George was wrong for that
#Ahsoka spoilers
lean sinew
So wrong
candid pine
Palps throwing whole ass booths at yoda while retreating never fails to make me laugh
fierce trout
I wish we got the blaster lightsaber thing in more instances than just ezra
candid pine
Pt a special kinda goofy
lime kayak
Palps throwing whole ass booths at yoda while retreating never fails to make me ...
The fall of democracy! (It rhymes)
I just love how Palpatine only has so much space to move on the centre podium when fighting Yoda
Have you seen the extended fight
Where he hangs onto a camera to escape
George was right cutting that one
candid pine
Lmao
lean sinew
Palps throwing whole ass booths at yoda while retreating never fails to make me ...
Also one of the coldest lines ever recorded and it was Yoda..
tranquil breach
Palps throwing whole ass booths at yoda while retreating never fails to make me ...
With duel of the fates blaring in the background
lime kayak
I like his “forgot to turn of my speeder I have, great toll of full it will use”
solar yacht
solar yacht
Misplaced faith in your new apprentice may be, as is your faith in the Dark Side of the Force. ||I hope I quoted that right 
||
Love that line as well
If so powerful you are line on top
Ice cold
lime kayak
You will not stop me, darth Vader will become more powerful than either of us !
solar yacht
He was true, too bad Obi-Wan put a STOP to that man
fierce trout
Me to the bagging vader who quits before next round of hvv
lime kayak
Me to Ahsoka when she try’s to leave the new galaxy
Thrawn to the witches as he leaves
Anakin to Ahsoka when she tries to wake up from the red mist dream experience
fierce trout
Me to my dad as he's leaving for the grocery store
candid pine
Also why the hell was Ahsoka so happy with being stranded in a galaxy with no way out and thrawn on the loose
I'd be at least a little annoyed
tranquil breach
I am once again asking, how the fuck did ezra escape the chimaera undetected
fierce trout
She's happy she doesn't have to shoot anymore scenes for the godawful show
tranquil breach
She's happy she doesn't have to shoot anymore scenes for the godawful show
For like, 2 years
fierce trout
Only 1 year until peakdor s2 
golden harbor
What is peakdork?
fierce trout
solar yacht
What is peakdork?
golden harbor
<:Washed:767883933190586368>
Swolo
proper totem
Aint no way yall didnt like anakin vs ahsoka
proper totem
https://tenor.com/view/anakin-vader-anakin-skywalker-darth-vader-lord-vader-gif-11388835687802000422
solar yacht
You lack conviction.
solar yacht
Man’s truing
proper totem
Well yeah
Shin and sabine aren't gonna have a same level fight as anakin and ahsoka
proper totem
She kinda won at the end there
But i doubt anakin was fighting to win
More so to teach a lesson
solar yacht
Yeah I don’t think there’s any possibility Ahsoka would triumph over Anakin going all out
They are not in the same tier
We don’t even know that was necessarily “Anakin” either though
Could have just literally been a dream
I.e. ahsoka’s mind
tribal pelican
one thing I think this show has proven
is that there is a clear divide between filoni fans and non filoni fans
tranquil breach
This is star wars, we're more split than the Russian empire after 1917
tribal pelican
yeah but I feel this is only going to get worse
tranquil breach
We finally had some sense of unity with the first 2 Mando seasons and then its...gone again.
tribal pelican
the best way I can put it is
"you didnt like it, not because you grew up, but because filoni fans didnt"
tribal pelican
We finally had some sense of unity with the first 2 Mando seasons and then its.....
mando S2 was the beginning of the end
solar yacht
So, why was Mando season one so relatively good though
What went down
How do they “lose the plot”after season one so bad
Makes me worried for Peakdor.
tranquil breach
It finished after the Trainwreck of Skywalker but yeah
solar yacht
it was fresh
Grogu always carried the show too in a way, from the start. Or shall I say the Child
i’ve only seen Mando season 1 once but I remember it being him doing side guests and shit
Was great
tribal pelican
tranquil breach
reef phoenix
Sabine magic force powers go brrrrr
solar yacht
vernal quarry
I'd have to rewatch his scenes but probably form 5
lean sinew
So, why was Mando season one so relatively good though
A unique star wars premise being explored in a refreshing yet authentic to star wars way
fierce trout
I'd have to rewatch his scenes but probably form 5
It looks like Form V but doesn't really address the core of it, which is immediate counterattack after defending
I believe it's more similar to Qui-Gon's style of Ataru, slowly and methodically overwhelming your opponent
glacial current
why reddit is so braindead
glacial current
I hate the fact that some people cant handle star wars if it doesnt have jedi/sith bullshit
stray crane
Mando S1 is peak star wars imo
i would say mando s2
stray crane
Mando season 2 carried by final ep
i really liked the episode with boba fett
do remember that we received mandalorian season 2 in the winter of 2020
it was absolutely brilliance in spite of all the global hurdles
lean sinew
i would say mando s2
LOL
lean sinew
I hate the fact that some people cant handle star wars if it doesnt have jedi/si...
Truly, it's not like Han Solo was a hugely beloved character or Boba Fett
Every mf these days just wants LED Swords, fuck nuance ig
glacial current
I have a friend like that. If the movie/tv show doesnt have big force drama , he is not interested
glacial current
yep
tribal pelican
Every mf these days just wants LED Swords, fuck nuance ig
marvel brainrot
tribal pelican
that too
fierce trout
why reddit is so braindead
Wtf does peak star wars even mean
This mf is acting like star wars is a genre
lean sinew
Wtf does peak star wars even mean
To me, it means being fresh and authentic to the star wars universe and the way it's niché compared to other universes
Embracing the star wars universe strengths
fierce trout
Damn you'd love the kotor games then
lean sinew
E.g Mando s1 which had lots of callbacks that weren't shoved down your throat, while introducing plenty new that wasn't generic or unauthentic
lean sinew
Damn you'd love the kotor games then
I do. I fucking adore what they explore
There will never be someone like kreia again
fierce trout
I would say mando s2 dropped off but I can't remember a single thing from that season except the ending
lean sinew
Exactly
They dropped that freshness for more blatant callbacks and legacy characters
Like it's enjoyable to watch, but the dropoff in creativity is obvious imo
fierce trout
One valid criticism of andor is the lack of alien species, I get that human actors are easier to work with but there's no reason why more human-looking aliens can't be used
As much as I despise BOBF I actually got excited when we started seeing the twi'lek characters, even if the guy was incredibly irritating
lean sinew
It's like going from Andor to rogue one.. they're both good but we all know Andor destroys it
lean sinew
One valid criticism of andor is the lack of alien species, I get that human acto...
Which is why I say Mando s1 is the best star wars content since PT
Well, before PT lol
Whereas Andor is the best content in star wars
If that makes sense...
fierce trout
I suppose it does, again star wars is a setting not a genre so what mando S1 does well is showcasing the highlights of that setting
Andor just tells a good star wars story
lean sinew
Bingo
Worded it better than I did lmao
I love that Mando s1 both doesn't hand hold AND introduces obviously new details for new fans
It's for casual AND hardcore fans.. which almost no star wars content can say imo lol
fierce trout
All in all it did a good job at revitalising the franchise following the sequels
Shame it ended in travesty
tranquil breach
It really was needed considering it came out before and after TROS
finite saddle
Mid.
tribal pelican
bro dave is gonna retcon the sequels!!!!
tranquil breach
As much as I despise BOBF I actually got excited when we started seeing the twi'...
Twileks, the one Ithorian, the Pykes, Tuskens, Cad Bane (Duros) ect.
tranquil breach
bro dave is gonna retcon the sequels!!!!
I cannot believe this cope existed
tribal pelican
it still does
tranquil breach
It's not as prevalent now because of how obvious it ties into the sequels now
tribal pelican
now the cope is over how criticism of filoni or ahsoka is invalid
embeds keep failing?
lean sinew
Yeah I haven't heard literally anybody complain about this so why me
Had to restart the app... weird asf
tranquil breach
I saw someone say that Filoni is "George Lucas-ing himself"
fierce trout
tribal pelican
co-writes ONE episode of TCW before S7
people think he made the show
fierce trout
Who made rebels
tranquil breach
Yeah
fierce trout
That explains why it’s so mediocre
tribal pelican
its the biggest thing I hate, its ignoring the creative work of all the writers and george lucas to instead give all that credit to one person who was only really a producer
fierce trout
Where’s the rebels bad guy
tranquil breach
How many episodes of Rebels did he write though
fierce trout
its the biggest thing I hate, its ignoring the creative work of all the writers ...
Star Wars fans lack the mental capacity to imagine more than 1 person running a show
It’s the same with people thinking Kathleen Kennedy is the sole reason for the sequels failure
tribal pelican
when mando is good
"filoni and favearu savung star wars!"
when mando is bad
"favearu fell off"
notice how theres a name omitted on the 2nd one
fierce trout
Most of the time only Filoni is praised
tranquil breach
I wonder if he just fell off or if ego got into his head.
He literally stated when the darksaber episode of rebels came out that Sabine was not force sensitive
But he wrote the last episode of ahsoka too
On top of everything else the ahsoka show went out of their way to say about sabine
lean sinew
>co-writes ONE episode of TCW before S7
>people think he made the show
Doesn't mean he didn't have a lot of input
finite saddle
you've been awfully quiet lately Cardooooor
lean sinew
George and Filoni attribute Mauls return to Filoni
finite saddle
awfully quiet
lean sinew
And ahsoka is all him
lean sinew
But he wrote the last episode of ahsoka too
Directed episode 1 and 5 too
Funny how the show got better after episode 5...
finite saddle
awfully quiet
lean sinew
He literally stated when the darksaber episode of rebels came out that Sabine wa...
Yeah I'm still really pissed they gave her the force tbh
Did anyone else notice they retconned Mando Jedi too
Apparently there's been a few now
lean sinew
That explains why it’s so mediocre
Bendu arc is still some of the best original star wars arcs we've had in years
Kanan as a character is nothing special and yet that arc makes me adore him
fierce trout
Apparently there's been a few now
Was it ever stated that tarre vizsla was the only one
I always thought it was merely the first one
lean sinew
No but it was always implied there was only one
But only implied
Isn't that the case in legends/EU too?
That there was only one? Or nah
fierce trout
There haven't been any in legends
lean sinew
Bruh
fierce trout
Boba fett doesn't count
tribal pelican
George and Filoni attribute Mauls return to Filoni
but dont forget who wrote the episode
fierce trout
Maul's return is a pretty shit idea
lean sinew
but dont forget who wrote the episode
Bro Lucas has literally stated that he was opposed to bringing back maul until Filoni convinced him of the arc
Your obsession with RPG books stats and tid bit facts are blinding you
lean sinew
Maul's return is a pretty shit idea
Executed amazingly tho
fierce trout
True
tribal pelican
bro just credit who came up with the idea and not the person who wrote it
lean sinew
>bro just credit who came up with the idea and not the person who wrote it
Once again, Filoni had to convince him with the plan
You don't just say
"maul"
"No"
"Maul."
"No"
"MAUL!"
"okay"
Especially not Vs Lucas
tranquil breach
"Let me Cook"
Actually cooks with bad idea
This is partly why he was so acclaimed in the first place.
tribal pelican
and mauls return was written very well
lean sinew
Because he convinced Lucas of it
tribal pelican
but nooooo we dont credut the writer here
tribal pelican
if filoni wrote mauls return it would have been ass
lean sinew
They BOTH deserve credit dumbass
fierce trout
He can see alternate realities
tribal pelican
all three do
fierce trout
Bro thinks he's dr strange
lean sinew
Dr Memesoon and the Multiverse of Madness
tribal pelican
lucas, filoni and the other lucas deserve credit for mauls return
lean sinew
Why do you think Lucas went from "I don't want maul" to writing an awesome returning arc for him
Was it purely by chance
tribal pelican
george didnt write
fierce trout
fierce trout
👀
fierce trout
What other lucas is there
lean sinew
Fr
fierce trout
Katie ?
lime kayak
Pity you haven’t met the other Lucas
tribal pelican
lean sinew
They*
tribal pelican
just gonna ignore the person who wrote the mauls return arc and nightsisters arc
tribal pelican
refuse?
lean sinew
Yes
tribal pelican
I was waiting until someone pointed it out
lean sinew
Nor does anyone here
.
tribal pelican
because its obvious you dont care that she did write it, because you kept on going about how it was filonis idea
tribal pelican
its the biggest thing I hate, its ignoring the creative work of all the writers ...
thus proving my point
lean sinew
because its obvious you dont care that she did write it, because you kept on goi...
Bro I didn't fucking know because you kept saying Lucas
Next time I'll read your mind
Never heard of Katie Lucas in my entire life
tribal pelican
i never meant katie when i said that
lean sinew
Omfg
Fall in to a Vietnam hole
Obviously she deserves credit given Filoni can't write TV for shit
Chronic strawmanner
tribal pelican
ad hominem
tribal pelican
for...? you proved my argument
lean sinew
I still firmly believe both sides of the Filoni argument are wrong
lean sinew
for...? you proved my argument
Dear lord you're dense... I agreed with you that Katie Lucas deserves as much as, if not more, credit than Filoni
tribal pelican
then we are in agreement
lean sinew
This mf
finite saddle
awfully quiet today cardoor
slate mulch
Bro Lucas has literally stated that he was opposed to bringing back maul until F...
wasn't lcuas's idea for the sequels did include bringing back Maul?
lean sinew
wasn't lcuas's idea for the sequels did include bringing back Maul?
Yes but his mind changed as it always does
Also Filoni was saying bringing him back in the PT whereas Lucas' original design is after the OT
finite saddle
quiet
lean sinew
why was that funny
Skill issue
reef phoenix
I don't like that Sabine magically unlocked the force with like no training.
I just finished the series last night.
lean sinew
I don't like that Sabine magically unlocked the force with like no training.
She had training tbf, but I still hate it
A Mandalorian jedi who only had minor force sensitivity would've been interesting and unique
But they just made it 3 force users with sabers and ig she has blasters
How boring
lean sinew
I hated Morgan so I'm glad she's dead.
She gave out a cool duel before she died
I respect it
tribal pelican
*the cool side of the duel
solar yacht
Did Morgan even get to showcase any of her new powers before dying though?
I didn’t really notice anything
Which kind of suck imo
tribal pelican
she got a cool sword
oh and some tattoos
type in "green flame blade" in the gif search, because its the dnd spell
gives me gifs of the sword from the episode
solar yacht
oh and some tattoos
Is that shit even really tattoo? I always took that as moreso a deformation
As if when the Night Gals become more powerful thru rituals like that, they’re exterior looks become degraded/physically corrupted
I mean, the lead Night Gal just looks like makeup pretty much, but the other two look seriously fucked up
Especially that one Mother
Looks so fucked up
tribal pelican
lean sinew
*the cool side of the duel
What
lean sinew
Did Morgan even get to showcase any of her new powers before dying though?
Nope lol, none
That was Dawson's best fight tho
Imo
All the other ones are sooo slow
tribal pelican
tfw hayden is just styling on her
lean sinew
Which is natural
finite saddle
lean sinew
Those death troopers were so cool ngl
And the entire night trooper force tbh, using that Japanese method of repairing things with gold was such a good concept
finite saddle
my bank finna be empty when the sudden urge to make an army of the undead troopers hits once the ahsoka lego sets drop
lean sinew
my bank finna be empty when the sudden urge to make an army of the undead troope...
What are your thoughts of Ahsoka?
finite saddle
wow ur really asking me that
lean sinew
You've been awfully quiet Valkie
tribal pelican
finite saddle
true
lean sinew
My thoughts are that ahsoka is mid but easily better than Kenobi or BOBF slop
I enjoyed some of it, had its moments
tribal pelican
just me or does kenobi get worse the more you know about other stuff?
lean sinew
Yea
I'm still malding that the people who made the inquisitor castle breaching sequence had no idea that cal did the same thing like scene for scene
Damn Valkie has a lot to say
tribal pelican
takes an hour to type "its mid"
lean sinew
I'm so curious if he loves it or not
He did the Andor thing where he spams GIFs of scenes he likes so maybe
finite saddle
I find the plot compelling, it had me intrigued throughout the entire thing. Mostly interested in where Baylan ends up. Worldbuilding was top notch. I don't like the actresses they chose for Ahsoka and Sabine. Stiff acting. I don't like Sabine becoming force sensitive either.
Visually it was good and the fight choreography felt improved on from other shows. I'd say it's better than middalorian s3, book of bad and obi mid kenobi but not better than andor
lean sinew
finite saddle
like a 7 maybe
lean sinew
I agree with everything except the 7
finite saddle
andor an 8.5
lean sinew
Solid 6 for me
finite saddle
felt it could've done more
tribal pelican
lean sinew
For sure
finite saddle
He did the Andor thing where he spams GIFs of scenes he likes so maybe
Also the actual reason for this
It's a public service
lean sinew
Hey tbh I'm not complaining lmao
finite saddle
I want to supply the people with the good scenes
lean sinew
You got the sexiest Andor GIFs
lean sinew
W
tribal pelican
peakdor
lean sinew
Also I kinda figured you'd love Baylan
Cuz he's stereotypical "based" archetype
But he is badass af tbh....
tribal pelican
titus pullo
finite saddle
yeah he's kind of redpilled
finite saddle
i didn't really get the point of shins character, is she just there to look sabine in the eye every now and then for some lesbian tension or what?
lean sinew
Shin is boring as fuck I'm sorry
Interesting first meeting then she does the same thing for the entire show
And the only face is 😐
"shin your mother just died and murdered your entire family with her, using a rusty spoon"
Shin: "😐"
finite saddle
true
finite saddle
if she wasn't like that for the entire season but instead after baylan left it could've made sense in a way of feeling abandoned/lost
because what is her purpose now like what
lean sinew
Yeahh, it would've been fine if she evolved in to something else or changed over time
But nope
lean sinew
because what is her purpose now like what
A bandit leader on a planet that doesn't matter whatsoever
finite saddle
the only conclusion i can come to is a sort of redemption arc but even that would not be very impactful since she's a shallow character
finite saddle
cgi bro
lean sinew
💀
You can't CGI that sexy face
Nor will he have enough excess scenes to work with
Nor should you do it posthumously without asking
finite saddle
true
finite saddle
A bandit leader on a planet that doesn't matter whatsoever
the planet btw
lean sinew
Like... they'll kick Leia out of an entire movie and reduce her final arc but Baylons story just goes on..?
Tf
finite saddle
the light that baylan stares to is the mortis temple right
so mortis is on that planet
finite saddle
it's interesting though that basically means anakin, ahsoka and obi got basically teleported to another galaxy back then
lean sinew
Yea true
finite saddle
and so that planet probably holds the origins of the force too
lean sinew
Shame it meant fucking nothing because memory erasure bullshit
finite saddle
true
lean sinew
Mortis was such a waste of time and just to be over the top and pseudo meta
I can be okay with the WbW but they saved ahsoka with it AGAIN
finite saddle
one of my top arcs
lean sinew
Anakin being the head lad in it is awesome tho
I LOVE where anakin is at rn
That feels like his prophecy being bigger than Rey again
So nobody can complain
lean sinew
is WbW multiverse or time travel
It has only been implied but I'd guess time travel
Tho it could literally just be space time continuum bs
So it's both
finite saddle
I have a unlikely theory that you've probably heard one similar of but I added my own shit. What if anakin is now the father, and thus rey becomes the new chosen one and that is how they'll redeem the sequel trilogy
because anakin takes a new role right
if that is the case
lean sinew
What would being the new chosen one entail
I can see the first part p clearly tho, it's possible
fierce trout
I find the plot compelling, it had me intrigued throughout the entire thing. Mos...
Book of bad 💀
lean sinew
Book of Bad Feet
finite saddle
What would being the new chosen one entail
Well they say in the show that everything is a cycle
fierce trout
The book of shit
finite saddle
which would imply
that there is a chosen one every time
Anakin was it, then rey is it
lean sinew
WHICH IS WHAT I SAID YEARS AGO
LETSGOOOOOOOO
I know star wars more than felony
Hire me
finite saddle
so you understand
lean sinew
Aw cmon
finite saddle
dont know if im for it but i mean it makes sense
lean sinew
He can be dumb but he was literally taught the entire universe by Lucas
lean sinew
dont know if im for it but i mean it makes sense
I'm the same. I can follow it logically but like.. do I have to? Lol
fierce trout
If I had nickel for every time he was corrected on set regarding lore and character actions...I'd have two nickels
fierce trout
Yeah that and also hayden telling him how anakin would actually behave in ahsoka
lean sinew
Really???
I need this source immediately that is juicy
Hayden stocks are at an all time high, invest now
fierce trout
Idk the source lol I heard it from someone in a server
I believe everything anyone tells me unconditionally
lean sinew
Ok so I've seen the clip, it's more like Hayden going over how he feels anakin should act rather than CORRECTING him
Directors often employ tactics like this as the actor spend years with one character whereas the director spends years with many many more
fierce trout
He'd spend the rest of his life with Ahsoka if he could
solar yacht
That was Dawson's best fight tho
She kinda got that Dune Bene Gesserit-style voice amp and that’s it
lean sinew
He'd spend the rest of his life with Ahsoka if he could
The final conversation ahsoka had talking about anakin was done really really well
I felt a little emotion well up
lean sinew
She kinda got that Dune Bene Gesserit-style voice amp and that’s it
Yeah true lmao, even then the mothers sounded way cooler
finite saddle
wrong link
lean sinew
🐐
Bro actually watched both TCW and Rebels
I love this man
And he used what he watched to influence his Vader in Kenobi and presumably in Ahsoka
Mf goat
fierce trout
Except filoni didn't write any of the anakin episodes bruh
I am now feeling memesoon's hate
fierce trout
Although obv it's not hayden's fault
lean sinew
Except filoni didn't write any of the anakin episodes bruh
What does that have to do with anything
uneven trout
ah
tribal pelican
I am now feeling memesoon's hate
lean sinew
vernal quarry
oh and some tattoos
Don't forget the nightsister mother deep voice echo.
tribal pelican
the demon reverb voice
solar yacht
Don't forget the nightsister mother deep voice echo.
I was really hoping to see the Great Mothers perform some actual combative tricks, or even see the voice echo be used in a practical way (if it has any sort of real ability) instead of just being purely auditorily aesthetic
Hopefully we see that in season two I guess
solar yacht
Yeah true lmao, even then the mothers sounded way cooler
Yeah, way deeper and fuller, Morgan’s voice amp was noticeable but not nearly as much as her parents
lean sinew
And I love that thrawn was the only person ever known to actually get the nightsisters on his side
Feels right
solar yacht
Yeah that’s true, I just can’t wait to see the dark magix in actual combat
lean sinew
Fr
We know almost nothing about magick
They also called it majik or something in the subtitles for Ahsoka
solar yacht
And I love that thrawn was the only person ever known to actually get the nights...
Lmao so true, seeing them say shit like “we are at your service my lord” is kinda jarring but knowing Thrawn and how much of a gangster he is it works
lean sinew
So I wonder is it something different from TCW nightsister magic
lean sinew
Lmao so true, seeing them say shit like “we are at your service my lord” is kind...
Yeah bro is the smoothest talker in the entire star wars universe lmao
solar yacht
So I wonder is it something different from TCW nightsister magic
I read that Sidious for a time was considering taking the Mother Talzin as his Sith apprentice. But then decided not to. Do you think she would have actually allied with him or no?
tribal pelican
probably not
vernal quarry
Talzin is the one who declined. She gave up her son Maul as a bargaining chip / token of appreciation for giving her the offer.
lean sinew
I read that Sidious for a time was considering taking the Mother Talzin as his S...
No, and that's why this information is so interesting to me. Talzin + nightsisters were probably some of the most likely candidates to actually have a chance of stopping palps.. and even the mastermind he is couldn't get them on his side
But thrawn is smarter is a different way, and it was shown by the fact they actually sided with him
stray crane
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHZZBbn2-Uo the soundtrack came out 🥹
lean sinew
Don't agree, but he has the largest pull by far ofc
His work on the sequels were.. alright
lean sinew
Couple amazing themes and the rest forgettable
Ludwig also did a pretty great job putting his own spin on things tbf, the Mando theme is fire
vernal quarry
Don't agree, but he has the largest pull by far ofc
I'm not being serious.
lean sinew
Well I figured you were only partly serious
And i used it as an excuse to be a stinky neckbeard nerd
stray crane
@proper totem hey do you remember the bingo image
solar yacht
No, and that's why this information is so interesting to me. Talzin + nightsiste...
It is extremely interesting. Thrawn is a gangster for sure. For what reasons do you think the Night Gals allied with him then, though? In other words how do you figure Thrawn got them to sign up
tribal pelican
well he is their only ticket out of there
solar yacht
Yeah this is where my lack of background knowledge becomes really apparent
Iderk why Thrawn and Ezra and the Sisters were there to begin with
Is that the Night Sisters’ homeworld?
tribal pelican
its implied
lean sinew
It is extremely interesting. Thrawn is a gangster for sure. For what reasons do ...
Probably some bullshit about the other nightsisters back home lmao
"they're waiting for you with blackjack and hoes, I swearsies"
lean sinew
Iderk why Thrawn and Ezra and the Sisters were there to begin with
End of rebels when Ezra uses the space whales to take out thrawn ISD
Then they crashed on that planet
Ezra ran away from wreckage
proper totem
<@551846594983624755> hey do you remember the bingo image
Yes
lean sinew
Came back to pester thrawn a few times but eventually thrawn built up enough defences that Ezra had to stay away and therefore found the rolly boys
solar yacht
Ah makes sense!
solar yacht
End of rebels when Ezra uses the space whales to take out thrawn ISD
Good ELI5/TLDR.
lean sinew
Yw
lean sinew
Is that the Night Sisters’ homeworld?
Supposed ancient homeworld, long lost. Thrawn had to wake them from I presume a very long slumber
lean sinew
They retconned mandalorian jedi being something that never happens ig
Idk not that dumb
finite saddle
And I love that thrawn was the only person ever known to actually get the nights...
I like that he cares for the people serving under him
Or has respect at least and respects their individuality
tribal pelican
I like that he cares for the people serving under him
sends waves of his own men in the hopes he'll slow down the heroes
finite saddle
Instead of seeing them as mere numbers
lean sinew
Or has respect at least and respects their individuality
Yeah, while also doing what memesoon said
Blurring the line between both is a level of nuance not many characters have
tribal pelican
lean sinew
https://tenor.com/view/command-im-in-command-every-missions-suicide-mission-futu...
At least he doesn't send everybody in to die immediately tho
Bro is hyper efficient
finite saddle
His fixation is a result of autism
grizzled schooner
why reddit is so braindead
Andor isn’t even peak sci fi
That show could have take place in 1930s Germany
It’s political thriller
based in Star Wars
a franchise very deeply rooted in political messaging
(If you’re not braindead)
fierce trout
Can't believe andor had a believable lesbian relationship, too political for my taste
grizzled schooner
Andor is just as Star Wars as any other movie or book or show, it just focuses on a different aspect of it
lean sinew
Can't believe andor had a believable lesbian relationship, too political for my ...
LMAO
grizzled schooner
hsk s pk nuthng
lean sinew
hsk s pk nuthng
Stop doing that
grizzled schooner
N
lean sinew
Zzz
lean sinew
I just continue ignoring those messages
grizzled schooner
What a swell guy
tribal pelican
The amount of cope...
take a sentence and run away with it, the classic reddit mindset
lean sinew
Downvoted for being right
I'd downvote it too ||because they spelt ahsoka wrong||
grizzled schooner
He literally stated when the darksaber episode of rebels came out that Sabine wa...
lean sinew
No idea
It was a weird comment to make
Its when they were talking about how old he is iirc
grizzled schooner
Tor Viszla is supposed to be unique in that he’s so weird
Mandalorian and Jedi mix like
idk
water and oil
Mandalorians, especially back in Tor’s and Huyang’s day, craved war
which is pretty much exactly the opposite of what a Jedi wants
It’s already weird that Tor supposedly exists and I don’t even think he does
grizzled schooner
this writing is ass
lean sinew
Yep I wasn't happy
grizzled schooner
having in universe folklore is cool
lean sinew
If you're gonna make it a norm, don't make something like that a fucking throwaway line
grizzled schooner
Tor being this mysterious guy no one actually knows anything about, being the only one of his class, is cool lore
lean sinew
Thinking with hindsight, I wonder if they did it purely because Sabine being force sensitive makes zero fucking sense otherwise lol
grizzled schooner
We don’t even have any actual images of him
lean sinew
Tor being this mysterious guy no one actually knows anything about, being the on...
Which is why I thought Sabine being a non force using jedi and a Mandalorian was unique af
Now she's just a generic jedi
grizzled schooner
I’ve always wondered what happened to force sensitive mandalorians
I don’t think it’s ever explained, even in legends
Just sending them to the Jedi, the most hated enemy, is uh, cringe
tribal pelican
"mom, dad, im force sensitive"
"hi force sensitive, im dad"
solar yacht
Classic
grizzled schooner
“You’re no son of mine. I WILL NOT HAVE A JEDI IN THIS HOUSEHOLD”
solar yacht
My pops hit me with that one all the time leading up to tea time
“Hey dad I’m hungr-“
“LMAO HEY hungry I’m dad ”
…
grizzled schooner
it’s a classic
fierce trout
It’s already weird that Tor supposedly exists and I don’t even think he does
I used to think that but then I checked canon Mando lore
grizzled schooner
Wdym
fierce trout
There is nothing that says the ancient mandalorians craved war or any mention of seeking glory through war in their creed
All canon Mandos gotta do is wear the armour, protect their family and refuse to take the fucking helmet off ig
grizzled schooner
well that can’t be right
death watch are supposed to be old school mandalorians
and they definitely do all of those things
Are you sure you weren’t looking at specially the Children of the Watch
fierce trout
Idk man but even if warmongering Mandos were commonplace in Tarre Vizsla’s day, there is still no creed or law that explicitly states he needs to be like that
grizzled schooner
Din’s sect is supposed to be weird
fierce trout
So he could’ve just been built different
grizzled schooner
Well yeah but then why would he be the “only one”
fierce trout
Maybe it was just super rare?
grizzled schooner
Theoretically speaking there’s nothing stopping a Mandalorian that doesn’t believe in the glory of war and yadda yadda from becoming a Jedi
fierce trout
But it’s perfectly believable for him to be a Jedi
I used to think that actually contradicted lore
Then I realised that it only contradicts legends lore
And tarre Vizsla is only in canon
grizzled schooner
But Death Watch is built on old legends lore
fierce trout
Nah legends death watch were way different to canon
fierce trout
Canon death watch are more akin to legends True Mandalorians
grizzled schooner
Is that the group of mandalorians that fought in the Civil War
fierce trout
Making them infinitely more based than legends death watch
grizzled schooner
To make Mandalore peaceful
fierce trout
Is that the group of mandalorians that fought in the Civil War
No
True mandalorians were the ones that wanted to uphold honour and a warrior’s code
Legends death watch were fine with barbarism
Actually….I don’t know much about canon death watch. Did they only want to return Mandalore to the ancient days of fighting wars, or did they place an emphasis on raiding and killing savagely?
I always thought it was the latter because in the show they’re shown to bomb civilians and shit
True Mandalorians would never ever do that
grizzled schooner
Definitely the 2nd one
fierce trout
Ok then I rescind my previous statement
grizzled schooner
ok now I’m all read up
TCW is in a weird state of being in both canon and legends although it fits a lot better into the canon timeline
fierce trout
Here is my tierlist:
True mandalorians > canon death watch > legends death watch > pacifist Mandalorians >>> Nite Owls >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Children of the Watch
grizzled schooner
but Death Watch seems to be just as warlike in canon and legends
fierce trout
Ok so maybe tarre Vizsla was just a really rare exception
Like I said there’s no creed or anything stopping him from being a Jedi
grizzled schooner
I kinda just don’t think he’s real, at least what Fenn Rau tells kanan
fierce trout
Idk who fenn rau is
high spire
tarre was the mandalorian jedi
fierce trout
Sounds like glup shitto to me
fierce trout
Rebels bad
fierce trout
My legends Mando brain is instantly repulsed
grizzled schooner
He was the leader of the Mandalorian Protectors
a group of mandalorians
that did stuff
fierce trout
That is absolutely disgusting, thank the emperor I didn’t watch rebels
grizzled schooner
and then they got butchered by the Empire
The guy you’re thinking of Skele is um
Sabine’s brother
I think
No wait
yeah I got nothing
fierce trout
fierce trout
Paz Vizsla?
fierce trout
fierce trout
So then who were the Mandos working for Gideon
grizzled schooner
what
fierce trout
Aren’t they the same people
grizzled schooner
There were no mandalorians working for Gideon
fierce trout
Didn’t mando S3 hint that mandalorians broke him outta jail
grizzled schooner
Didn’t mando S3 hint that mandalorians broke him outta jail
They were stormtroopers using mandalorian tech
fierce trout
I stopped paying attention to the show
grizzled schooner
The one guy
high spire
The guy you’re thinking of Skele is um
gar saxon
fierce trout
Bruh
grizzled schooner
Oh it’s just straight up Gar
grizzled schooner
Even I know you didn’t watch rebels
high spire
yep
fierce trout
Gar Saxon was with maul
grizzled schooner
Yeah and Maul died
grizzled schooner
In the show he’s pro Imperial
high spire
fierce trout
What are you on about
grizzled schooner
you’re high
fierce trout
Was there a comic or smth
high spire
gar saxon didnt die in the clone wars
fierce trout
Where tf did they show that
high spire
in rebels
grizzled schooner
In rebels
high spire
as we’ve been saying
fierce trout
Oh I didn’t watch that shit 💀
high spire
could you please research before you say stuff
grizzled schooner
You monkey
fierce trout
Mb mb
high spire
dont just say “youre wrong im right” when you have no idea what youre talking about
grizzled schooner
fierce trout
Last time I saw him was TCW so
grizzled schooner
Why are we even talking about this
Ok
back on track
I personally think
well, thought
that Tarre Viszla, the Mandalorian Jedi was not real
and was just folklore created to justify a war against the Jedi
grizzled schooner
It doesn’t matter
It’s cool loot
The mandalorians wanted it
and wanted to justify their claim on it via Tarre
however with this new random snippet that apparently Tarre wasn’t the only Mandalorian Jedi and Huyang speaks about multiple
fierce trout
Mfers invented a whole religion just so they could have a laser sword
Tbf so did the Jedi
grizzled schooner
yeah that’s religion
Anyway multiple Mandalorian Jedi having been confirmed to exist by Huyang, apparently
make it more likely that Tarre was real
which makes it the newest of a series of dumb writing decisions
fierce trout
Why
It just provides more evidence for something we’d already assumed to be true
(Except you apparently)
grizzled schooner
Because a mandalorian Jedi is as contradictory and nonsensical as an Eldar Space Marine
fierce trout
Except it isn’t when we’re talking about canon lore
grizzled schooner
Especially back in Huyang’s day
fierce trout
We just been through this 💀
grizzled schooner
except is doubly is considering the canon civil war between the new peaceful Mandos and the old warlike Mandos
🤓 ☝️
fierce trout
Old warlike Mandos doesn’t state that Mandos couldn’t have been Jedi
There is no creed that prevents that
Just the vast majority of them were warriors
grizzled schooner
Yeah but if the old Mandalorians running around were anything like Pre Viszla
then it’s unlikely they’d be considered by the old Jedi order
proper totem
Imagibe not knowing who fenn rau is
proper totem
How about u gulp some shittos
fierce trout
Ok
fierce trout
then it’s unlikely they’d be considered by the old Jedi order
Unlikely but not impossible which is why he was the only one (of that time period)
Then maybe two or three more became Jedi over literal millennia
grizzled schooner
I’m just saying you can’t hold the ideas of both the old Mandalorians and the Jedi
one of them must take precedence
tranquil breach
It's a very strange paradox
grizzled schooner
This isn’t something where you go to football practice at 5 and band practice at 7
In order for a Mandalorian to become a Jedi he or she would have to give up their mandalorian heritage
or culture
or whatever
fierce trout
I’m just saying you can’t hold the ideas of both the old Mandalorians and the Je...
Again there is no creed or code saying they needed to be warriors in that time. Vast majority could've have been but maybe Tarre was just content with following the established code (which doesn't mention warring)
fierce trout
In order for a Mandalorian to become a Jedi he or she would have to give up thei...
Agreed.........in legends
fierce trout
What is this established code
Note that if you then click on legends, it becomes the version of the code that you are referring to
grizzled schooner
😵💫
fierce trout
Perhaps the old ways simply refers to the "old way of doing things" which involved waging war in addition to the code
Or maybe this is just canon continuity being dogshit
grizzled schooner
fierce trout
Common TCW L
tranquil breach
I say the latter in context
If TCW tying halfway into the EU while also trampling over other stuff
I want to know who's bright idea was for TCW Anakin to be a knight immediately after the battle of Geonosis
grizzled schooner
thinking about Mandalorian ideology harder than the show writers
stray crane
guys i really liked this show 🥹
i am so happy
i didn't like the first two episodes and i had lost hope and then i loved the rest of the show
solar yacht
Well that’s good for you
tribal pelican
lean sinew
There is nothing that says the ancient mandalorians craved war or any mention of...
Haven't we had this discussion
lean sinew
All canon Mandos gotta do is wear the armour, protect their family and refuse to...
The helmet thing is not a Mandalorian thing, it is that particular sects things
grizzled schooner
Yeah see there’s a split here
In TCW, the Death Watch is spoken of as traditional mandalorians
The followers of the ancient ways
yet at the same time in the Mandalorian, the Creed is also described as ancient
lean sinew
Dude
grizzled schooner
and how old Mandalorians did things
lean sinew
Mandalorians in canon have been infighting for a very very long time
Obviously there's many different beliefs
I never really bought in to the fact all mandalorians had like an ideal hivemind
Like yeah it makes them badass but idk.. just never worked out in my head
grizzled schooner
Correct me if I’m wrong but the infighting began with the civil war between pacifist and old Mandalorians pre clone wars
not that long before the show started
lean sinew
No
grizzled schooner
at least that’s all that’s been covered
lean sinew
I have quite a few vague memories of them alluding to it happening long before too
It has been a way of Mandalore
This is what satine tried to stop
grizzled schooner
true
lean sinew
Because if they were peaceful then there's no infighting too
grizzled schooner
But is that in reference to war in general or specifically infighting
Either would make sense for Satine to be against
Still, in any case though both TCW and the Mandalorian treat the ancient traditions their Mandalorians follow as having always been adhered to by ancient Mandalorians
tired of the word
mandalorian
There was little, if any mention of dissenting Mandalorian ideology
unless deliberate historical revisionism is going on from both the Children of the Watch and Death Watch
which
I don’t know that the TCW and Mando writers would think about
solar yacht
Lmao
My biggest question is how the hell did nobody, including Ahsoka, realize how strong Sabine is in connection with the Force?
tribal pelican
because she wasnt written to be one back then
solar yacht
So Sabine is a Mary Sue?
tribal pelican
and given she was like, 20 in rebels
if she actually was force sensitive, she probably would've been kidnapped by the jedi already
tribal pelican
So Sabine is a Mary Sue?
she always was
solar yacht
and given she was like, 20 in rebels
if she actually was force sensitive, she p...
So they’re essentially contradicting canon given the fact she surely would have been detected as Force sensitive
tranquil breach
and given she was like, 20 in rebels
if she actually was force sensitive, she p...
She spent over 5 years in rebels alone with Kanan and Ezra. Not even disregarding the MULTIPLE other force users she came across (Maul, inquisitors, DARTH FUCKING VADER, and Ahsoka herself) and none of them said anything themselves at that time
tribal pelican
well the redditors argument as for defense of ahsoka is that "the force resides in all things"
if thats the case, why didnt the jedi train the clones
grizzled schooner
lean sinew
My biggest question is how the hell did nobody, including Ahsoka, realize how st...
Ahsoka did
It's covered
Ahsoka ran from Sabine the first time because she knew that Sabine had potential but if she unlocked it, that she'd do it for the wrong reasons and turn easily
grizzled schooner
dumb
lean sinew
and given she was like, 20 in rebels
if she actually was force sensitive, she p...
jedi
going to Mandalore
To steal a Mandalorian
That'll go swimmingly
Hell why would a Mando even tell the jedi
lean sinew
dumb
No not really, just the force sensitive part
They explored it already when kanan trained her
She was angry
Very angry
tranquil breach
>jedi
>going to Mandalore
>To steal a Mandalorian
Reminder that Sabine probably would've been born on the extremist parts of Concordia or something.
Since her clan were vizla allied
solar yacht
Ahsoka ran from Sabine the first time because she knew that Sabine had potential...
Fair fair yeah I remember that now.
lean sinew
The fact she went from Luke's hoth saber grab to force pushing Ezra that far though...
I'm sorry but that was extremely dumb
solar yacht
Yeah
lean sinew
If literally all she did force wise was the saber, I'd honestly be over it by now
That push was absurd
tranquil breach
Luke could barely lift rocks on Dagobah
lean sinew
Are we really meant to believe Sabine had this the whole time and it was only a mental block?
I don't believe that, and I won't lol
grizzled schooner
gys
tranquil breach
Its incredibly dumb
tranquil breach
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Holocron_Heist
The Chad Bane
grizzled schooner
Made u type normally
guys
lean sinew
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Holocron_Heist
Go on
solar yacht
The fact she went from Luke's hoth saber grab to force pushing Ezra that far tho...
Is this what you mean by the “force sensitivity part” being dumb?
tribal pelican
the link contains those letters
grizzled schooner
Sbn shuld b n th lst
lean sinew
Is this what you mean by the “force sensitivity part” being dumb?
I mean I didn't want her to have the force in anyway except maybe in similar vein as to the Han Solo theory
But the push took it even further
grizzled schooner
the link contains those letters
lean sinew
Sbn shuld b n th lst
You're hurting my ADHD
I'm not exerting effort for your shitposts
vague hullBOT
gay
The /r/StarWarsBattlefront community is a fan-made community that includes Star Wars and Battlefront fans of all nationalities, creeds, identities, and sexualities. The admins and moderators would like to show the LGBTQIA+ community our support, and let them know that they are welcome to be themselves in our server. We encourage all our members to be supportive and considerate towards all other members to make this a welcoming community for everyone.
lean sinew
tranquil breach
Sbn shuld b n th lst
? How much does this matter though?
Would she get yoinked and trained as an inquisitor?
Mando inquistor sounds cold
grizzled schooner
y
lean sinew
Iirc it wasn't, otherwise Cals arc was for fucking nothing
grizzled schooner
Chd bn
tranquil breach
Didn't the holocron blow up with the frigate
grizzled schooner
um
lean sinew
tranquil breach
Oh wait no he still had with him
grizzled schooner
Well yeah but was it successfully stolen?
stray crane
Well that’s good for you
i've noticed you're always positive and respecting of everyone
please never change 🥹
lean sinew
Did Bane get all the data to Palpatine though?
Surely not
lean sinew
i've noticed you're always positive and respecting of everyone
Yes I love sweneh, we bashed a little at the start but bro is modest in all the best ways 
grizzled schooner
proper totem
i've noticed you're always positive and respecting of everyone
Hes the most sane out here
atomic gazelle
tribal pelican
yep its still shit
atomic gazelle
high spire
Anyway multiple Mandalorian Jedi having been confirmed to exist by Huyang, appar...
wym
also you’re talking about ahsoka without taking out letters, you’ve lost your bet
grizzled schooner
No I’m talking about Tarre Viszla
never once mentioned anywhere but Star Wars rebels
fierce trout
grizzled schooner
:3
high spire
you just said “huyang confirmed there are multiple mandalorian jedi” which was in ahsoka
grizzled schooner
Huyang, a character originally from Star Wars: The Clone Wars
fierce trout
lean sinew
Probably gonna find the clip tomorrow, I'm 95% sure about it but I can't seem to find a clip that either doesn't skip it, or exactly which scene it's from
This'll have to do for now, that's definitely the line
See my point about how throwaway it is?
lean sinew
Nope
Huyang straight up mf says it
And everyone just moved on
I have a feeling it's this scene but this YouTube video has too many cuts to tell if they removed it or not
grizzled schooner
n
FUCK
all my talk about Mandalorian Jedi recently has been declared Legends
👍
my bad
lean sinew
@grizzled schooner did you find it
This will probably come up a few times in star wars conversation for a while tbf
grizzled schooner
Ys
lean sinew
W
grizzled schooner
n th nxt scn
grizzled schooner
👎
grizzled schooner
mn f my wrd
lean sinew
grizzled schooner
14 mnts
grizzled schooner
You made a bet for that long..?
1 wk
lean sinew
