#beta-ptr-spoilers
1 messages · Page 421 of 1
Are you really going to try and toss that
have you no other arguements
OK. let me tell you why that arguement is bullshit.
catfite
Back during Wrath of the Lich King
do you remember what was the number 1 thing the community asked for?
I know why cata came to be
people wanted the whole world to be affected by the events of later expansions
Exactly
People wanted the world to be fluid
and flexible
they didn't want each expansion to be in its own little bubble
little did people realize, that means leaving behind certain things for good
like past expacs
as, at the time, we didn't have the bronze dragon NPCs
it certainly doesn't feel like that anymore, and since TBC and wrath are in bubbles of their own, why force us to go through them when they are outdated and irrelevant
Blizzard gave us what we wanted
Why bother have a leveling experience to begin with by that logic Akr
all leveling is irrelevant
and outdated
except legion and BFA
yeah hes right tbh just delete old expansions the moment a new one comes out
^
pandaria and wod are in bubbles, fuck em
"the moment a new one comes out"
it's been more time since cata came out, than the time between vanilla and cata
1-90 would be a lot more fluid if cata started at 60
no it wouldnt
the difference is that those 2 expacs would still be accessible
just not recommended in the guide
and ignored
which means
no ones going to even know it exists
they'll just skip it and go forward on the path given
You're effectively removing those 2 expansions
so why not just admit that you'd want them removed?
Personally i think we should get another cata esque revamp
for ALL the older expansions
I don't want them removed, I want them out of the leveling experience
Like, new stuff is still happening in northrend
lets see it!
Considering they only exist for 2 things, leveling and farming by people who are aware theye xist
What happened to Outland after Legion?
you remove half of it
and the people who are aware it exists dwindles
You've done what reddit likes to call "Quarantine"
a slow and horrid death.
well all of wow is in a bubble since its a video game
delete the whole thing
people who boost probably don't know outland exists
northrend, possibly, if they get their artifact and are of a certain class & spec
(and getting artifact is probable thanks to annoying, pestering NPC that pops into existence in dalaran)
Well
tbh imo desu ka outland is boring to level through, at least hellfire
but hellfire is all you need to do so you can skip to wratch
well technically you could do boring tundra or howling fjord
but I greatly dislike those zones, even compared to hellfire peninsula
I havent done either in a hot minute
will be quite soon though
So we'll see!
Hellfire will put you in the lvl 73-4 range
Boring Tundra might just be an accurate name though >.>
it really is
yeah, hellfire got me to lvl 601 or so and the game then told me to go to northrend
on that character
you can go to northrend at 58 (boring tundra or howling fjord)
and im like less than 5% through that xpac
see, and I ignored it then
and now its telling me to go to dragonblight
which is enticing
Thats the good part
the zones in Northrend are all just as empty as Boring Tundra; it's just that the landscapes of the rest of them make it more interesting
for example, most have trees and mountains
I feel like every xpac except legion have empty zones
and I guess bfas are kinda compact
Legion just feels so dense though
maybe since I got to it late
Draenor zones are indeed pretty empty, except for Gorgrond and Tanaan Jungle.
it does a good job of masking the emptiness except for Shadowmoon Valley.
Mop has pretty zones
MoP is very pretty, even if I dont like it much i'll give it that
I'd love to take a walk there
maybe with a guard
ye it's pretty and all the zones do well at looking like they aren't empty
haha
legion and bfa zones are legitimately packed tho
BC is supposed to be empty tho
WotLK is too, considering you are in a hostile land
I think world bosses should have a few here and there that are more complex
like, more of a world dungeon or mini raid
in outland, emptiness helps Hellfire Peninsula's atmosphere, Netherstorm cheats because there's a big void throughout it, the rest are good at covering it up
I dont like hellfire
zangar is cool though
and what else
nagrand? and tanaan right?
tanaan = alternate hellfire
i dont even think I can name anything in those zones at all
ah yeah thats wod
whats the
the other one
terrokar
terrokar
blade's edge
not a big fan of blade's edge
It's empty
except for all the spikes
ye it's empty and IIRC it has several quests that have you kill an unreasonable amount of mobs
go get me 50 bear asses!
Terrokar Forest was my favorite WoD zone. Simply because that’s the zone I was in when I dinged 98
you mean talador?
does wowhead have the 3D viewers for any of the transmog from tides of vengeance
not yet
Where is the BElf heritage armor >.<
Not in the game yet
why is ptr updating like once every hour
I'd guess adding new stuff checking if the game still lives and then add more stuff
but idk the exact procedure :- )
Ptr updating is a bug
I recommend setting updates to manual until tomorrow or whenever the next build is pushed
oof
THe new guard armour looks great
cries in blood elf
ehhhhhhhhhhh
Their other set looked much better
can we get a portrait shot @ruby star ? So that we can see their weapons and shield.
Can't tell if they changed or not
I can try, but it keeps crashing, you gotta walk backwards and if you look outside it @hollow dock
@hollow dock This a better shot?
Much better thanks <3
OK so they lost their dual-blades
the HD shields look nice
also, female guards
how progressive
Yeah, it looks great
Did they lose them? the weapons in the datamining stuff seemed to be dual edged
I can look behind her if you want, but game is a 50-50 if it will crash or not, perhaps skybox is causing issues, outside crashes game
You can see a little of the other edge of the weapon on the first picture
No idea if it's the second blade of if it's like the alliance weapons where it has a small dagger at the bottom
let me find da weapon again
They still have dual blades @hollow dock
You just cant see the other blade from the front
Furthest people have got is too the flightmaster
ah ok
its like the game is like "oh no bois, you can't come here yet"
and the players are like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWULCfJ2PGA
PTR still buggy or?
it should be -mostly- fine if you use DX11 but it still crashes in a couple places
It’s a mess overall. It should get better next build
I hope so
time to riot?
dont think burning zuldazar = it burns down forever
especially since its made of gold and brick
two things that generally dont burn well
What if it gets melt
Yeah we don't know how hot Azerite burns
probably going to be burning part of the jungle
because its burning of zuldazar
not dazar'alor
Burning of Zandalar
@ruby star ThE nEW ARmoUr LoOkS gOoD
It mainly means that Silvermoon guards can finally be females as well.
They were all male previously because the shield and spear etc. were all part of the same model, which was male.
Now they're equippable items, given to both male and female NPCS.
@ruby star any idea what's up in SMC? seems to be something near Lor'themar, breaks the game when you get near court of the sun
Silly MindWont, women can’t gaurd. /s
you say /s, but Ive seen unironic posts saying that female guards in stormwind need to be given guns, because they wouldnt be able to guard as well as men with swords
Nani
forums know no bounds
I think the answer to that is a no
Can figure it
I mean even thulm may lose some of his neurones reading certain individuals that come and go in this discord
I mean, I'm prob gonna get hate for this, but objectively speaking, the average man is better suited for physical tasks than the average women
please don't kill me
Now, this is a game, obviously
but the trained guards of a city are not "average" in any way
^
Yeah, wow certainly isn't going for any kind of historical realism
Would women have often been knights or guards in medieval times? No
But would an orc death knight ever even exist?
Anyways, I want to make a kul Tirana and a dark iron character but idk what classes to do for each of them
Not really interested in playing Druid at all tbh despite the cool models kul Tirans get, or shamans for dark iron
Really I think I just need to decide which one to make the hunter and what to do with the other
I think Dark Iron hunter makes more sense than Kul Tiran
honestly, for a Kul Tiran, I've no clue what makes sense (other than a druid of course). a warrior, maybe? lol
I already have a warrior and a monk
And I plan to do a gnome/void elf mage or warlock but not sure which of those will do which class
You do realize that women weren't knights and warriors at the time due to sexism that you're spouting right now right? @native seal @jovial skiff
Is not sexism, is realism
Give me 5 minutes, I'm buying food and I'll explain
No need
You're informed
Women were put to death and tried as witches and pagans for trying to be what men were. It was blatant sexism.See Joan of Arc
Nobody is talking about that
We're no longer talking about anything. It was sexism. It's still sexism.
What I was trying to say is the following
Women are not as physically strong as men, by biology
If you're a guard, you're trying to protect stuff from something
That something doesn't care if you're a man or a woman,and the labor to stop someone, specially in the middle age where no guns are involved, required physical strength
That's why a man was a better guard than a woman. If you want to call it se ism, go ahead
If biology is sexist, then yes lmao
I said middle age if you can read
isn't as strong as those she saved
But yeah, women are not strong as men and that's a fact, blame biology
There's a reason 95% of fireman are men
They're worse than in average yes, because they have less strength and fire gives no fuck about your gender
<@&299347348847329281> can we get this to stop.
Lmao, OK dude, think whatever you want
Yeah cuz this isn’t even the right place for this
I'll stop but I wasn't the one that brought this up
You were the one who brought up the example
Yeah cause he called me sexist outta nowhere and I proved my point
Shouldn't I defend myself?
Two things, one. I was being objective in all my points and using facts.
Now if you want to continue that conversation, you can do so in dms but seeing as this is for the ptr, I’m going to have to ask you to stop
Fine I'll stop, but I don't think we're stopping for the right reasons. Have a nice day
🤔
insert thonk here
banhammer incoming
Right reasons to stop - 1. Wrong channel
- Mod said to stop
That’s the only reasons you need
lots of crashing and glitches
waiting for the belf heritage armor
the usual things that happen in ptrs
I hope the armor is not a robe tho
The armor is going to be a robe
cease
But what if I wear
Plate
nightborne don't care if you wear plate
Nightborne don't judge
Robes dont care if youre plate
Hey anybody know more info on the night elves new customization stuff? If I unlock it how do I apply it? Do you have to make a new character entirely?
I assume nobody knows yet tbh but it's worth asking to me
https://i.imgur.com/iyL39cJ.gifv
Ion on the state of wow
@jovial skiff in every single Wowheadpost that mentions it links to the full scenario
It’s unlocked by completing the Tyrande scenario, which is likely a post-war campaign thing
anything about prot warrior buffs?
They’re a skin option, which you can now change in the barber on any character
literally we have had 1 patch of extremely preliminary changes
we know pretty much nothing about forthcoming class changes
@jovial skiff There are kilts that come down to your feet for paladins so robes can be plate sometimes.
They are supposed to have someeg armor below
@frozen adder yeah, the paladin set from forelands was basically cloth
Do you think Judgement is cloth then?
just cuz its a robe. Ignoring the fact that plate robes exist for Crusaders and Paladins
What?
Yeah
[stares at Lightsworn set from ICC]
It's cool but it's has a ton of cloth
Could easily be a set for a mage too
Especially since the line on cloth and leather and plate seems to blur often
Oh and mail, I forget that one
Not entirely? It's a plate robe.
It being a robe doesn't mean itgoes onto a mage. As seen with the Judgement set, tier 2 I think it is for paladins.
Which was the firstplate robe set.
I didn't say it should be mage because of robe, but because of a lot of cloth and also because mage gear has a lot of extra stuff on it too sometimes
And the fire theme I guess
But nothing on there is cloth. It's all plate. O.o
the only thing that looks like cloth is the chest plate.
which is the robe
I think skylor's point is that plenty of cloth does not look like cloth
which I disagree with
it's only little things on the cloth armor that doesn't look like cloth
not the whole set
we're talking about the firelands paladin tier set. he is claiming it looks like it's mostly cloth and thus fits on a mage
Yes, I think the firelands paladin ties set would fit a mage just fine and I stand by that
Try that set with a different chest piece and then say that
Because if that’s still the case, you might need to get your vision inspected
wat dis
A concept
a koncept
no
you want sneks
go alliance you filthy horde trash
Horde doesn't deserve anything else
I'm already satisfied with what alliance has/is getting
I'm satisifed with horde too, but alliance doesn't deserve sneks
not more than horde
Same, we didn't even need void elves tbh but I'm not complaining
have fun with your furries
No thanks, vulpera can go away
I'd rather get blood trolls than vulpera
But just to spite vris, i'm happy to get more furries
Vris don't like em?
They honestly are really cool. Kiro, etc.
Bloodthirsty little savages
DIdya see this?
Thought it was a neat idea
i can't see things
I don't like it 
Why not
It makes whole point of Tyrande and Night Elves going Night Warrior and fighting to reclaim Darkshore a futile tragic event.
Especially when you consider Tyrande's "I'm going to fight with or without Alliance" was one of best moments of Night Elves post bfa after their unending tragedies
Nope, let's just keep losing!
Imo, anything that knocks tyrande off her high horse is a plus
I never got the appeal of Tyrande but Night Elves need their fistbump moment that can make up for Burning of Teldrasill
dey will have one
Well
Losing to Forsaken is gonna be great moment for Night Warriors
Having a single town in a sea of horde is not gonna go well
And horde can't be losing everything, lol. I am not saying they'll win, but it is possible
Idk about The Horde but the true loser is Sylvanas
Most players I know that main Night Elf gave up on story and some unsubbed, they seemed to hate losing Teldrasill but they'd be ok if it portrayed Night Elves as at least competent but sadly it kinda didn't
And kick in the gut was Night Elves/Tyrande not trying to fight back in 8.0 which actually seems to be coming in 8.1
Night Elves are doing just fine storywise.
What in tarnation are you on
They are getting development and spotlight
Motivation for the war, back to their roots like wc3
Burning of Teldrasill's entire purpose was just to be used for Humans to get motivation to fight and reclaim Lordaeron and it sucks
I wonder if i can paint tyrande as a hypocrite about her and nightborne and teldrassil
With no real retallation
Like
They fought for Lordaeron, but not really for the Night elves
Or did you read a "this be for Teldrassil"?
This'a be for Teldrassil'a
Genn says something like that it's retaliation for Teldrasill in BfL event
It seems that Alliance honestly forgot them, which is why Tyrande talked like that in the datamined text
And that hurts
Exactly. They may have been cast out of their home. But they are getting good development.
Tyrande becoming this vengeful leader
How?
Would you rather them not get anything? e.e Any development is good.
That's not gonna be enjoyable story for Night Elves if they get beaten by Horde again
It doesn't seem like they are going to be beaten
Dawn, we don't know what is happening
Yeah I hope so, they should win Darkshore
That is jumping to conclusions
They should
And maybe will push back again
Maybe
I haven't seen the power of the Night Warrior still
If Tyrande as a night warrior kicks everyone's ass
They its a sure win
Yeah Khamnin I was just explaining why I didn't like that map with Nelves losing everything
You know what's kinda funny
Maybe now Tyrande knows how the Nightborne feel
Nightborne say that Elune's wisdom guided then away eme
Wat
Where's Elune's wisdom now Tyrande?
@zealous basalt Night Warrior should be extremely powerful, it's Warrior side of Elune
Kham
If you didn't put attention
Tyrande calls it on Elune
She starts calling her bullshit
That's my point
I think Elune did to every night elf...maybe in order for they to archieve the night warrior form
idk how gods act
Like...they are all about elune in legion
Tyrande says they will see where Elune's wisdom guided them
-fast forward to now-
Prolly
New blackrock orc
She is in charge of creating Iron Stars apparently
"Whoo! Your iron star made my post shake all the way from the front gates, Uraka!
Uraka smiles.
I knew you'd appreciate my genius eventually.
We gotta make more of them. Hundreds of them... Millions of them... Bomb-billions of them!
Heh. You bring the Azerite, and I'll bring the boom, lil' one.
Deal! That's a binding contract!"
What?
oh shit
iron stars and a goblin
i hope we get iron stars in a warfront or something
or a mount
😛
theyre a part of the incursions
How do you know? @uncut vault

Did I miss something
alliance defense in tiragarde involves the horde using iron stars
Hm, ok.
neat
So
I did some research on Gnolls
Apparently the redridge gnolls are under the service of a warlock who was looking for the scythe of Elune and was reasercging dragons
If he isn't already a black dragon, he may have something to do with a Dragon isles patch
Thus Horde would get Gnolls for after that patch
Where is your source?
Questing in redridge mountains...
The npc never died, and was replaced post cata.
Was it or was that the replacement
Was it
Like anything that happened in those areas just ended there
The scythe was recovered by druids later
And most of the gnolls were killed
Morganth was replaced when cata hit meaning Morganth is still out there.
Nope he teleopts away
"You have done well, <name>. In defeating the warlock Morganth, Stormwind is saved from a grave peril. I offer you this reward most humbly. And I would bid you peace, if these were peaceful times. But instead, I will bid you luck with your trials, and victory in the conflicts ahead."
Doesn't look like so
Deafeated doesn't equal kill
Is a drop from him too so
defeated doesn't equal kill
He tps away and it drops from his minnion
well based on datamined voicelines
zandalari paladins as NPCs for sure is almost certain
as playable, idk maybe
Keep as a reminder that we have no idea what happens to the prelates post recruitment. For now, the Loa at the top is Bwonsamdi.
And unless we're betraying him, well.
well,there are prelates in the raid
so they have to be getting their powers
from SOMEWHERE
not really
Prelates didn't get power from Rezan - he wasn't related to Light at all, they get their holy power from devotion/faith etc
but Rezan's death might've killed their spirit and weakened them but enough to make a raid boss
then why are prelates being regarded "out of the question" with rezan's death
if they dont get their powers from him
o.o
Because only Rezan had prelates and without it, Prelates doesn't have a Loa to revere/devote and wouldn't be able to channel Holy Power
They just need another Loa to revere, doesn't have to be Light related
I'm like 100% sure Zandalari Paladins will be a thing
Rezan is not the only one who had prelates lol
The dialogue with the Prelates of Rezan says "the highest order of holy warriors", meaning there are others. They're simply the most notable
That said, I agree that Zanda Paladins are going to become a thing eventually. Potentially, Voljin could be our new loa. Eyir called him a "Force of Valor" which sounds awful Paladin-esque imo
But there's also An'she, who could potentially imbue them again, and the Sunwell (though that's unlikely since the Belves are suuuuuuuper protective of it)
^ Right? I would 100% be on board with Voljin, Loa of Valor
I mean, I'm gonna be faction changing to a zandalari paladin one way or another, but I'd be doing it with 1000% more gusto for Voljin lol
I don't quite understand why. It's the same paladin stuff. You're just a genocider at that point
¯_(ツ)_/¯
huh?
Yeah Zanda's should get new loa - not anshe or sunwell lol and be their own thing
That's how Horde Paladins should be, each different groups unlike Alliance ones
Unlike? Well technically only 2 (3 I guess with Dark Iron) races are actual "Paladins" nad that's Humans and Dwarves
Draenei are technically Vindicators and function a little differently
They're all clumped under "Silver Hand" though
and Night Elf Paladins seems like they'll be clumped too when they're playable, one arc of Legion Order Hall is dedicated to it
Well technically so are some Blood Knights and Sunwalkers per Legion
Nelf paladins dont exist as their own independant group
so you can't really speak on that
Now if you want to legitimately look at all the paladin groups
There are two sects of the Silver Hand that exist now. Ironforge and Stormwind. The Draenei vindicators are their own independant group.
^
I kinda meant that Zandalari should be their own thing in how they get their power - in their case "devoted to Loa"
And the LF Draenei Paladins are all like Arch-Vindicators
The Order of the Silver Hand that exists right now is the leftovers of the Argent Dawn and Crusade banding together with the other paladin orders like the Sunwalkers, Blood Knights, Vindicators, etc to fight the Legion.
Lorewise they will
gameplay wise
they wont
I think we're all saying the same thing here lol
they never will. cuz that's how the classes work
And all Alliance Paladins get their power from Light in same way afaik
Ehhh not really
Only the humans and Dwarves.
Dwarves/Humans get it via Faith and Conviction
and even then, Dwarf paladins don't technically exist as of Cataclysm
as their own order of people
It's a bit of both spider
the Light is neutral
it does not care what you're doing it for
massacre of a village or crusade against the demons
What makes Draenei Paladin and Human Paladin different
Vindicators wield it as a direct empowerment via the Naaru
if you're righteous and have the faith and vindication, the light answers your call
whcih is why it left Arthas.
they don't have Naaru now though
He lost that faith and conviction.
....
Yes they do Dawn. There are more Naaru out there.
^
Oro wasn't their only Naaru
There's several, quite a few in fact lol
it was just the last descendant of the Prime Naaru
And Vindicators can get their holy power from any Naaru they want from any part of Cosmos?
This is also why Vindicators tend to be more aggressive in their use of the light
Yes. That's how magic works
Since their power doesn't come from faith/conviction but rather as empowerment
Which is also why you see Maarad go angel form in WoD's opening
I miss Maarad
We all miss Maarad
if they didn't fucking cut the content that sacrifice would have made sense
I still think, when they changed the "Judgement" animation for pally, they should've changed it to that light-beam Maarad did with his hammer
originally Yrel was supposed to be the AU of Maarad's wife. The woman holding the child in his warbringers short
That short was awesome
The shorts were epic af
If you listen to that woman, it's Yrel's voice actress too.
No lie, WoD made me love Draenei
WoD shorts were indeed epic
Say what you want about the xpac, but it made me like Draenei
And then Legion came along and gave me Lightforged Draenei 🤤
It angers me that WoD was so gimped
I mean some characters were cool but as a race, it didnt feel that much different than MU ones
they weren't supposed to
just like the Mag'har orcs the horde just got
they are almost no different to the current ones
Idk, I felt the "Draenor" Draenei were a little more bamf than the Exodar ones, personally
They got more fleshed out than the ones on Azeroth
Velen takes no shit in the Rise of the Horde book
VELEN
WoD was a potential good expac
Yeh
it infuriates me the more I think of it
Admittedly, I enjoyed it. I liked Ashran and Tanaan and Ret Paladin felt epic in WoD
And I still had my seals in WoD -_-
And exorcism..
Final Verdict too
seals didnt add much for me tbh
it was just an arbitrary buff I had to keep up
I felt seals were part of the class fantasy. It made us less shiny-arms-warrior and more like a Holy Knight
And they did cool things, and had different uses/utility
I didn't mind the upkeep, also because I've played Ret for over a decade and it was just part of the class
so
not really for me
I used 1 seal and that was it
it was just a buff I had to hit.
...How?
There were at least 2 seals you could've/should've used, especially for dungeons
One gave you more AoE, one was for single target
w/e, personal preference I suppose. I liked it. I liked Blessing of Might too ---
-_-*
Heh, remember back in.... BC I think it was, we had Blessings and GREATER Blessings
Regular Blessing was on one person, Greaters hit the whole raid/party
Oh God yes
Well, raid wide buff were a great change
Won't debate that at all, just remembered it and chuckled to myself
100% raid-wide buffs > singular buffs. I wish I could at least put wisdom on the whole raid
Also someone that gets my share on the Final Verdict
Yuh dude, I loved it. The over-head-smash animation, the DAMAGE
and the "clink"
First time I saw it I was in-love, especially cause I was reppin' the Hammer of the Naaru and getting a "Hammer on the nail" animation made me sooooo happy
The 8.0 verdict is godd
good
better than the legion one
Legion's verdict was just
I've never been a huge fan of TV or the "combo-points" system for us in general
It was a botchy mechanic in Warhammer Online for Warpriests that feels botchy and clunky in WoW too
I like them, like, its a good side resource
So they just finished recording Sylvanas and Jaina's voice lines for 8.1
We'll see in future builds. 😛
Are they both dead? Please say they're both dead
Nah. We already had the text anyway, it was just missing the voice.
Oh
why kill Jaina?
She's annoying and I'm tired of Mary-Sue's dominating WoW
I don't think Jaina is a Mary Sue...
She's not a mary sue hwat
She would be like...the counterpart of a Mary Sue?
She is literally the opposite of a Mary Sue. Yrel is a Mary Sue
^
Jaina's had what. 5 expacs of build up, three books, a comic and an animated short?
A Mary Sue is a character that is as generic as possible
Jaina is the opposite of generic
Jaina is a frost mage who showed up at the perfect moment with a magical ship to magically dispel the poison about to kill the alliance and then knocked down the walls with said magic ship
hwat
She's a deus-ex Mary Sue if there ever was one
she used chemistry HORRORIBLE CHARACTER SHE IS
A Mary Sue can’t be a deus ex machine
in which case
She froze the gas temporarily
the PLAGUE is a deus-ex machina in of itself
^
So Jaina was brought in to counter it. A deus-ex machina to counter a deus-ex machina.
Can't see why are you trying to argue there for a character that stopped a deus ex
Deus ex machina =/= Mary Sue
^
They aren’t even related
A Mary Sue has a boring backstory that could be written by a shitty novelist
Now granted that Mary Sue's also describe characters that are powerful and beloved for no reason.
Jainas backstory is closer to Shakespeare, not in quality, but in type
Which also doesn't fit Jaina as a character for she has a lot of build up over multiple different expansions, books, a comic or two, and an animated short.
A mary sue is someone who has powers convenient for the plot. IE SUperman back in the "golden age" developing a new super power for every circumstance or Batman haviing shark repellent
and also warcraft 3. that happened too.
There’s tragedy, comedie, resolution, impending resolution, internal and external conflict
Jaina still doesn't fit that Spiderdad.
She doesn’t fit that
She's a frost mage, she's always been a frost mage.
She only has two big powers
Chemistry dictates you can freeze a gas into a solid.
Teleport and ice
and the books shows she has all the same abilities a PC frost mage would have
Actually, she moreso incapsulated the gas within ice
Freezing a gas to a solid is very difficult
Freezing the water around it is not
That’s how permafrost works partially
there was no water around the gas. It was simply a gas spread out onto the battlefield that even the Light, a force of the cosmos, couldn't stop
She quite literally displayed exactly what I described with that magical ship she showed up with
Water is in the air
That wasn't a magical ship
Did you not watch Warbringers: Jaina?
The same way dalaran can float
Did
It’s not a magic city
She rose it out of the sea.
It’s magic cast on the city
the same boat she has was the one she floated to Lordaeron.
It’s magic cast on the boat
It’s just a normal boat
She showed up in a cinematic way
that's not a new thing in WoW either. Nor is it something Jaina doesn't have access too.
There’s nothing wrong with cinematic moments
So how is it she developed a new power to combat this scenario?
And ofc she has been prominent, this expansion is focused on her story
She's become Blizzard's alliance golden child with a lot of story focus on her for 2 expacs as well.
The same happened with thrall
Focusing on a character is important to make it easier to create a consistent story
Hope she doesnt turn into blonde jesus or some shit liek that
Horde sort of has a problem on that front since it’s split between several characters
*green jesus
I’m really hoping we just never hear from thrall until his son is an adult in a few expansions
Spider's been typing for a while. can't wait to see it.
No need to be condescending Des, it IS possible to have disagreement without it :P
Her showing up with a power she's never shown before, completely dispelling (not in the sense of the actual spell, but in the sense of REMOVING IT from play) the Horde's trap, to then turn said flying ship on it's side by herself and make it blow a hole in Lordaeron's walls, all BY HERSELF, a level of power that hasn't been seen from Jaina in game, in WC3, or in the shorts, feels like Mary Sue/Deus Ex shit and yes while they are 2 different, separate things, they can both apply at the same time. A Mary Sue can have a Deus Ex and a Deus Ex can be the result of a Mary Sue. For simplicity's sake I'll just call it Plot-Armor.
A group of mages causing Dalaran to float, somethign that required an immense amount of power, doesn't mean any mage cna do it on their own even with Jaina not just being "any mage." Her showing up at the precise moment she's needed: deus ex. Her having the perfect powers and abilities for the exact situation at hand, mary-sue
Same shit goes for Sylvanas' plague, even with it being a failsafe she's had installed in Undercity for a long time. It's obnoxious and bad writing
Then my apologies
Dude, a boat is very small
Now to break apart your argument here.
She is one of the strongest mages on azeroth, and even then we see her struggle
Peach if I may
Compared to a city? Sure, but a galleon is most certainly not small
It's not, BUT. there are certain elements of Jaina you are absolutely ignoring that has happened to her in the course of 5 expansions, three books, a comic or two and an animated short.
So if I may, I have a lot to type and bring up.
Yep. Took 8 mages to teleport a whole city and they were exhausted afterwards
I'm hardpressed to say whether or not the books count. Canonically sure, but for those of us who haven't read them we only have whats in game and the shorts on youtube
Now first up: Floating a galleon. A galleon that is empty. It does not have its own canons, it does not have other people on board, it is just a large pile of wood and bolts. While a galleon is HUGE and HEAVY, it's significantly lighter when there's several tons of supplies not on it.
What city? Stormwind or Dalaran? Cause Dalaran isn't that big
Second: Jaina is not your average mage. This can't be stressed enough. Jaina has Antonidas' staff, yes Archmage Antonidas the mage that faced down Arthas and the scourge, shielded the city of dalaran before it fell etc. Every mages staff carries their essence and powers within it as it's their focus. A larger focus means that you get to channel more power and ability through it.
Another thing is that Aegwynn gave Jaina a portion of her power. Aegwynn. The Guardian of Azeroth. Medivh's mother. She has guardian power within her.
A third thing is that she has the remnants of Aman'thul within her staff thanks to the Pandaria campaign against Lei Shen. She absorbed Lei Shen's storm machine essence, which Keeper Ra'den used to store Aman'thul's essence he got from when the Pantheon perished to the Mad Titan and Lei Shen stole.
Also Dalaran is A LOT LARGER than you give it credit
cuz. everything is shrunk down in WoW itself
Now her showing up at the last minute was done more so for cinematic effect and the whole "Second Wind" aspect
much like Gandalf coming in at the last moment to Hell's Gate
It's meant to be an inspiring moment for the defenders to charge back down.
Could it be done better? yea probably.
Blizz has only really started doing this cinematic story telling en mass very recently
so it's certainly going to be rough around the edges.
Now there is another aspect of all this to focus on: Neither side can win this conflict.
Fair enough. It's still a deus ex and like you said could have been done a lot better. There are ways of telling things like that that make them significantly less "plot-armory." I'll retract my claim of her being a mary-sue, I was wrong there. But I standby the Deus ex bit.
Oh absolutely.
And Gandalf showing up was the same lol
Indeed it was.
It being a deus-ex machina isn't necessarily a bad thing though.
and still hold that having tropes, cliche's etc
Personally, I thought the same about Alleria and Mechatorque. They could've implemented it better than just "oh thank god you arrived just in the nick of time!"
aren't bad inherently
just they're bad when handled bad.
I'd be less annoyed if, at the release of the plague and Jaina had already been there fighting along side them, Anduin called to her for help. Her showing up with perfect timing made it a DE. Then the same inside Lordaeron if, when they were surrounded and Lorthemar was taunting them, Genn/Anduin shouted "Mechatorque, NOW!" or somethign like that
Implementing it as a strategy of a well-prepared Siege makes it more believable and makes it feel less like Blizzard is giving the Alliance plot armor and DE saves
Also makes it better writing
Indeed. but as I said, theyve only started doing this indepth scenario writing as their main storytelling very recently.
Which was Legion.
They had it in WoD and MoP too, didn't they?
I seem to recall a few of these in WoD
Not to the size Legion and BFA had.
Fair enough
There's a lot more to do in both of these expacs and because of that, there's more workload to get through.
So things end up being less refined, is my thinking.
Another thing is this: Neither side can win this faction.
So the writers are pretty much fucked by all ways.
True
How do you write a conflict that neither side can win but make people care about it?
Rhetorical is that question, but it makes you wonder.
You make it not about the factions, which people don't seem to like. It would behoove them, in my opinion, to set it up so that the Horde and Alliance are more like America and Britain. Tentative allies that have fought in the past, are willing to fight again, but have a peace with some rogue-exceptions and are separate.
Well that's what we had in Vanilla to Wrath.
But now, how do you hold all of that with characters that want to push for all out war no matter what?
and as this is only 1 plot point out of WoW's 20 or so, you'd have tp balance it out with everything else.
With all of that in sight, I can excuse some of the lighter things like Jaina or Sylvanas' deus ex machinas but will not excuse character assassinations like the Mag'har scenario
Meaning? Are you talking about Yrel going from Paladin to spanish-inquisition zealot?
Hell no that would need more explaining
what Im talking about is a bronze dragon willingly helping the horde break their own rules
and how Ettrig somehow has a part of Garroshs' hour glass
Oh yeah lol
Also another thing to note is that Yrel in there was trying for peace.
but Grom wasn't having it.
and with Orcs beign Orcs
when they get zealous, they get violent
cuz otherwise, I do not think yrel would actively try and kill Durotan.
inb4 garrosh did
Seemed the other way around from what I recall. Yrel was being zealous and both were trying for Peace, but Yrel was saying "my way or death" and the orcs didn't want to kowtow or fall in line
Uh no she didn't.
O.o
Unless the dialogue was changed, Yrel's words to Grom was "Very well. We'll do it your way." after handing him a last chance.
Is this discussion about the Mag’har recruitment scenario or something else?
The mood felt that way. And I think blizz was doing that on purpose as a "flip" of the original universe draenor where the fel drove them from draenor
Yrel wanted to bring everyone to the light, possibly because the Prime Naaru that fell down onto Draenor was getting her to, but she was doing it peacefully. until the orcs decided to ya know
go insane
as orcs do when given godly magic
It's a nice flip on Ghoulish Daniel's fel horde going insane and converting orcs into fel orcs
If y’all are talking about the Mag’har recruitment scenario story, then yeah, Yrel is a bad guy.
We just discussed how she wasn't but sure.
I mean in my opinion she comes across as a bad guy, and I don’t see anything in your discussion that changes my opinion.
Alright
Did you read the book?
enjoy thinking that.
Like
¯_(ツ)_/¯
A small book in that scenario?
clearly they hadn't
Because that's where it says how Yrel was doing everything peacefully
Alright I’ll leave sorry for having an opinion
Until some of the lightbound orcs started forcing
hwat
I said enjoy thinking it
What's the reason for being so passive aggressive @gilded drum
I don’t know I just felt like I was trying to bring up my opinion and it got shot down right out of the gate. Also no, I didn’t read the book in the scenario.
I certainly didn't shoot it down
And I think it’s much more interesting to have Yrel be an overzealous leader forcing people to follow the light, or killing them
I mean.
Rather than it being “oh look at those orcs! Being evil again!”
It'd be character assassination
in the tenth degree
Orcs are a savage people. Always are and always will be
I don’t doubt that
And a lot of time passed since we left AU Draenor, shit could have changed.
That shit being the Naaru
It did.
A prime naaru landed and created Lightforged draenei leading their own army of the light
Yrel isn't Velen
for what reason we are still unknown for.
She didn't know what Velen told us in Argus about the sides of the light
Anyways I do actually have to go now, got to drive to work.
Like, she is unaware that Light can be used for evil things
but all of that doesn't mean Yrel is suddenly going to be happy to go commit genocide
Des you got this story wrong
The reason the orcs are resisting is because Yrel is forcibly converting them
So then did they change the dialogue or not?
She said join me, they said no thanks
The part where she says we will do it your way is at the end of the scenario
She says they can join willingly, or be forced
So the maghar flee with us
alright great it's character assassination.
So suddenly she's OK with doing what the Iron Horde AND Legion did
How is that explained
How are they trapped
let him talk
But one day Yrel goes to talk with the naaru and they tell her something different - the orcs are inherently bad and need to be converted or they will eat away at draenor until it dies along with the Draenei
This isn’t completely wrong
so no prime naaru crash landed onto Draenor?
OK SO the answer to my question was Yes. they did change up a lot of stuff
What part of let him finish can't you understand
So Yrel begins offering orcs a path to the light - join us so that the world can be saved
Some orcs join, but part of lightforging means they aren’t quite themselves anymore
Orcs like their individuality, and this scares them
They begin to refuse, and at this point, Yrel becomes similar to turalyon
She sees only one future - the one presented by the light
There is no other path
She is told to convert them by force if necessary to save the light and the world
Ofc the light only sees a future of complete order, so while it might not actually be accurate, she is convinced into believing this is the only way
As she coverts the orcs by force, the clans join together to try and save themselves
The Draenei continue to slowly pick them off
By the time we arrive, all of the remaining unconverted orcs are in gorgrond
Draining all of its resources to defend themselves, thus affirming the visions of the naaru that Yrel has been receiving
These are savages who will destroy the world to save themselves, they are dangerous
Again, like with turalyon, it’s partially correct
But the light makes her believe that it’s fully correct
It pushes her to make, unfortunately, bad decisions
This is where we arrive
There is a final stand
Yrel offers a choice
Join us by choice, by force, or die resisting
I already had my question answered. that yes. they changed a lot from the beta we datamined out.
Gromm lantressor and a few others stay behind in order to defend the rest as they flee with us
This is exactly the same as what was datamined
Nothing changed
No?
We just didn’t know the order
Beta datamined that the HONORBOUND did the converting after yrel PEACEFULLY converted some orcs
and that they killed Durotan up in Frostfire Ridge
Totally changed
ALL without implementing Yrel
They never once said Yrel did any of this
Lightbound did bad things
Yrel led them
Because she was lightforged and brainwashed by a naaru
And it was unknown if she was against this, but it had already happened so what the hell is she going to do about it, and just went forward with it
but I guess they tossed out all the potential complexity and just said "Yea no she's just OK with genocide now."
The point of the scenario is mainly further emphasizing that pure order is just as bad as pure chaos
She isn’t genociding
She doesn’t kill them
Most of the orcs are captured and converted to lightbound
For all we know that might be grommashs fate
she's OK with doing what the Iron Horde and Legion did
By a being that is so good it’s evil
and she just ignores it
She doesn’t see it
cuz plot needs her to
She is brainwashed
Leading up she's brainwashed all the way through?
just first time she's brainwashed and no longer yrel
When she is lightforged she is brainwashed
She was a good ally until she was lightforged
Yes
The naaru are the true bad Guys in the scenario
It’s the same thing we saw with illidan and argus
And xera
The naaru are beings of order
Pure order means no free will
No choice
No differences
Pure order is equally evil when compared to pure chaos
Well, it doesnt help that in that universe there isn't chaos anymore as the Legion got defeated, or well, at least in argus
draenor*
it's defeated everywhere Mak
No chaos means order is outweighing chaos
Legion is in all timelines
so there's no legion to fight in the Alternate Universe that draenor sits in
^
I was talking about other risks out there like void
Is blizzard taking some inspiration from The Shivering isles expansion of Oblivion?
The naaru want to order the universe
Because it seems that all is light with no void
void still exists
There is no void on alternate draenor because it exists in a bubble
but there's no void presence on Draenor
It could get there theoretically
again peach Blizz did say there's an AU azeroth
I know
the void was there
It exists
when we went there.
But seems to be separated somehow
But it isn’t attached to draenor
There was with the Shadowmoon Orcs.
it's the one paired with Draenor
Alt draenor was kind of moved into a bubble
the orcs on AU draenor were to invade AU Azeroth.
Because the artifact paired it to our azeroth
So basically it made a time bubble just for us?
Kind of
Like "borrowed" AU draenor?
It went back when we closed t
I suppose we were the anchors
They might not be trapped
I think I misspoke
I more so meant that they aren’t going to leave until they bring order to draenor as the naaru directed
I misspoke and I apologize for that
Which was another thing changed from the beta. Cuz a prime was supposed to have landed and that's what started up the whole "We have to get the band back together." thing.
First Draenor