You have to BOOST manual defending because right now it is the most random mechanic in the entire game.
Every time I switch towards my defenders (lb,rb,cb,cdm) it feels like the game decides who has the chance to catch the ball or not, even if I switched and pressed the tackle or X button for advanced defence setting at THE RIGHT TIMING, I don't win the tackle 100% of the times.
Players do not perform the animation even if I'm near opponent's attackers, I would like to know why this happens because I don't understand and this makes me so nervous while playing this game.
CB with bruiser playstyle and nice strenght stats do not win a shoulder/shoulder tackle so many times, this is not correct, fix this.
You have to reward people for manual and not for cpu defending, that is skill gap between player.
Hope you understand, thanks.