex is NOT the type of person to shrug off ignorant family members, his grandparents are all he has left
Ooh thanks for that insight Key that's useful
it can differ from person to person, i couldnt care less if my family didn't support my sexual preferences. im not close with them and ive never been a super "i love my family" kinda person... it sounds cruel but ive just always been a loner.
but alex?
dude lost his mom to an illness, and had a drunken abusive dad. his grandparents took him in, and then his grandpa judges him for loving someone?
It's not a hard thing to mod, but I think that dialog would really benefit from some of that old timer "I'm trying to understand" allyship
which I'm inevitably going to do
Not everyone wants that reminder in their game, in much the same way I can't stand Demetrius being so overprotective. I've dealt with that before, I know people who've dealt with that before, and I don't want to deal with it in fiction if it's not going to lead to growth.
and even then. eh.
demetrius - dont you go near my daughter
me - married to a 40 year old man who is old and dying
pffft
obviously you're free to mod the game however you wish, but thats just reality and part of writing good characters is putting them into recognizable situations
oh absolutely
It just puts me off building that relationship. Like. I don't want to marry Alex if I have to deal with that. It's upsetting to me, and there's no recourse.
thats fair, but if you're really into the roleplay of things, then love should always prevail
Oh absolutely
(if you're not, thats fine too lol, just saying)
oh absolutely
yeah I'm very into the roleplay of each save, which is actually one of the reasons I care to mod it the way I do
ive never considered doing like rp in game
They don't need to be perfect or infallible. I just want them to learn and be the kind of people I'd work to befriend really closely.
ty keychain
The old man can be homophobic, but I'd like him to eventually. Not be.
LOL @ morris
he is eventually nnot, spoonie :0
he will eventually become supportive of you and alex!
well that's good
is it only with alex that he makes comments?
i believe so yeah
perhaps it's just our point of 'hard' is different, if I imagine george criticise me for that.. well back about 'grumpy old man' for me, at least he didn't tried to stop my relationship, just a gauge of leek will shut him up anyway lmao
I've experienced about parents not supportive about personal choice, both of my parents criticised my choice just because I wanted to be game developer but they never hindered my attempts on it, again, people are different so.. I'll take that as good point
man azzy english not being your first language really shows sometimes.. no offense buddy. its hard to have a full conversation with you sometimes.
being unsupportive of career
isnt on the same level as being unsupportive as sexuality tho
*of sexuality
^^
I know so many people whose parents/families have come around, but they're still traumatized by it. So I imagine some people would like an option where George is still true to his character and doesn't necessarily understand, but he's supportive.
a career is something you can more or less help, change, you cant change who you love or what gender you love
like, you Pick your career
you dont got a choice about sexuality, sexuality is Just Part Of Who You Are
you mentioned about choice before, I thought you're generalising about sexual and career, but anyways I agree with your points
that's what matters
like, supportive from the get go
correct me if im wrong azrael but i believe we had this discussion in DM's before
not specifically about george but about homosexual struggles.
anything about DM is discussed in DM, no need to bring it contents here, also key, I think this is different, I'm sorry if it sounds offensive but I never meant that way
i didn't reveal contents of DM
im wondering why this general concept is still difficult for you to process ._.
anyways
stardew got sum pretty good writing and we may be looking at more depth in 1.4 and i cant WAIT
it's going to be very exciting
lord i cannot wait
I'm looking forward to the additional lore/progression that further lore/progression can be built on
im going
to draw so much
if abby even gets
1 more heart event
which she will, im pretty sure, based off of CA's Q&A
im going to draw SO MUCH
you come into abby's room
youve been dating for a while
she's on the floor
she's choking
she ate too many rocks
nothing says romance like someone throwing up gravel
meanwhile i get shit for drawing like 5 pics of morris
slams fist on table morris is hot nobody can argue otherwise
wwwwwwwwwww
ur more thann welcome to like whoever u like
but no wait george comes around tho cause like. yeah, he makes the comment, but its in past tense?? he even tells you that he supports you both now
He does come around yes
if she's choking you should do the heimlich maneuver DX
its never brought up prior to him saying he supports you
makco shhh
theres never a big bad convo about it
again i propose that we wheel george into the lake
that came off
a lot harsher
than i meant
i like george :c
hm
thats from the same conversation
No
theres never any confrontation
is it? the tone really takes a 180 then
hes telling you how he used to think and how he supports you
It's really not the same convo, trust me I've seen it so many times now
yeah i don't think it is
The first cap is before you have 10 hearts
Then at 10 hearts he changes and says the I used to think line
idk man ive romanced alex a lot but ive never gotten that without having the good talk?
And then says the thing in the bottom cap
They're both separate dialogues
I hate to say you're just misremembering but you're def just misremembering
it really wouldn't make sense for it to be the same conversation either
the first cap is just a completely different mindset and tone
shrugs
Yep. And the bottom cap having the star for the heart box shows the change too
If they both had the red circle I'd accept I was wrong but they don't
I have an eye for detail 😉
what if
Alex x Abigail
no
just Throwing It Out There
thats illegal
abby would strangle alex
Alex x Sam
Alex x Sam is top tier for me outside OT3
that sounds precious
Alex x Sam is Way better than Alex x Abigail
im kinda surprised alex and sam aren't friends tbh
or well. OT4 if I'm involved
true
tbh, Sam seems the type to Befriend All
sam just seems like the type of person who would play catch with alex
if I had any clue how to write Alex, I'd totally write for that
Sam and Sebby 
like the one thing i dislike about liking older bachelors is there's nobody to ship em with outside of ocs
DAMN thats true as hell
such a good boy
sam is junk
oof
There's a reason I made him effectively Jackson's best friend
tru but i love him
like who tf i gonna ship harvey with
@echo mesa befriend Alex, marry Alex, then dig through the files and read through his dialog a bunch
pam???
i am junk too
its better than pock 😭
Sam is a blast to write for and his almost puppydog like nature is refreshing
if I did that tho
I'd have to Stop Obsessively Playing Skyrim for a while
Harvey and Penny would be p cute
im so dumb
as much as I love Penny and Maru
I love Harvey and Penny
theres this rly good fic about em on Ao3 but it hasnt been updated in Ages and I'm Cry
Harvey and Elliott?
simple
harvey/demetrius
oh my god
science dads!!
this is just crackship central now
I vow to never be a writer who leaves a decently popular fic un-updated for months
science dads
i love crack ships
bless u Fable

who'd be the best person for a Robin and Demetrius ot3

I say decently popular because I've ignored my Pokemon fic entirely




