#Expand ironworking in africa OR completely debase ironworking from feudalism

25 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

shell jolt
#

Ive made this point before, in a post along with many other issues, but i isolate this one in specific because of just how much it breaks realism and gameplay in thease areas. Right now, ironworking is limited to north and sahelian africa, along with the eastern swahili states and zimbabwe. Nigeria, in fact i believe any state in west africa, besides the muslim ruled ones, they lack feudalism, and ergo ironworking. This is just plain wrong historicly. The peoples of west africa were some of the best blacksmiths and ironworkers of antiquity. And, with the migration of the bantu from southeast nigeria, ironworking would spread across most of the remainder of africa. The game should model this, all of what ive said here. By the start date of EU5, every single organised state on the map of africa should have ironworking. You dont even need to change the faudalism->ironworking problem, just have them start out with ironworking, the rest of that part of the tech tree can stay locked! It is that simple.

shell jolt
#

Id also maybe even give an iron production bonus regional inovation for west and bantu africa, considering how few iron RGOs some regions have, and how much bog iron smelters just suck.

dawn sandal
#

Can you put down some sources for reference, the pdx like that

shell jolt
cold prairie
#

I think that this is a good idea you shouldn’t need to give historical credence for this, the game will never be 100% historically accurate it needs to be fun

dawn sandal
#

I'm just curious

cold prairie
cold prairie
# shell jolt How is this fun?

It’s not that’s the point but it’s historically accurate for nations to do that, currently a lot of Africa is downright unplayable/slogish and unfun

shell jolt
#

True!

#

Ha, but i use this game as a sort of alternate history generator, i dont care about if im winning or all that, id like that realism.

#

I dont understand that half measure. To have some realism, but just as long as its fun? No, thats stupid to me. You can just give up any(?) notion of realism in that case, like civilsation or stellaris. It is all or nothing, for me at least.

shell jolt
# dawn sandal If you got a map that would be epic.

the green is feudalism+legalism, the yellow is just feudalism, and black is no institutions. all of africa (besides maybe a few pockets in southern africa) should have feudalism, or should i say ironworking.

dawn sandal
shell jolt
#

im suprised nobody has made a mod for this yet

#

meybe someone should...

nova sonnet
#

or, direction more accurately

#

you say historiography and i show you the blobhemia and entirely french lowlands, golden horde stable till 1800s

dawn sandal
#

This is why we are here rn

nova sonnet
#

really shouldve been a demo

shell jolt