#End of the Wall

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

charred imp
#
  • Rare (or uncommon?)
  • +1 hand size until end of round if played hand contains exactly 4 scoring cards.

I gotta pitch mahjong themes stuff til I die.
Anyways, picture is showing the "(dead) end of the wall" in mahjong from which you draw a tile when you play 4 of a kind. That's the inspiration.

ivory igloo
#

Fun idea, but I think it would be better if it stuck to 1 effect

charred imp
#

Maybe there's a way to reword it without changing it

#

English is only my second language

ivory igloo
#

That wouldn't change the fact that it's 2 effects

#

I like the 4-related one, 4s could use more synergy

#

Could also be 4oak related since it's based off of 4oak from Mahjong

pulsar light
#

but the joker idea itself is nice

ivory igloo
#

What if it was like this:

End of the Wall (Uncommon/Rare)
Gains +1 Hand Size if played hand contains a Four of a Kind, resets at end of round
(Currently +0 Hand Size)

charred imp
#

this gave me a different idea entirely, gonna edit the og post

#

aaand reworded

charred imp
ivory igloo
#

In your version, does it activate multiple times?

#

Because if so, I think it's a bit strong

charred imp
#

hmm, yeah, yeah, that might be right

#

maybe "until next hand is played"

ivory igloo
#

That might get tricky to keep track of

ivory igloo
charred imp
#

4oak is just a hard to make hand early and an easy to repeat hand later (with good deck fixing)
hmm

#

but you know, you're right about the theme-relation to the initial inspiration (mahjong)
so yeah why not

charred imp
ivory igloo
#

I'll post the first two versions for future reference:

Original: Draw 1 extra card to hand if played hand contains 4 scoring cards, draw 2 extra cards if played hand contains 5 scoring cards

Edit 1: Gains +1 hand size until end of round if played hand contains at least 4 scoring cards

Edit 2: Gains +1 hand size until end of round if played hand contains a Four of a Kind

#

Is that right?

charred imp
#

the edit was "at least 4 scoring cards"
My wording was also a lil different but whatever

ivory igloo
charred imp
#

This makes me think.... would it still be op if it was "+1 hand size until end of round if played hand contains exactly 4 scoring cards"?

ivory igloo
#

I didn't remember the exact wording

charred imp
ivory igloo
#

I think that might be OK as a Rare? I'm not sure, I would need some feedback from others

charred imp
#

yeah, I'm thinking rare, because you can also utilize stone cards (and Four Fingers obviously)

ivory igloo
#

(Idk how I forgot 4 Fingers, we were just talking about it...)

charred imp
#

and I'm thinking this gives two rather rarely used jokers a nice synergy as well as stone cards (so Marble Joker is also more relevant outside of high-card or Stone Joker builds)