As the title says, no matter how many times I reset or what deck I was using, I would get "Handy Tag" on small blind, "Garbage Tag" on big blind, and "Grabber" as my voucher in Ante 1.
I was able to fix this by deleting my settings.jkr file to reset my tutorial status. I was never given the tutorial in the full release of balatro. I assume it got bugged/confused somewhere from left over data from the demo, as I also had some progress/unlocks when I started (I reset my profile to start fresh, as some of friends who played the second demo had their progress reset).
After removing the settings.jkr file in my appdata, and running the game WITHOUT letting steam cloud sync, I was given the tutorial and now I no longer only get "Handy"/"Garbage" as tags and "Grabber" in the initial shop.
May need some better checking around if the tutorial has triggered, or a "reset tutorial" / "skip tutorial" options?