#Rework the match rating system on Pro clubs.

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

cyan charm
#

I think ratings should be reworked to be position-specific, with metrics that highlight the actual responsibilities of each role. For example:
Attackers - shooting chances created, goal involvement, key passes, successful dribbles, off-ball movement.
Midfielders - chances created, passing accuracy, progressive passes, tackles/interceptions won, ball recoveries.
Defenders - tackles won, interceptions, aerial duels won, blocks made, clearances, marking effectiveness.
Goalkeepers → saves, punches, claims, distribution accuracy, positioning.

Right now it’s very “one-size-fits-all,” where scoring/assisting dominates ratings, and that doesn’t respect midfielders or defenders who can dominate a game without getting a G/A.

This way, every position can be judged fairly on their true impact, making ratings more realistic and rewarding smarter all-round play rather than just chasing goals.

silk pier
#

This is a good idea

#

Defenders and defensive mids get no recognition in this game…

cyan charm
#

Exactly, the game right now is too biased to attackers, you can have a poor overall game as a striker but if you score a last minute goal your rating skyrockets from 6.5 to 9.0

idle locust
#

It’s easiest for a cam tbh. I score a hattrick while my cam gets 10rating and motm for a bit passing and dribbling and 1 assist

cyan charm
#

I agree, when I was using my spark archetype I found it extremely easy to 10 rating after matches compared to using any attacker build

cyan charm
#

Bump

pastel steeple
#

+1

cyan charm
#

Thanks again

cyan charm
#

Bump

fossil wolf
#

I agree with this, and I even have a ready-made vision for each position on how to calculate it.

cyan charm
cyan charm
#

Bump

wooden dirge
#

Bump

thick breach
#

I completely agree with this.
One thing I’d add is that clean sheets should be factored in, especially for defenders and goalkeepers.
It's true the system encourages players to move out of position just to score or assist. But also, the penalty for not being in the correct position based on the formation is too steep, especially when you sometimes have no choice but to break formation to defend or create a scoring opportunity.

cyan charm
#

Exactly, everyone should be rewarded based on how they played in that position